DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Designing Women: Season Three
Designing Women: Season Three
Shout Factory // Unrated // March 2, 2010
List Price: $44.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Cameron McGaughy | posted April 3, 2010 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
"Everyone knows you can be Miss Maine or Miss Vermont and still be a dog as long as you can play a musical instrument or something. But you never see a homely Miss Mississippi!"
- Suzanne

The Series
Fearing that Charlene has been brainwashed by a cult of perky salesladies, Julia is trying to talk some sense into her friend, who has morphed into an irrational drone who robotically recites her new employer's mantra:

"Charlene, I don't want to hear anymore about this Lady June person! First of all, anybody who would call themselves by that name must have a serious problem. And secondly, who the heck is she, anyway?"

"Well, she's the founder of our company! She's our mentor and teacher and best friend for life!"

"I know that, Charlene...I mean, who is she to form this little cult of Stepford wives?"

"...did y'all see that movie?! That was a good movie!"

And that, my friends, is why I love Designing Women. All it takes is a little sidetrack from the lovable yet easily distracted Charlene to get me smiling (you can take the girl out of Poplar Bluff, but you can't take Poplar Bluff out of the girl). And as the sitcom's third season played out, the cast and crew were in a comfortable groove that had the women as smart and sassy as ever.

Not much has changed at Atlanta's Sugarbaker & Associates--the weight gain controversy and dismissal of Delta Burke was still two seasons away, with the resulting cast changes and drop in quality soon to follow. No, this is still comfort food viewing--with a lot of intelligence in its scripts and passion in its performances, Designing Women was not only mature for its time, it's mature by today's primetime television standards. Sure it has was some might view as a liberal slant (something I might argue with, at least in these earlier seasons), and some of the scenarios are a stretch--most of them created to set up Julia Sugarbaker (Dixie Carter) for a fiery speech. But you have to love a series that has a stance, gives divergent views a voice, knows how to make us laugh and isn't afraid to make fun of itself.

By now, the personalities of the four leading ladies have been sharply defined, and the cast runs with it. Julia is still "The Terminator" and proud of it ("I know I can be sanctimonious and self-righteous"), making her rare breaks from character all the more enjoyable (and her big glasses are back, too!); the sometimes-insensitive Suzanne (Burke) still draws most of her life lessons from her days on the pageant circuit--and still manages to be sweet and insulting at the same time ("Suzanne! Must you always do that? Treat Anthony as if he's the eunuch of the harem?"); the imaginative Charlene Frazier (Jean Smart) is still prone to stream-of-consciousness sidetracks filled with pop culture adoration; while Mary Jo (Annie Potts) remains the show's most "normal" character (and for my tastes the least fun one), a nervous wreck whose lack of confidence and huffy, dorm-slamming tirade entrances dominate her frequently whiny screen time (but as the frequent voice of reason, you still gotta love and root for her).

Also returning for the ride this year are put-upon delivery man Anthony (Meshach Taylor), once again drawn into the ladies' wacky adventures (and a frequent target of Suzanne's stupidity: "Charlene, we just can't go rushing off into the night driving through the dark Georgia woods with Anthony...it just would not look right!"); and Bernice (Alice Ghostley), their scatterbrained and kooky elderly sidekick ("I think Bernice is a little ling on dry wall and a little short on studs..."). They team up for a few memorable moments, and Anthony's venture into drag (and frequent outcries of "Some white woman!") enlivens the already funny "Wilderness Experience".

The designing men also make a few appearances throughout the season: Julia's beau Reese (Carter's real-life companion Hal Holbrook, who also directs an episode this season) gets minimal time; Mary Jo's boyfriend J.D. (Smart's real-life companion Richard Gilliland) gets more juicy script time, but is oddly "dumped" via dialogue in Episode 17 (an odd move considering episode 16 focuses on his relationship with Mary Jo); while Air Force captain Bill Stillfield (Douglas Barr) gets the most time, his solid relationship with Charlene building to their wedding in Episode 18 (they remain one of television's best couples ever).

Along the way, Season 3 offers a lot of memorable episodes (in addition to the aforementioned "The Junies", one of my favorites) that play to the show's strengths. Julia's politics and passion are ignited the most in Episode 2, where she runs for a seat on the local board of commissioners (primarily to combat the controversial views of the conservative opposition); and in the season finale, where a risqué advertisement has her starting a crusade against smut ("Pornography is not free speech...it's commerce."). Both episodes offer some rousing speeches--not all of which I agree with, but you have to love their conviction (the cathartic end of Episode 2 is one of my favorites). But the show also proves it can step away from its comfort zone and still be hysterical when mining more conventional sitcom material--Mary Jo's desire for bigger boobs in Episode 5 is a hoot, and also refreshing considering Julia doesn't react the way you might expect.

Another silly set-up (involving Suzanne's pet pig and a gun) invigorates "Full Moon", an episode that also gives Julia some gun control fodder (and features a hysterical "subliminal message" gag used to great effect); while the late, great Wendy Jo Sperber (Bosom Buddies) and some suggestive photos pep up "The Women of Atlanta" (Julia + pearls = funny). Charlene's attempt to impress Bill's upper-crusty family in "The Engagement" is also amusing ("She said, 'Tell me Charlene, do you have a habit?' And I said, 'No, I'm just nervous.'"); it reminded me of one of my favorite episodes of Friends, where Lisa Kudrow goes through the exact same nightmare (in an odd coincidence, both episodes feature a character named Phoebe, played here by Anne Haney--another late and great industry veteran). Also look for Carter's real-life daughters Ginna and Mary Dixie, who play the nieces (and hysterical younger versions of) Julia and Suzanne in "The Naked Truth".

There are a few misfires along the way--the worst episode by far is (sadly) the wedding episode, an empty effort that feels like a clip show even though it isn't; and Mary Jo's reaction to J.D.'s unemployment goes a little too far in "Mr. Meal Ticket", where you'll be annoyed with her immaturity. I also wasn't too enamored with the circus on display in "The Last Humorously-Dressed Bellboy in America", where Suzanne tries to get even with a man who wronged her; and the firm's encounter with a cat in "Mr. Bailey" turns what should have been a small subplot into the main course. As for the season opener, it's fun--but isn't quite as fantastic as the Season 2 finale, which also brought together all the couples for a weekend getaway that turns into a battle of the sexes. (I could also do without the show's continued annoying habit of inserting jarring bits of sappy music to suddenly signify "important" scenes, which would be far more meaningful and effective with a silent soundtrack.)

But even the weaker episodes are still packed with amusing exchanges and memorable scenes, and as a whole this season keeps the series flying high. If you've read my reviews of Season 1 and Season 2, you know why I love these characters and why the show ticks. That all still applies here, so I thought I'd let their own words speak for themselves--and how entertaining Designing Women is. I hope you enjoy them as much as I do:

"I think you're just one of those people who's...too much. Julia and Charlene and Mary Jo would never tell you so; they're too nice. But I can tell you because...I'm too much, too. I mean, your smile is too big, your heart is too big and quite frankly, your breasts are too big."
- Suzanne

"'Tiny Bubbles'?! Suzanne, Don King does not sing 'Tiny Bubble's...that's Don Ho! She just does it to drive me insane. It's like we're the Smothers' Brothers, and she's Tommy and I'm Dick."
- Charlene

"Who would have thought of homemade food in a gas station? Is that just in the South or what? I mean, now you can go in, get your tires checked, buy some birth control in the bathroom and have a little turkey and dressing on your way out."
- Mary Jo

"A training bra? You little people have to train yours, and you call us dumb!"
- Suzanne "The Citizens' Coalition feels that you have the best chance of making him look bad, because you're just the kind of woman he hates. No offense, but what they don't know--and what kind of has me concerned--is that before you can make him mad, he'll make you mad. And then you'll go off on one of your machine gun, hellfire-and-brimstone diatribes, the whole podium will go up in flames and we'll have to run up and drag you off the stage, and then people will begin to think that you're just a big-mouthed, man-busting, liberal nutcase."
- Anthony

"You know, I've been included in a lot of groups in my life, but I must say, this 'little breasts' category is--for me--a first."
- Julia

"I don't believe in bisexuals. I figure the rest of us have to choose, so why shouldn't they?" - Suzanne

"You know Charlene, I get a little tired of you berating me just because I do not know the same people you do. And for your information, I can name a lot of Eddies! I can name Eddie Fisher, Eddie Cantor, I can even name Eddie Amin! But I'm sorry, I do not know Eddie Haskell!"
"Eddie Amin?! Suzanne, are you serious? His name's Idi, not Eddie!"
"Oh yeah, right...he's a man and his parents named him Edie!"

"No Suzanne, we do not think that is silly--the idea of a nice, college homecoming queen ceremony where you yourself would be rooting for a 30-year-old black man seems not only logical, but very dignified."
- Julia

"I've never seen such a tidy room for a man who wasn't unnaturally close to his mother..."
- Suzanne

"I realize that different people have different definitions of what is obscene. I myself may not be able to define pornography, but I know it when I run over it."
- Julia

"I can tell when a man's interested in me...I have a sixth sense. Danny only has four! That's just too weird for me..."
- Suzanne

"Oh for Pete's sake. Every time you two get a little cranky you start going on these man-bashing jags, you know? 'Men are the cause of all trouble in the world!', 'Men invented high heels and cheap pantyhose!' I bet you next thing you know, you'll be accusing them of that whatchamacallit...that, uh...PMS envy!"
"PMS envy? I swear, someone from the Geraldo Rivera show ought to follow you around with a tape recorder."
- Suzanne and Mary Jo

"None of the women in my family perspire!"
- Suzanne

Suzanne: "Let me get this straight...he's never had a girlfriend, he knits sweaters and he works at a beauty shop? Well, I don't mean to get personal Charlene, but has it ever occurred to you that maybe Odell is involved in some homosexual activity?"
Charlene: "Suzanne! Just cause a person is sensitive and artistic doesn't mean he's gay...not that that would matter to me anyway."
Julia: "Well, I think he sounds like an interesting and talented young man!"
Suzanne: "I think he sounds like a woman..."

"Charlene, the man publishes a porno magazine...he's gonna be susceptible to an incredibly sexy woman--and I'm gonna give it to him with both barrels!"
- Suzanne

"Anthony, isn't it true that if a man gets kicked down there, he is debilitated, right?"
"Suzanne, I would be debilitated if I just saw another man get kicked down there."

"Isn't it amazing how specific these magazines are? I mean, there is something for everybody! There's one out there all about feet! I mean, can you believe that?! I've never seen anything like it in my life. I mean, if a person liked that they could just get a Kenny's catalog and have a real good time!"
- Charlene

Episode Guide:
The 22 episodes (about 23 minutes each) are spread across four discs:

1. Reservations for 12, Plus Ursula (aired 11-14-1988) A voluptuous au pair stirs up friction between the men and the women during a vacation to the beach.
2. The Candidate (aired 11-21-1988) A politician's conservative, sexist position riles Julia, who runs against him for a seat on the local board of directors.
3. E.P., Phone Home (aired 11-28-1988) Excited about "The King's" birthday, Charlene invites the ladies to visit Graceland, where they run into a plethora of Elvis nuts.
4. Getting Married and Eating Dirt (aired 12-5-1988) Julia takes on a New York newspaper that claims Southerners eat dirt, and it's news to everybody that Bernice is getting married.
5. Big Has and Little Falsie (aired 12-12-1988) Mary Jo contemplates breast enlargement when she receives an inheritance--with the stipulation that she must spend it on something frivolous.
6. Hard Hats and Lovers (aired 12-19-1988) Frustrated with loud-mouthed construction workers, the ladies decide to do something about the harassment. Charlene encourages Bill to date other women.

7. Curtains (aired 1-2-1989) As a textile company's biggest client, Sugarbaker's is targeted for protests by striking laborers. Mary Jo has trouble getting her car repaired.
8. The Wilderness Experience (aired 1-9-1989) The women attend a wilderness survival weekend designede to build leadership. Julia bumps heads with a tough New Yorker while Bernice takes command.
9. Tyrone (aired 1-16-1989) Anthony introduces his surrogate little brother to the ladies. After Julia hires him to work part-time with Anthony, everyone is a little hurt when he betrays their trust.
10. Mr. Bailey (aired 1-23-1989) A recently deceased client leaves millions to her pet, and the women find themselves working for a cat.
11. The Naked Truth (aired 2-13-1989) The Sugarbaker firm accepts a job to redecorate a nudist colony. Julia and Suzanne's nieces visit.

12. The Junies (aired 2-20-1989) Charlene takes on a part-time job selling Lady June cleaning products
13. One Sees, the Other Doesn't (aired 2-27-1989) A blind client becomes interested in Suzanne.
14. Odell (aired 3-6-1989) Charlene's brother asks her to help him elope. Anthony agrees to dance with Bernice in a contest.
15. Full Moon (aired 3-13-1989) Julia moons Atlanta's elite in a fashion show. Mary Jo becomes convinced Claudia is going to have sex.
16. Mr. Meal Ticket (aired 3-20-1989) Mary Jo kicks J.D. out after he loses his job.
17. The Engagement (aired 3-27-1989) Charlene's excitement about her engagement degrades when she meets Bill's old-money mother. Mary Jo decides to re-enter the dating world.

18. Come On and Marry Me, Bill (aired 4-10-1989) Charlene's wedding hits a bump when she finds Bill handcuffed to an exotic dancer.
19. The Women of Atlanta (aired 5-1-1989) A photographer shooting a magazine spread asks the decorators to participate, but they become suspicious wen he keeps encouraging sexier poses.
20. Stand and Fight (aired 5-8-1989) The Sugarbaker women take a self-defense class after Mary Jo is traumatized by being mugged.
21. The Last Humorously-Dressed Bellboy in America (aired 5-15-1989) Suzanne discovers the accountant who took off with her life savings working as a bellboy and pianist in Atlanta.
22. Julia Drives Over the First Amendment (aired 5-22-1989) Julia faces a lawsuit when she knocks down an offensive advertisement selling pornographic magazines.

The DVD

Video:
As with the previous season sets, this one full-frame presentation shows its age. A lack of sharpness and detail, along with plenty of dirt and grain and some edge bleeding, keeps this from impressing. Still, this doesn't keep me from recommending the set at all--these episodes are perfectly watchable and enjoyable.

Audio:
The 2.0 track is also average, but I never had an issue understanding dialogue, so can forgive a little balance issues and minor white noise at higher levels.

Extras:
Like the Season 2 set, this collection just has trailers for other Shout releases.

Final Thoughts:
The southern belles at Sugarbaker & Associates have hit their stride in the third season of Designing Women, another outstanding effort that combines intelligence and insanity with smart scripts and passionate performances. You have to appreciate a show that isn't afraid to take a stance and speak its mind--and the fact that it can be funny while doing it is impressive. Always fair, always open-minded and never afraid to make fun of itself, these women not only stood out in 1989, they stand out today. This season is pure comfort food viewing, and comes Highly Recommended.

Popular Reviews
1. Nightbreed: The Director's Cut
2. Pee-wee's Playhouse: The Complete Series
3. Snowpiercer
4. Mad Men: the Final Season-Part 1
5. Nekromantik
6. 24: Live Another Day
7. Gone With the Wind: 75th Anniversary Edition
8. Medical Center: The Complete Fifth Season (Warner Archive Collection)
9. The Vanishing
10. The Purge: Anarchy


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use