DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Special Offer

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Timer
Phase 4 // R // June 22, 2010
List Price: $29.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Tyler Foster | posted July 11, 2010 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
DVD Talk Collector Series
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly
I could be exaggerating, but it might have been as many as four years ago that I stumbled upon the teaser trailer for Timer on YouTube by accident. The hook: in the not-too-distant future, people have wrist-implanted countdown clocks indicating the moment they'll meet their true love. It's one of those movie gimmicks that could easily turn out terribly, but it stuck in my head for just long enough that when Timer showed up on the DVDTalk request list this year, I remembered what it was and snagged it.

As it turns out, the Timer process is more complicated than it looks in that initial teaser. My assumption was that people were given Timers at birth, but it turns out it's a voluntary process, and if your soulmate doesn't have one, your Timer will be blank until that person takes the plunge. Oona (Emma Caulfield) is one of those people hounded by a blank readout; time after time she brings unadorned guys to the Timer store to get injected, and time after time, her numbers don't come up. Her situation bonds her with her sister Steph (Michelle Borth), whose Timer is ticking towards a date many years in the future, but leaves her emotionally cold to the average stranger, who already has a date saved for someone else. Oona drifts along, cosmically anxious, until her 15-year-old brother finally gets his Timer, and his big moment is 3 days away. It's the straw that breaks the camel's back, and Oona finally throws caution to the wind, targeting 22-year-old Mikey (John Patrick Amedori), a grocery store clerk who flirts with her despite a deadline 4 months away. Until then, there's no reason the two can't have a bit of fun, but as the date begins to loom, the burden is on Oona to switch off.

I've seen a fair share of romantic comedies. As a guy, my taste in these kinds of films tends toward the male-centric (a part of the genre that John Cusack has cornered with High Fidelity, Grosse Pointe Blank and Better Off Dead), but it wasn't until I saw Timer that I realized how oddly unfeminine the average romantic comedy is. At one point, for whatever reason, I wanted to vent against the kind of crap Hollywood was producing, so I suffered through the shockingly misogynstic (nay, misanthropic) Katherine Heigl/Gerard Butler disaster The Ugly Truth and wrote a fairly hateful DVDTalk review that never ran, because the site didn't get a DVD screener. That movie, to summarize that write-up, doesn't have a clue about men or women, but the thing that seems more interesting upon reflection is that it doesn't even feel like it comes from a woman's perspective, despite a script by three of them. Fellow Online Film Critics Society member MaryAnn Johanson has been railing against "the male gaze" lately, which is the way a movie assumes, through its depiction of events and people, that the viewer is male. It's not that The Ugly Truth represents "the male gaze", but it feels like it represents nobody.

Timer was written and directed by a woman named Jac Schaeffer, and it has a refreshingly feminine perspective on things that really imbues the movie with personality and attitude. The central bond in Timer is not necessarily the one between Oona and Mikey, but the one between Oona and Steph, with constant support from JoBeth Williams as their mother. Given how authentic these relationships feel, it's no surprise to learn that a good portion of the screenplay is Schaeffer tweaking her own experiences to fit her film's science-fiction premise, which she does with a strong sense of perspective and self-awareness rather than exaggeration and self-deprecation. All too often, I see films where the writer/director has obviously turned their experiences into fodder for the film without trying to observe what happened from a perspective other than their own, but Schaeffer is careful to illustrate both sides of the picture, without giving too much credence to "herself" in the Oona character.

Caulfield is wonderfully charming as Oona, giving her the kind of resilience a character like this needs. Timer could be a big pity party for Oona, in which she comes off as needy and sad, but she has an ability to bounce back that makes her likable instead. She also claims her sexuality instead of letting the opportunity find her, striding back into Mikey's grocery store after rebuffing his earlier attempts to draw her out of her shell. She and Amedori (who exists somewhere between Patrick Fugit and Paul Dano) have great chemistry together, in both the high and low points, and none of their passion feels pre-concieved the way most of these things do. I've gotten so tired of seeing budding romances in movies (most of the time in movies where it isn't a given, like action films), but Timer's energized me, made me care for Oona and Mikey as a couple.

Of course, Timer has a slight conundrum at its core: there are only so many outcomes to this story that could hit all the right bases, and they start to bubble up in the viewer's mind long before the film is over. I was unsure, despite my admiration for the film, that Schaeffer could stick the landing, finding a that balance between the logical and unexpected that would also avoid crushing Oona's fighting spirit or the movie's romantic atmosphere. Maybe it's not perfect, but it's relieving to say that Timer manages to slip by, cleverly juggling all the pieces in a way that makes sleeping in seem like fate. I may not be the target audience for these kinds of films, but Timer is an immensely enjoyable triumph that actually has a voice, and I think anyone who swallows contrived crap like Killers or The Bounty Hunter as cinematic comfort food should consider that a "chick flick" can be more than mindless junk food, and give Timer a shot.

Bold, clean packaging clearly illustrate the movie's concept without any bad photoshop. The back cover may be just a little too basic, but all in all, I don't have any complaints about the design here. The disc is packed into an Infiniti case, and no insert is included.

The Video and Audio
Timer is blessed with one of the best-looking standard-definition transfers I've seen as of late, with strong colors and contrast, and only the lightest hint of softness, most visible during the opening credits. I think the only pattern I saw the DVD struggle with is a very close pinstripe pattern on Desmond Harrington's shirt. Obviously, a movie like Timer is going for naturalism, so it doesn't necessarily leap off the screen or sear itself into the viewer's eyeballs, but it looks very good.

Dolby Digital 5.1 is bouncy and well-mixed, especially when it comes to Andrew Kaiser's wonderful, Huckabees/Me and You and Everyone We Know-esque score (a true highlight of the film). All too often, when it comes to low-budget independent films, the mixing feels sparse or cheap, but even without a whole lot of stuff going on in the soundscape, Timer has the appropriate handful of heft for its subject matter. On the other hand, I'm disappointed by a lack of any subtitles on the disc. Closed captioning is provided, but there really ought to be tracks on the disc itself, as I've never gotten TV-generated captions to work on an HDTV (only old tube TVs).

The Extras
For some weird reason, five deleted scenes (0:31, 0:43, 0:37, 2:47, 0:53) are accessible straight off the main menu. The fourth and longest scene, involving a recurring gag about telemarketers, might've been a nice inclusion, but otherwise, these are unnecessary. I also have to mention that the lack of a "Play All" option is always a mistake, and that, having been one, a person who administers telephone surveys is not technically a telemarketer.

Next, on the actual "Special Features" menu, we have two featurettes, called "The Making of Timer" (8:46, aka "Countdown to Love: Behind the Scenes of Timer" according to the featurette itself), and "Inside the Timer Store" (1:34, aka "The Timer Store"). They're pretty light, but the cast interviews feel more genuine than your average EPK, and it's cool to hear from the production designer regarding the Timer Store, so they're worth a look. Video features are rounded out by a reel of bloopers (3:16), which is...a blooper reel, although there's a tiny bit more of Kali Rocha and Eric Jungmann (from Not Another Teen Movie) as Timer Store clerks.

Last but not least, we have a feature-length audio commentary with director Jac Schaeffer. Red flags reflexively go up upon hearing it's her first commentary, but go back down almost as quickly when it's clear she'll actually have something to say rather than narrating or remaining silent. Actually, it's more like listening to a friend than listening to an audio commentary; I bet you'll recognize Schaeffer's particular brand of light sarcasm and self-deprecating humor as similar to someone you know almost right off the bat. Surprise inspirations include Zack Snyder's Dawn of the Dead, "The X-Files", The Goonies, and Zodiac; less-surprising ones include Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and other mainstream-indie films like Little Miss Sunshine and (grumble) (500) Days of Summer. She also reveals something fairly personal near the end of the track, and even if it's not the kind of revelation is likely to throw the viewer's life into upheaval, it's nice to hear a director be completely and truly candid and open with the audience.

Trailers for Adopted, Good Intentions, and Play the Game automatically unspool before the main menu. Two theatrical trailers for Timer are also included, although neither are the teaser trailer I saw on YouTube, which started with the Timer commercial.

These "big premise" comedies are always a bit of a risk, because it's a fine line to walk between a genius idea and a genuine story, and the fact that Timer is also a romantic comedy adds another series of traps for the film to fall into, but thanks to writer/director Jac Schaeffer, Timer walks the tightrope and makes it across in one piece. It's a sweet, sexy love story that avoids the unintentional misogyny of the average Kate Hudson movie. The DVD has solid picture and audio and packs on a nice commentary and a few video bonuses to boot. I almost ran this review with a "highly recommended" rating, but after considering it, I've concluded that the independent market is so flooded with mediocre, middling romances that feel like paint-by-numbers grids from the "quirky" screenwriting guide for dummies that Timer, as the special, clever, personal movie that it is, is worthy of the DVDTalk Collector's Series. I think viewers will be rewarded.

Please check out my other DVDTalk DVD, Blu-Ray and theatrical reviews and/or follow me on Twitter.
Popular Reviews
1. William Shatner's Get a Life!
2. Batman: Assault on Arkham
3. The Amazing Spider-Man 2
4. Dr. Kildare: The Complete Third Season, Part One & Two (Warner Archive Collection)
5. Toy Story of Terror
6. Y tu mama tambien
7. Out Of The Past: Warner Archives
8. Woodstock, 3 Days of Peace & Music (40th Anniversary Revisited)
9. The Children's Hour
10. Muppets Most Wanted

Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use