Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Lost in Space

Warner Bros. // PG-13 // September 7, 2010
List Price: $24.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted September 10, 2010 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

Stephan Hopkin's 1998 big screen revival of the cult TV series Lost In Space probably sounded like a good idea on paper. The director had found some success with genre material when he helmed A Nightmare On Elm Street 5 - The Dream Child and with the underrated Predator 2 and proved himself capable of making more serious dramatic fare with The Ghost And The Darkness. The fact that the likes of Gary Oldman and William Hurt had signed on for major roles in the film was also a big plus, and Heather Graham, fresh off of Scream 2 and Boogie Nights was a rising star at the time. Somewhere along the way, however, things went wrong.

The film is set in the fast approaching future of 2058 where almost all of the Earth's natural resources have been almost completely exhausted. As such, the planet is soon going to cease being able to support the humans who live on it, forcing world government organizations to have to do something about the problem. Their solution is to find a new planet that will support humanity and to relocate the entire human race by the use of a pair of specially designed Hypergates which will allow a mass exodus through space to a suitable planet.

While all of this is going on, a high ranking scientist named Professor John Robinson (William Hurt) decides to take his family -wife Maureen (Mimi Rogers), daughter Judy (Heather Graham), younger daughter Penny (Lacey Chabert), and son Will (Jack Johnson) - on a mission with a fighter pilot named Major Don West (Matt LeBlanc) to a destination called Alpha Prime which they hope will be able to sustain humanity. What they don't know is that a sneaky no-goodnik named Dr. Zachary Smith (Gary Oldman) is working with a criminal organization called the Seditions who plan to uses the ship's robot to send their ship, the Jupiter 2, veering off course. When this happens, John uses the ship's hyperdrive but soon the family find themselves off course and, as the title suggests, lost in space, but Smith didn't make it off the ship before it went off course, which is obviously going to lead to some problems. The Robinson's now have to find their way home while contending with time warps, technological problems, and of course, Dr. Smith himself.

The film follows the same basic premise as the television series did but attempts to modernize it for a more current audience by injecting some depth into the family dynamic. Where the TV versions of the Space Family Robinson were pretty wholesome, here Penny is your typically troubled teenage girl dealing with her own adolescent issues while various characters deal with personality issues and the like. A subplot involving Major West's intentions towards perky, pretty Judy also rounds things out a bit. This makes the characters a bit more believable, but not really any more likeable or interesting. Thankfully, the film finds a saving grace with Dr. Smith, played devilishly by Gary Oldman who, if nothing else, excels at playing characters devilishly. Hurt is fine as the lead, playing John Robinson as a noble and well meaning man of good intentions and a strong constitution, but Oldman overshadows him at every turn, even if neither actor is really given all that much to do.

This is a film where the cast and characters play second fiddle to the set pieces and effects work. Rather than flesh everyone out and make them interesting to us, the film instead opts to try to distract us with effects set piece and fancy set design. It works to an extent, as there's enough action and intrigue and completely superficial excitement to bring you back around once you start losing interest, but it doesn't exactly make for the most memorable film you'll ever see. In fact, unmemorable is probably the best way to sum up the film. It's inoffensive and periodically entertaining but never more than that despite some fun moments with the cast and a few inspired effects set pieces.

The DVD:

Video:

New Line's VC-1 encoded 1080p 2.40.1 high definition widescreen transfer of Lost In Space is a decent one, showing spectacular color reproduction and strong black levels right from the start. Unfortunately, the transfer isn't always that consistent and there are quite a few shots and scenes that look just a bit on the soft side. Darker scenes get to be a bit muddy at times, and shadow detail isn't always going to 'wow' you but skin tones do look natural. The film shows the most improvement over standard definition in close up shots, where there's simply more to see. Some of the effects shots look a little bit blurry at times, but this is likely to do with the way that the film was shot rather than the transfer itself. Overall, yes, this does improve on the standard definition release, but it's not a revelation.

Sound:

The English language DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio track isn't the immersive surround sound experience that many might have hoped for but it certainly sounds decent enough. The front of the sound stage gets the most action, with rears used a fair bit more sparingly than they could have been but springing to life when called upon. Dialogue is always clean and clear and never in the least bit tricky to understand while the sound effects pack noticeably more punch than they did on DVD. The low end is tight and strong and provides some nice bass rumble when the movie needs it, and generally things sound pretty decent here, even if the movie doesn't sound as good as a more modern feature might in this department. Optional Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound tracks are provided in German and Spanish with subtitles available in English, German, French, Spanish and Portuguese.

Extras:

The extras, all of which are carried over from the standard definition release, begin with a commentary from director Stephen Hopkins who is joined by writer Akiva Goldsman, who were recorded separately and then spliced together, to discuss the origins of the film, casting the picture, basing it off of the beloved television series of the same name, and various production issues that cropped up from time to time. It's a decent track though too frequently it is simply content to simply tell us what's happening on screen. A second commentary track involves effects supervisors Angus Bickerton and Lauren Ritchie, director of photography Peter Levy, editor Ray Lovejoy and the film's producer, Carla Fry, for a discussion that is weighted far more heavily towards the technical side of making this film. There's much discussion and explanation of the film's special effects work and the technology that went into creating them. This can get a bit dry in spots but there's a lot of welcome information and a surprisingly honest critique of the effects seen in the finished movie.

From there, we move on to a collection of deleted scenes, all of which are presented in standard definition and not in the greatest quality. They also feature unfinished effects work. Regardless, here we'll find some excised bits that cover a subplot or two and feature some ideas that were chopped out of the finished product. There is roughly twelve minutes of material here in all, presented in non-anamorphic widescreen.

The disc also includes three featurettes, the first of which is the fifteen minute Building The Special Effects segment which covers much of the same ground as the second commentary track, albeit in a much leaner form and with the added advantage of visual representation. It's quite interesting and worth checking out, though the same thing can't be said about the ten minute long The Future Of Space Travel, which is an outdated bit from 1998 that predicted how things would be ten years from the time it was made. It was a bit off the mark, to say the least, but some unintentional comedic value can be had here which means it's not a total loss. The third featurette is a collection of interviews with the cast members of the original Lost In Space television series who each have a small cameo in the film and who, here at least, seem pretty hyped to have been involved in the feature film.

Rounding out the extras is a music video for the film's theme song, the movie's theatrical trailer, animated menus, and chapter selection menus. All of the extras are in standard definition.

Overall:

Lost In Space isn't a particularly great movie at all when you think about it, but it does offer a modicum of entertainment value and makes for a harmless enough time killer of a film. New Line's Blu-ray release does offer an improvement over the standard definition release but it's not a huge upgrade, making this much more suited as a rental on a lazy weekend afternoon than a must have purchase.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links