In 2009, Phil Spector was convicted
of murdering Lana Clarkson at his home six years earlier. He was
found guilty at a second trial after the first ended in a hung jury.
Evidence was difficult to analyze and Spector's guilt was not easy
to assign. The Agony and the Ecstasy of Phil Spector is a film
by Vikram Jayanti built upon unprecedented access to the reclusive pop
music producer during the days and weeks leading up to his first trial.
Jayanti allows Spector to speak for himself - and captures him in
all his tarnished, self-aggrandizing, twitchy, fact-challenged glory.
Spector comes off as brilliant, creepy, vainglorious, defensive, and
lucid. Jayanti's film treats Spector honestly, uninterested
in glorifying or vilifying this hugely influential and physically tiny
legend of pop culture - and poster boy for the seamy underbelly of
the entertainment business.
Jayanti's film has four elements,
which are carefully layered to maximize context. First there is
the core of the film, consisting of interview footage with Spector,
shot in 2007. Then there are about two dozen of Spector's biggest
songs, which are heard in full on the soundtrack, sometimes at the front
of the mix, and sometimes beneath either Spector's voice or excerpts
from Spector's first trial - excerpts that comprise the film's
third element. Lastly, there are text quotations from Mick Brown's
definitive biography of Spector, Tearing
Down the Wall of Sound, which are utilized to illuminate the significance
and impact of Spector's major songs.
At times, the structure can get a bit
cluttered, but Jayanti's goal, while seemingly simple, is a multifaceted
and difficult one. Jayanti avoids overt editorializing, allowing
Spector's bizarre self-image to remain front-and-center. Occasional
editorial flourishes - particularly in the juxtaposition of Spector's
songs with trial footage - lend a certain bite to the proceedings,
but these are few. For the most part, Jayanti is only interested
in Spector himself.
A towering figure in the history of
pop music, Spector had spent over two decades out of the public eye,
living more or less alone in a gigantic mansion, before Lana Clarkson
was killed there. But he was always eccentric, to say the least.
In the documentary, Spector regularly compares himself to Galileo, Michelangelo,
Alfred Hitchcock, and Leonardo da Vinci. He disses Brian Wilson
and Bob Dylan. He also discusses the assassination of close friend
John Lennon as if it were a rational, logical event.
Jayanti's use of Spector's music
on the soundtrack helps illuminate Spector as a creative personality
and as someone with a dark inner life. While it is a familiar
trope to discuss creativity born of pain or suffering or joy, Spector's
songs here resonate with something close to madness, and more than a
hint of Spector's demons. There is joy, too, but the songs that
are joyful don't seem to come from experiences of joy, but rather
desperate dreams of it.
The Agony and the Ecstasy of Phil
Spector is in limited theatrical release in the United States.
Director Vikram Jayanti has assembled a portrait on film that goes a
step or two beyond other "tortured genius" stories. By arranged
Spector's words in a context that relates to his groundbreaking music,
the film provides us with a deep-set way into Spector's
mind. Beyond Lana Clarkson's tragic murder, it's his self-loathing
and capacity for delusion that disturb us.
Casey Burchby lives in Northern California: Twitter, Tumblr.