There's a strangeness to Zach Galifiankis's comic persona, which in his best moments (particularly when he was more active as a stand-up) teeters right on the brink of darkness. His oddness is so authentic that he can, at times, seem genuinely unhinged; he's got something akin to the unapproachable genius of Andy Kaufman, and if there is a drawback to his newfound film success, it's that it's taken him off the stage and away from the opportunity to go into possibly uncharted waters. But here we have It's Kind of a Funny Story, a film that seizes that darkness, molds it, and pushes it as far as it can go. By now, the wacky comedian turned serious actor has become such a standard movie-industry trope that we tend to sneer when another comic takes the leap. But with Galifianakis, the transition to the dramatic doesn't seem like a stretch, or even a surprise.
The movie that surrounds him, however, is no great shakes, or at least has nothing about it that is nearly as unpredictable or refreshing as his performance in it. This is a disappointment, because it comes by way of writer/directors Anna Boden and Ryan Fleck, whose previous films handily and skillfully transcended the seemingly inevitable clichés of the stories they told, be it the inner-city teacher trying to save a student he takes a shine to (Half Nelson) or the baseball player coming to America to find his fortune (Sugar).
Here, working from the popular young-adult novel by Ned Vizzini, the coming-of-age story and transformative-mental-hospital tale are told pretty much as expected. The focus is on 16-year-old Craig (Keir Gilchrist), who checks himself into a psychiatric hospital because he's contemplating suicide. Due to renovations in the teen ward, he finds himself mixing with the adult patients, including Bobby (Galifiankis), an easygoing long-timer who knows the ins and outs of the joint. Craig quickly realizes that (comparatively speaking) he's not quite as screwed up as he thought, but he's committed, so there you have it.
There are girl complications: Noelle (Emma Roberts), a fellow patient who he quickly takes to, and Nia (Zoe Kravitz), his long-time crush on the outside, who suddenly finds Craig attractive when she finds out how screwed-up he is. And there is the family dynamic, with the ineffectual mother (Lauren Graham) and the father (Jim Gaffigan) who's too busy working to pay attention to his son.
Boden and Fleck seem to know that they're traveling a well-worn road here, and they attempt to supplement the oft-told tale with stylistic flourishes and comic digressions. But most of their attempts and cleverness and invention come across as cutesy or even cloying (with the sole exception of a fantasy sequence set to Queen and Bowie's "Under Pressure" that somehow manages to harness the considerable emotional force of that song).
Ultimately, it's a film about performances. Gilchrist does his best, but he's honestly a bit of a blank slate; there's nothing wrong with his work, but nothing terribly memorable about it either. Graham and Gaffigan are pretty well wasted in their unremarkable supporting roles. But Jeremy Davies (whose presence in a movie like this is all but a foregone conclusion) is rather wonderful, and Kravitz continues to develop into an interesting (and crushingly luminous) screen presence. Nothing would be easier than to discount Roberts as a mere beneficiary of nepotism (and Aunt Julia surely helped open some initial doors), but here and in Lymelife, she's proving herself a charming and charismatic actress.
If the film is worth seeing, though (and it probably is), it's for Galifianakis. His work is somewhat reminiscent of Robin Williams's first dramatic breakthrough, in The World According to Garp--it's not a humorless piece of work, as evidenced by moments like his attempt to help Craig practice asking Noelle out. But the character's inner sadness grounds the performance (and anchors the rather lightweight film); it's a turn that's both spontaneous and precise, in which anything seems possible--for the character and for the actor. There's real anger when he snaps at Craig, and real danger and pain when he loses his shit at a particularly difficult moment. This is not a stand-up screwing around for kicks; this is a real actor of real skill.
The white, antiseptic hospital setting threatens, at times, to overwhelm the 1.85:1 image. But the bright costume design mostly manages to keep the image from washing out, and the saturation of those bold colors is nicely reproduced here. The hard white backgrounds do occasionally get a tad over-compressed, but aside from that, there are no real issues with this acceptable if unexciting transfer.
The Dolby Digital 5.1 mix is mostly dialogue-based, so most of the action is in the front, center channel. Dialogue reproduction is clean and clear; audibility is never an issue. The environmental sounds of the hospital (PA announcements, ringing phones, rambling schizophrenics) are present if a bit too subtle in the surround channels, while Broken Social Scene's music is smoothly interspersed. Music cues from Queen and Method Man give the track some juice, and give the LFE channel a chance to shine.
Spanish and French 5.1 options are also offered, as are English SDH, Spanish, and French subtitles.
Bonus features are pretty slight. Five Deleted Scenes (8:56) plug a couple of story holes, and one brings the Gaffigan subplot to a needed and well-executed (if somewhat formulaic) conclusion. The reel of Outtakes (11:29) is a bit overlong, but it's got some real laughs in it--most of them courtesy of Galifiankis, who gets to show his comic chops with some "Line-O-Rama"-style dialogue variations. "A Look Inside It's Kind of a Funny Story" (3:15) is basically an extended trailer; a slim package of Red Carpet Footage (2:33) from the New York premiere closes out the bonus features.
Late in It's Kind of a Funny Story, Craig asks Bob if he wants to hang out some time. The way Galifianakis responds to that, the specific choices he makes in that moment (which is ultimately more bitter than sweet) suggest that, right then, he has a deeper and more nuanced understanding of his character's fate than the movie's requisite feel-good ending will allow. As a movie, It's Kind of a Funny Story is nothing new, and at times its familiarity is borderline irritating. As an appreciation of a unique and gifted actor, however, it is a tremendous success.
Jason lives with his wife Rebekah and their two cats in New York and holds an MA in Cultural Reporting and Criticism from NYU. He is film editor for Flavorwire and is a contributor to Salon, the Atlantic, and several other publications. He blogs at Fourth Row Center and is yet another critic with a Twitter feed.