DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD / Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer
Search: For:
Reviews » Blu-ray Reviews » Black Swan: Three-Disc Target Exclusive (Blu-ray)
Black Swan: Three-Disc Target Exclusive (Blu-ray)
Fox Searchlight Pictures // R // March 29, 2011 // Region A
List Price: $39.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Thomas Spurlin | posted March 29, 2011 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
DVD Talk Collector Series
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
The Film:

Ballet appears dainty and harmless to those on the outside looking in, but those who have endured the bruises, exhaustion, and snapped tendons that come along with it will gladly voice to the contrary. Black Swan, Darren Aronofsky's latest mind-meddler, dips into this raw and painful side to conjure a rush of psycho-sexual tension and artistic meditation, funneling a dancer's fear of career-ending transience into a descent towards mania. But the film doesn't stop with the physical; dashes of traditional horror reaching back to Dario Argento's Giallo films and even a heap of David Cronenberg mingle with the unspooling of a young artist's mind, coming as close to a visual embodiment of "transcendence" for art's sake as one can get. We witness the metamorphosis of a woman on-screen, both as a dancer and as a girl losing her inhibition, and it's relentlessly unsettling -- and utterly mesmerizing -- by way of the director's intellectually aggressive style.

After waking from a odd-yet-satisfying dream where she's dancing in a dark spin on Swan Lake, Nina (Natalie Portman, V for Vendetta) twists her ankles and feet in a few circles, letting the creaks echo in her kitschy little bedroom. She's a weathered dancer with a major ballet company, living in an underwhelming apartment with her intrusive mother (Barbara Hershey, Hannah and Her Sisters) coddling her between daily rehearsals. Nina's always been meek around her colleagues, especially company director Thomas (Vincent Cassel, Irreversible), and it's transformed her career into that of an accomplished supporting player with little more to show for it than promises for more of the spotlight. She's always a key secondary character in Swan Lake, yet she hasn't stood out enough to earn the role of Swan Queen, a part routinely given to soon-to-be-retired veteran Beth (Winona Ryder, Girl, Interrupted). More importantly, she hasn't broken out of her shell nearly enough to embody the duality of the Swan Queen's role in her dancing -- first delicate and warm, then brooding and incendiary. While Nina steps up her game both on and off the stage, a dark-haired, tattooed newcomer, Lilly (Mila Kunis, Forgetting Sarah Marshall), seductively slips into the competition. And Nina, who's anxious to tweak her personality for the role, takes close notice.

The eeriness generated in Black Swan's opening dream sequence lingers long after its fleeting time on-screen, suggesting something sinister coursing underneath the film's abrasive trimmings. But Aronofsky, similarly to his rough-and-tumble drama The Wrestler, first focuses on the exchanges between Nina's colleagues in the ballet world -- here, mostly one-upmanship cattiness -- and some vicarious maternal drama for its foundation, etching out a portrait of New York-bound performance competitiveness within its brash, electric setting. He illustrates the extent of Nina's personality within this maze of slate-colored hallways and stony dance studios, and how she differs from her colleagues; she lacks gumption and composure, even though her talent soars above those around her. In that, the edgy screenplay pivots around her quirks, from the nervous scratching that reddens her shoulder to her compulsory need to vomit upon the slightest flutter of stress. She lacks joie de vivre, and she knows it.

Aronofsky returns to mainstay cinematographer Matthew Libatique (Everything is Illuminated) to capture Black Swan's cold, rasping surroundings, yet it's interesting how similar the earthy visual tempo resembles that of Maryse Alberti's work on The Wrestler. As we peer over Nina's oft-itched shoulder and slender neck, it feels as if we're seeing -- and feeling -- the world about her in a grounded and effortless fashion, the verbal digs and weighty pressure closing in. Clint Mansell's (Moon) score, reflecting on tones in Tchaikovsky's work with his own searing percussion, adds to the flush of tension that swallows up Nina; his work on Black Swan differs from his momentum-driven, piano-and-string-heavy odes, more delicate and subtly haunting than he's expressed previously. This trio of filmmakers has concocted many a stunning picture together, ranging from Requiem for a Dream's severity to The Fountain's existential allure, yet the frosty and sleek aesthetics in Black Swan merge into what's arguably their most polished collaboration to date. As a film about performance art's erratic moving pieces should be, it's an insatiable onslaught on the senses that thrives off of leaving its audience boggled and entranced to equal measure.

As Nina's nervous spasms intensify with her preparation for the role of the Swan Queen, specifically the darker and more seductive half of the part, Black Swan descends into a stark and disturbing portrait of envy, emulation, and the madness that follows obsession. Aronofsky guides Nina's anxiety through a thick cloud of ambiguity over its realism, allowing the spine-chilling opening dream sequence to ignite a series of intensifying supernatural twitches that may, or may not, be the workings of an artist slowly losing her sanity. Is the rash on her back the work of a childhood habit whenever Nina gets nervous, or is it the potential exit point for a pair of wings? Aronofsky paints a searing portrait for his audience that profusely teases an answer, which, along with a peppering of impressively seamless visual effects, turns this into the director's first real tango with traditional horror. Yet this isn't about us as her audience; it's about Nina's rush to crack her outer shell, while we're just allowed to witness the grueling scope of her manic transformation.

The most important character in Aronofsky's film, as a result, is the labyrinth of Nina's mind, both in how she sees the world spiraling around her and how she adapts to the duality demanded for the darker, sultry Black Swan. The madness that she undergoes ravishes the screen due to a pinnacle performance from Natalie Portman, both in acting and dancing capability. Aside from lengthy pirouettes and vigorous en pointe work, which will be obvious, it's Portman in the ballet slippers, trimmed to a svelte frame and edgy with her somewhat frantically-determined disposition. With the rivalry intensifying and the physical demands whittling Nina down thinner, Portman pumps up her fatigued, hotheaded edginess to match the chaos around her. She's complimented well by Vincent Cassel as company instructor Thomas, who aptly embodies both the brilliant and coarse sides of a director. There's a particularly involving scene where he demonstrates the consuming rush of seduction for -- actually, with -- Nina, and it ignites a bit of a stir on both physical and mental planes.

Then, there's Mila Kunis, who impressed earlier this year in The Book of Eli. There's an edge to her performance as Lilly that will take insight to see, perhaps a second screening. However, when the two-faced fabric of Lilly's demeanor comes into light, it's obvious that Kunis' emerging talent claims a lot of the responsibility for the deft rendering of the film's concept. As an effortless dancer who pops pills and beds men at her whim, Lilly becomes something of an inspiration to Nina -- but obviously not just in the dancing arena. She becomes a benchmark for everything that Nina isn't, a goal to obtain and, in ways, the yin to her yang. Portman and Kunis share the ideal chemistry for their places in the narrative, off-and-on distanced and clingy, which builds to a ravishing ... erm, "climax" in their relationship that matches steaminess beat-for-beat with meaningfulness to the script's grand design.

The macabre allure in Black Swan builds into a cerebral puzzle splintered within an intellectual concept, showing the extent that slaves to art endure within this fantastical, oftentimes horrifying depiction of creative abandon. As the final act spins into a nightmarish whirling dervish, furiously constructing an answer to the film's ambiguous question, its attempt to both knock us off-kilter and rope us into significance rattles the senses all the way to the big performance -- a stripped-down, disquieting take of Tchaikovsky's work. And, boy, does Aronofsky succeed. It's possible that Black Swan's stroke of meaning might be lost on those that haven't known artists who desperately chase their craft, be it stage performers or method actors or even sketch-and-paint artists. Most, however, can appreciate the magnetic pull towards accomplishment that's achieved through diligence and zeal, which takes on a deeper meaning in artists. They must live and breathe their art form for it to feel real to their audience, and Aronofsky has created an intricate, engaging and ominous display of the transcendent process.


The Blu-ray:



Black Swan twirls its way onto Blu-ray from Fox Searchlight, which, with the standard retail packaging, comes in a two-disc case housing the HD and Digital Copy presentations. In lieu of that, Fox Home Entertainment have also coordinated with Target stores to release an exclusive package of Darren Aronofsky's film, arriving in a three-disc case that also includes the retail DVD for the film as Disc Two (which includes some of the special features from the Blu-ray) and the Digital Copy disc as Disc Three. A dark-red backing replaces the white one that's behind Nina's head in the regular artwork, while a shiny slipcase replicates the front and back cover.


Video and Audio:

Shot on Super 16mm to achieve a textured movement that's reminiscent of documentary-like vérité cinema, Black Swan arrives from Fox in a 2.4:1-framed Blu-ray transfer that retains the film's monochrome, intentionally grainy aesthetic with nimble high-definition execution. Director Aronofsky and cinematographer Libatique only use color with surgical intent throughout the harsh black-and-white New York ballet scene, with faint pinks, greens, and blues pouring in only when they're needed in the set design -- especially noticeable in the Swan Lake production near the end of the film. The range of motion during the ballet sequences never leaves a pixel out of place as it flows at 24fps, while the erratic behind-the-shoulder movement never loses its composure. Black levels remain deep yet reflective of minute elements in the shadows, while the intricacy in Nina's "rash" and the her costumes deliver crisp detail where needed. Though the 16mm film stock grows a bit heavier than expected, Fox's Blu-ray transfer simply astounds with its faithful projection of this complex, coarse yet alluring photography.

As steady and beautiful as the visuals are, they're eclipsed by the sublime quality of this 5-channel DTS HD Master Audio track. Clint Mansell's masterful spin on Swan Lake claims much of the attention, with the woodwind, percussion, and piano-heavy orchestral elements ringing true in loud moments, even truer in the more subdued and graceful ones. They mesh with the dialogue perfectly, bouncing against the New York locations with intuitive awareness of the surroundings as Vincent Cassel's accent, Natalie Portman's dainty bursts, and Mila Kunis' gravelly alto sauciness stay impressively clear. But it's the slight, reserved effects that bolster this aural treatment towards greatness; the shutting of doors, the crackling of bones, the shatter of glass, the grind of ballet slipper resin, and yes, the scattering of atmospheric bird effects. They all effortlessly slip in and out of the surround design to create an unsettling environment, one that never relents its pins-'n-needles movement. In short: damn. Spanish and French 5.1 tracks are also available, along with English SDH, Spanish and French subtitles (though you have to manually access the French subtitles, as they're not an option under the "Setup" page).


Special Features:

Black Swan: Metamorphosis (48:55, 16x9 HD AVC):
A knee-jerk response when looking at the special features for Black Swan would likely be one of slight disappointment when a commentary isn't listed, instead with a making-of documentary entitled "Metamorphosis" taking center stage. But instead of Aronofsky mulling over details in an audio rundown, this piece actually captures the elements that he'd likely discuss and shows exactly how they're conceived, shot with some form of DSLR camera as it weaves through the low-budget stages and locations. Looking at the components, it doesn't sound much different from run-of-the-mill marketing stuff slapped on other Blu-rays and DVDs: interviews with the director, actors, and crew are cut with scenes from the film and extensive off-camera footage. What's assembled within the moody pulsing music and a sense of documentary "momentum" is much more than that, though, coming together into nearly fifty (50) minutes of material that goes a few steps beyond what a traditional commentary would accomplish.

Split into three parts -- the first two, Chapter One (15:15) and Chapter Two (21:17), being somewhat seamless across New York locations while the third, Chapter Three (12:33), covers the visual effects used to transform Nina -- "Metamorphosis" tackles everything from production design and cinematography to smaller tidbits that revolve around the film's minuscule budget. Candid, honest face-time with the actors and insightful behind-the-scenes footage dissect things like the material concocted to replicate "safe" shattered glass, the importance and difficulties of shooting around said mirrors, how Libatique and his team achieved the frantic pirouette sequence with Vincent Cassel, and the lengths taken in both the editing and computer-generated arenas to integrate Natalie Portman's dancing capabilities with her ballet double. The earthy movement of the DSLR camera lends intimacy to the three chapters, while also capturing a few deeper revelations behind the story's intricacy (notice who writes "WHORE" on the ladies' room mirror). "Metamorphosis" is sober yet stylish, and consistently stimulating with its context.

Along with that, a series of interview-heavy featurettes address assorted other topics, most in a standard, brief, and somewhat redundant fashion that aren't as boast-worthy as the central supplement. Ballet (2:33, HD AVC): briefly covers both the nature of Swan Lake and the characters of the film, while Production Design (4:00, HD AVC) quickly but eloquently glides through Aronofsky's and production designer Thérèse DePrez's "organic" and "minimal" aesthetic conceptualization, specifically the subtlety in perpetuating the Swan Lake elements and mirrors into the set design. Costume Design (3:55, HD AVC) revolves around the boldness of Amy Westcott's implementation, as well as Rodarte's re-conceptualization of the Swan Lake standards in the outfits. A few Profiles bounces through the evolution of the actors' association with the project, from the eight years of development involving Natalie Portman (3:16, HD AVC) and how Darren Aronofsky (2:48, HD AVC) reveals the connections between Black Swan and The Wrestler as companion pieces.

Rounding things out, a series of chat-heavy pieces bring up the rear of the supplements. Conversation: Preparing For the Role (3:53) brings Portman and Aronofsky together to discuss how the actress prepared for the film's vigorous physical demands, while they discuss the most difficult part of emoting and communicating in Conversation: Dancing With the Camera (1:35, HD AVC). Finally, a series of five generic Fox Movie Channel Presents (4x3 SD AVC) pieces concentrate on talking about the characters of Black Swan with Natalie Portman (5:56), Winona Ryder (2:17), Barbara Hershey (3:37), and Vincent Cassel (4:43, as well as focusing on standard filmmaker content with Darren Aronofsky (6:23). On top of all that, Fox have also included the haunting post-festival, post-Oscar nomination Theatrical Trailer (2:02, HD AVC), which delivers a punch in communicating its creepy edge and tension-driven tone.


Final Thoughts:

Darren Aronofsky meshes compelling elements with Black Swan, from psycho-sexual tension and horror-driven thrills to cerebral contemplation and, ultimately, metaphorical expression. What he achieves fits snugly between extravagance and brilliance, rife with grind-on-the-nerves ferocity and monochromatic visual allure. Commanded by an astounding performance from Natalie Portman (and an equally impressive, if under-appreciated turn from Mila Kunis), this unsettling fable of artistic expression and the mentally-straining demands of achieving perfection in that spectrum is easily one of 2010's best films -- and, after plenty of discussion and numerous screenings, my favorite of the year. Fox's Blu-ray does an impeccable job of presenting the film in high-definition, along with a healthy wallop of special features led by a spectacular three-part making-of doc, which earns this mesmerizing challenge of a picture an entry into DVDTalk Collector's Series.



Thomas Spurlin, Staff Reviewer -- DVDTalk Reviews | Personal Blog/Site
Other Reviews:
Find the lowest price for 'Black Swan: Three-Disc Target Exclusive (Blu-ray)'
Popular Reviews
1. Godzilla (2014)
2. Hannibal: Season Two
3. South Park: Season 17
4. Arrow: Season 2
5. The Rover
6. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
7. Eraserhead
8. The Great Train Robbery
9. Flesh + Blood
10. Any Given Sunday: 15th Anniversary


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use