DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD / Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer
Search: For:
Reviews » Blu-ray Reviews » Red Riding Hood (Alternate & Theatrical Cuts) (Blu-ray)
Red Riding Hood (Alternate & Theatrical Cuts) (Blu-ray)
Warner Bros. // PG-13 // June 14, 2011 // Region A
List Price: $35.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Thomas Spurlin | posted June 23, 2011 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Skip It
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
The Film:




Somewhere within Catherine Hardwicke's Red Riding Hood lies an adequate anxiety-driven gothic mystery, accentuated with Brothers Grimm-caliber whimsy and contemporary polish. A fine snowy setting populated by dark-wood cabins dominates the image, while suitable casting choices -- focal being Big Love's Amanda Seyfried -- offer their services in breathing life into the whimsical town of Daggerhorn, a village plagued with unease over the presence of a voracious wolf looming in its outlying forests. However, the trendy flamboyance and sturdy cast materialize into a tepid mess through the Twilight director's eye, letting a scrap of promise slip through its fingers by way of obnoxious scripting and a dithering, dull focus on the chemistry generated between its leads.

Little Red Riding Hood's simple cautionary tale holds a lineage of loose adaptations, passed down from medieval peasants to Charles Perrault and the Brothers Grimm. Taking a few liberties with the premise feels welcome in the hands of Orphan screenwriter David Johnson, whose script gives Red Riding Hood a name, Valerie (Seyfried), and draws up the Daggerhorn village as a bucolic nook in a forest, one that offers livestock sacrifices to a bloodthirsty, almost curse-like wolf. But I guess the paranoia following a gory death at the hands of the beast, heightened by witch-hunter Father Solomon (Gary Oldman) charioting into town and claiming that it takes human form during the day, isn't enough; it also forces a love triangle within the town's suspicion, between Valerie, a poor woodcutter named Peter (Shiloh Fernandez) she's loved since childhood, and wealthier blacksmith Henry (Max Irons) that her family -- father Cesaire (Billy Burke) and mother Suzette (Virginia Madsen) -- have arranged for her to marry.

Red Riding Hood generates a little allure with its updated gothic premise and a glossy artistic eye, a prime setting for the cast to muster an energetic fantasy-horror tale. Shot in Vancouver, the location of Daggerhorn nestles into trees and snowy banks, while Australia cinematographer Mandy Walker fluidly moves the lens over log homes and bursts of color -- snow-laden blues, earthen warmth, and the red of Valerie's cloak -- to create a thriving rustic aesthetic. Amanda Seyfried gallivants through the forbidden forests and between the dimly-lit locations, eventually bathed in deep crimson to signify all the faint prescient symbolism culled from the original story, and her wide-eyed, soft-voiced poise meshes smoothly into the befuddled Valerie. Virginia Madsen stands out as a fine choice for her mother as well, while Gary Oldman should wear the over-the-top preaching that spills from a werewolf hunter like a glove. The components are there, down to Alex Heffes' and Brian Reitzell's snappy rhythmic score.

Underneath questionable direction and the way Hardwicke navigates an ill-defined script, Red Riding Hood lethargically slumps into tedium. Honestly, the village's atmosphere drew attention at first, generating an inkling of curiosity at the sight of a goat chained up alongside a makeshift moon calendar, heightened by the protective spikes jetting from Daggerhorn's structures. Even though the film lazily shapes the wolf into a current pop-culture-friendly werewolf, the anxiety that initially knocks the town's populace into an uneasy state flirts with Wicker Man-esque eeriness. Yet a consistent stream of blunt dialogue awkwardly hangs in the air -- Valerie's wood-cutter beau lustfully exclaims he could just "eat [her] up", among others -- and any of that naturally creepy flow gets lost in its own stiff atmosphere, draining the color from its cheeks. It's saying something if even Gary Oldman's exaggeration appears lethargic and chained down.

Instead of sustaining Daggerhorn's werewolf-saddled misgivings, the tone Hardwicke builds atop it can't resist from refocusing towards the angst-hampered romance. Red Riding Hood aims to balance supernatural doubt with swooning as Valerie suspiciously darts her eyes amongst the town's citizens and back to her beaus, and it doesn't seem to realize that it's turning a cold shoulder from its more thrilling draws and towards muddled clich├ęs. Her warring chiseled-jawed hunks generate a wishy-washy mood not unlike the brooding in Hardwicke's Twilight, while falling into the archaic battle of rich man-poor man where a matronly girl wrestles with choosing between matters of the heart and parent-propelled financial security. This triangle wouldn't be any great shakes even had it been aptly handled within the whodunit mystery's confines, but Amanda Seyfried's carriage saunters between two wooden suitors, thickening the blandness with a tedious parlay of testosterone and medieval manner.

The result, even while picking up the pace and latching onto action near the close, is an unfocused jumble that neither evokes the passion it perceives itself to have nor offers even meager jolts, making Red Riding Hood an eye-catching but tiresome slog. Twists and turns occur, while a computer-generated wolf eventually tears into the flesh of Daggerhorn's citizens during the "blood moon", only in the ways a PG-13 film can muster. Just for kicks, it also scratches off flickers of the fable's lore -- the way the wolf communicates with the young heroine, the ridiculous "My, what big eyes you have" scenario, and the temerity the filmmakers deemed tolerable for the story's twisted conclusion in Grandma Julie Christie's house, filled with blood, claws, stones and operatic flourishes. Yet it all feels like a massive pulled punch, with everything from the visual design and actors to the overall tone captured in a leaden state, almost begging to be handled in a more raw, vivacious, and ... well, engaging fashion.


The Blu-ray:




Red Riding Hood bears its teeth on Blu-ray by way of Warner Brothers, arriving in two iterations on the same disc: the Theatrical Cut (1:39:50), and the ever-so-slight Alternate Cut (1:40:24). The difference primarily boils down to the ending, in which the alternate cut tacks on a "little" twist at the close that's pretty unnecessary. A cardboard, lenticular slipcover adorns the two-disc release, with the second disc being a DVD/Digital Copy Hybrid Disc that only contains the theatrical cut (and no special features).


Video and Audio:

Little dispute can be made over acknowledging that Red Riding Hood's biggest asset comes in its vibrant visual attitude, and Warner Brothers' 2.35:1 1080p AVC encode make it a point to preserve it as alluring as the medium can handle. Rushes of red in Valerie's cloak look exceptionally balanced and controlled, the fluctuation of skin tones shifts from pale to flush at noticeable points, while the blanket of snow appears either crisp white or faintly blue where the palette deems necessary. Rich textures in dark wood paneling and in costumes offers fine minuscule details, while the gray/green depth of stony and metallic surfaces show a nimble grasp on contrast. The entire image leans a little dark intermittently and a handful of darker-contrasted scenes show slightly graying black levels, but the finesse in Mandy Walker's cinematography can be palpably seen in this Blu-ray rendering.

Coming in right behind the stunning visual treatment, the DTS HD Master Audio track also sinks its claws into the aural delights that the film has to offer. Paramount of those delights being the exceptional music, which makes broad use of the entire bass spectrum as it traverses its rhythm from drums to pulsing electronic attitude. Amanda Seyfried's whispering vocals slip through clear and attuned through the front channels, while Gary Oldman's rasping, forced demeanor as Father Solomon scrapes right along where it needs to against the design. A few vigorous sound effects rush to the rear channels -- clanking of metal and flickering of fire in a blacksmith's shop, livestock in the distance, and the sound of a wolf lunging at the screen -- while distortion remains at the utmost minimum across the film, matching the visual treatment tooth-and-nail in quality. English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese subtitles and language tracks have all been included.


Special Features:

Secrets Behind the Red Cloak (Theatrical, HD AVC):
Essentially, this is a mix of behind-the-scenes shots, interviews, and an audio commentary featuring Catherine Hardwicke, Amanda Seyfried, Shiloh Fernandez, and Max Irons, with the video footage appearing in a red-framed box within the image. The output of content leans more towards jovial conversation with a little bit of insight into the making of the picture, such as how chickens were a pain to work with and how Max trained to be a blacksmith. They talk about the massive dance sequence and the song specifically composed for it, from Fever Ray, while some audition footage captures the actors grasping their roles early on. It's a fine watch and should satisfy fans on the film, but the depth won't really sell any detractors otherwise on the picture's composition.

Behind The Story (HD AVC):
A series of featurettes, most of them repurposed in the Secrets Behind the Red Cloak feature, cover a series of topics that range from adapting the original story to the big screen (The Reinvention of Red Riding Hood, 5:25) to the pair of newly-discovered actors that play the two central leads (Red's Men, 3:18). Brian Reitzell also elegantly discusses the score quite a bit (Making of the Score, 10:59), while a brief snippet dips its toes into creating the computer-generated wolf (Making of the CGI Wolf, 0:40). Alongside that, the raw Casting Tapes (7:24) and full-on Rehearsals (5:52) can be viewed on their own, as well as a quick fast-forwarded version of the movie entitled Red Riding Hood in 73 Seconds (1:28) that's, well, a little too easy to poke fun at.

A slate of four wholly unneeded Deleted Scenes (4:18, HD) have been attached to the supplements, along with a Gag Reel (2:37, HD AVC) and two Music Videos (5:27, HD AVC) -- one for "The Wolf", and the other for "Just a Fragment of You". And if you pressed the right button right next to the Music Videos text, you can access an Easter Egg (0:26) featuring Hardwicke and, uh, a "wolf".


Final Thoughts:

Eh, Catherine Hardwicke's Red Riding Hood doesn't do much to make us perceive it as anything but Twilight in wolves' clothing. For every step it takes in the right direction with its audiovisual style and proper casting choices, it takes a few steps back in meager scripting and aloof, unfocused direction. It's a really attractive fantasy thriller and, with the components at use, could have delivered a rush of suspense; however, there's not much of a chill or jolt to be found, and certainly not much of a pull to the love triangle around ole Red. Warner Brothers' Blu-ray looks and sounds excellent, and contains a series of satisfying special features for fans that include a Picture-in-Picture commentary and a series of behind-the-scenes glimpses. It's a really flimsy, trying attempt at expounding and modernizing the fable, though, and the visual/aural execution and the ample cast really doesn't do enough to save its misfires. Skip It.



Thomas Spurlin, Staff Reviewer -- DVDTalk Reviews | Personal Blog/Site
Other Reviews:
Find the lowest price for 'Red Riding Hood (Alternate & Theatrical Cuts) (Blu-ray)'
Popular Reviews
1. Nightbreed: The Director's Cut
2. Sherlock Holmes: The Complete Series
3. The Sopranos: The Complete Series
4. F for Fake: Criterion Collection
5. Sex Tape
6. The Dogs of War (Limited Edition Series)
7. Begin Again
8. The Doctor And The Devils
9. Fedora
10. The Vanishing


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use