As a network, HBO certainly doesn't suffer for a lack of recognition (take a look at any Emmy or Cable ACE award nomination list). But not enough praise has been given the company for their increasing interest in documenting solo performances on Broadway--usually by big stars, mind you, but there's still something commendable about the fact that they're bringing high-dollar productions to audiences across the country who might not otherwise see them. That said, Will Ferrell's You're Welcome, America, Carrie Fisher's Wishful Drinking, and Colin Quinn's Long Story Short were all comic monologues--stand-up performances on a network that has always had a bit of a specialty that particular arena. Their recording of Thurgood, Laurence Fishburne's one-man realization of Supreme Court justice Thurgood Marshall, is something quite different: a serious examination of an important man.
Which is not to say that it's some sort of dry, academic slog, even though it is set up to be that very thing. The premise of the piece is that an elderly Marshall (Fishburne) is returning to his alma matter, Howard University, to give a talk on his life and times, and indeed it is structured as a lecture, as "instructor" Marshall peppers his audience with stories, questions, and even occasional praise. He moves quickly from his history to ours; he's talking about the Plessy v. Ferguson case by the nine-minute mark, and begins to weave our shared histories together. "If you want to understand my story," he announces, "don't forget that name: Homer Adolph Plessy."
Let it be said, at risk of frightening off the potential viewer, that Thurgood is a tremendously informative program, with much to teach. Marshall walks us through the process of attaining equality in the eyes of the law, step by step, base by case, setback by setback. He talks about his most famous fight, Brown vs. Board of Education, and gives a detailed (and riveting) description of arguing it before the Supreme Court. But equal weight is given to important cases along the way that we may be less familiar with (this writer, for one, was clearly not as aware of Smith vs. Allright as I should have been--blame it on a public school education, I guess).
But this is not mere discourse. Fishburne's Marshall is an entertainer, a raconteur, filled with earthy humor and inventive ad-libs (he handles a pair of late arrivals brilliantly, and the punch line to his Richard Nixon story is, by itself, worth the price of the disc). It takes a bit of time, at the beginning of the evening, to get used to Fishburne's portrayal of Marshall's advanced age; he, too, seems not quite comfortable with it (the later scenes of older Marshall are more convincing; he's had time to age into them). But he loses much of the age as he goes back to his youth--he becomes the younger man, to a great degree. His speech gets quicker and sharper as the stories carry us away, and he gets a good rhythm going. He's a good storyteller, this Thurgood Marshall is, and so, simultaneously, is Laurence Fishburne. It's a bravura performance.
Video & Audio:
The MPEG-4 AVC-encoded image is crisp and attractive, capturing the vivid saturation of the costuming, as well as the full, rich darkness and shadows of the staging. Detail work is impressive too, from the stylized close-ups of the opening credit sequence to the considerable textures of Fishburne's skin. The English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix is fine as well, providing a good, clean center track for his dialogue while nicely spreading sound cues and audience reactions to the side and back channels. The immersion works; it puts us right in the middle of that audience.
A Spanish DTS Digital Surround 2.0 track is also included, as are English SDH, Spanish, and French subtitles.
No bonus features are included.
Thurgood's filmed performance is directed by Michael Stevens (the script was written by his father, George Stevens Jr., and, well, you may have heard of his father), and you can seem him trying to keep the image dynamic. To avoid the stodginess of a "movie of a play," he might cut a bit too much and move the camera a bit more than is strictly necessary. But it's not distracting, and he nicely interweaves the photos and footage that appear on the giant screen behind Fishburne. Most importantly, though, he focuses on his riveting star, keeping the camera close and capturing every lucid turn. "I have to tell you," his Thurgood tells us, towards the end of the evening, "sometimes I get a little weary of trying to save the white man's soul." He says it with a little glimmer in his eye, equal parts humor and bitterness. There's a lot about the man in a moment like that, and Thurgood is filled with those moments.
Jason lives with his wife Rebekah and their daughter Lucy in New York. He holds an MA in Cultural Reporting and Criticism from NYU. He is film editor for Flavorwire and is a contributor to Salon, the Atlantic, and several other publications. His first book, Pulp Fiction: The Complete History of Quentin Tarantino's Masterpiece, was released last fall by Voyageur Press. He blogs at Fourth Row Center and is yet another critic with a Twitter feed.