The movie
When you buy a new PC, if
you have a choice whether or not to have the Microsoft Windows operating system
pre-installed, you have Linux to thank for that. Linux: it's not a person
(though it's named for its creator, Linus Torvalds), but rather a computer
operating system that is both free (yes, that's right: you don't have to pay
for it) and "open source," meaning that its source code is available
for anybody to tinker with. More than that, it's an operating system whose
proponents managed to boot-strap it up from its humble origins at the hands of
a few visionary hackers to become a major competitor for the corporate giant
Microsoft.
Revolution OS (the OS
stands for "operating system") steps back to the origins of the Free
Software movement to reveal how Linux is more than just a competitor for
Windows with a lower price tag. It's the culmination of the "hacker
ethic," as exemplified by the technological guru Richard Stallman. In this
mindset, while users buy their hardware, the software that they use ought to be
free, and what's more, freely shared, for each person to tweak, improve, and
build on to create new, more powerful programs.
For the technically inclined, Revolution
OS offers a fascinating look into the origins and development of the Linux
operating system, following it from its origins in the combination of
Stallman's GNU system with Linus Torvald's Linux. At the same time, the film
traces the development of the Open Source movement, also with origins in
Stallman's hacker ideology but growing into something different in the hands of
the Silicon Valley software engineers who expanded the reach of Linux as a
viable choice for an operating system.
But Revolution OS isn't
just a documentary for techies. Its presentation of the "battle of the
operating systems" may be eye-opening for viewers who are used to the
ubiquity of Microsoft Windows, but even beyond that, it's a fascinating look at
the closest thing the U.S. has got to a modern-day Utopian vision: people
coming together into communities bound only by their shared love of computers
and information, designing, building, and improving complex software for the
sheer joy of creating and sharing. It's a kind of counterculture that, as we
see in Revolution OS, drew in an assortment of very different
characters: from visionaries like Stallman to entrepreneurs, from people like
Linus Torvalds whose interest lay solely in the technical side of things to
people like Eric Raymond who looked at the open source movement with an
anthropologist's eye and drew larger organizational conclusions.
Perhaps partly because I was
already somewhat familiar with the "hacker ethic" and Richard
Stallman's work (from reading Steven Levy's nonfiction book Hackers,
which I highly recommend), I found myself wishing that Revolution OS
would go a little bit more in-depth in its presentation of the material. This
is a fairly minor quibble, though; as a whole, Revolution OS does an
excellent job of presenting a nicely structured, well paced presentation of the
various threads that make up the Linux/Open Source movement.
While the program as a whole
takes an enthusiastic slant toward the whole Open Source movement, it's not
cheerleading for anything. The various interviewees are clearly excited to talk
about Linux, Open Source, and the Free Software movement, and that sort of
enthusiasm is always infectious to some degree, but even when Richard Stallman
is at his most vehement, there's never a sense that the filmmakers are trying
to press an ideology on the viewer. And I was interested to note how Revolution
OS concludes: although the program as a whole is focused on the origins and
development of Linux, it's also up-to-date, and we also see briefly what
happens to Linux in its competition with Windows and to the Linux-based
companies in the post-dot-com mania.
All in all, Revolution OS
is certainly worth viewing. With a running time of two hours, it's long enough
to present the material without feeling rushed, and it's paced well enough that
the program is always moving steadily along and keeping the viewer interested.
The DVD
Revolution OS is a
two-disc set, nicely packaged in a single-wide keepcase that has a separate
"page" inside to secure both discs in plastic spindles. Appropriately
enough, given the philosophy of the Free Software and Open Source movements,
this is a region-free disc (Region 0), and it proudly states that it is
CSS-encryption free. It's in the NTSC format.
Video
Revolution OS is
presented in a widescreen 2.35:1 aspect ratio transfer. It's not anamorphically
enhanced. Overall, the image is respectable, and certainly good enough for the
material being presented: mainly interview footage. Colors are natural-looking,
contrast is fine, and while the image isn't extremely crisp, it does have a
nice clean look.
Audio
The Dolby 2.0 sound is a notch
above average, offering a clean and generally clear listening experience. A few
of the interview clips are a bit muffled-sounding due to that segment being
recorded in a noisy or otherwise sub-optimal environment, but on the whole Revolution
OS sounds fine.
Extras
Revolution OS puts a
solid amount of material in support of its "Special Edition" label:
the second disc is definitely necessary.
On the first DVD, we have the
option of watching the documentary with a director's commentary or with a
music-only audio track. I can't imagine what would possess anyone to want to
watch a documentary like this with only the music... not to mention the fact
that (let's face it) the music is lousy, always managing to be slightly (or
wildly) inappropriate for the material it's supporting. There are also trailers
for Revolution OS and a completely unrelated feature film.
70 minutes of additional
interview footage are included as the first special feature on the second DVD.
We get further interview segments from most of the people interviewed in the
main feature; I am pleased to note that this is all new material, with no
repeated footage from the documentary. It's nicely organized, with title
screens appearing to indicate the topic of that segment of the conversation. We
get to see Linus Torvalds, Richard Stallman, Brian Behlendorf, Michael Tiemann,
Bruce Perens, and Larry Augustin, as well as a segment from the panel
discussion on Open Source at the 1999 Linux World convention. It's possible to
select individual interviews, or to play them all continuously (using the
"continue" button, oddly enough).
The second major section of special features is the "Document
Files" section. Here we get the full text of a variety of documents related
to the Open Source movement. Of most note here is the inclusion of several key
documents that are referred to in Revolution OS: "The Cathedral and the
Bazaar," the article by Eric Raymond; the GNU General Public License; the
GNU Manifesto; and the Open Source Definition, version 1.9. We also get the
lyrics to the "Free Software Song" (OK, I could have done without
that) and Richard Stallman's initial announcement. The one drawback to this
otherwise excellent collection of documents is that they're displayed in a
not-very-user-friendly white font on various colored backgrounds.
A section of
"Biographies" has (not surprisingly) biographies of the principal
players mentioned in the documentary. Hidden at the end of the biographies
section, though, is another useful feature: a list of additional resources on
Linux and Open Source topics.
Finally, we also get a photo
gallery and the full music video of the "Free Software Song," in case
you really couldn't get enough of it.
Final thoughts
Don't be fooled by the fairly
specialized topic of Revolution OS: this is a well-done documentary that
will be of interest to anyone who's curious about computer-related topics,
whether they're an experienced techie who knows all about the Linux vs. Windows
debacle or just someone who's curious to know what all this "Open
Source" and "Free Software" stuff is all about. Revolution OS
shows not just the technical side of Linux's development, but also the
philosophical side, and as you'll see, ideas of community-building, sharing,
and encouraging creativity are at the heart of the GNU-Linux system. With a nice
widescreen transfer and a second disc packed with extras, Revolution OS
stands as a solid "recommended."
Buy: