Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



Christ in Concrete
aka  Give Us This Day

Christ in Concrete
(aka Give Us This Day)

All Day
1949 / b&w / 1:37 full frame / 116 min. / Christ in Concrete, Salt to the Devil / Street Date June 17, 2003 / 24.99
Starring Sam Wanamaker, Lea Padovani, Kathleen Ryan, Charles Goldner, Bonar Colleano, Bill (William) Sylvester, Nino Pastellides (George Pastell), Philo Hauser, Sid James, Karel Stepanek, Ina De La Haye, Rosalie Crutchley
Cinematography C.M. Pennington-Richards
Art Direction Alex Vetchinsky
Film Editor John D. Guthridge
Original Music Benjamin Frankel
Written by Ben Barzman from the novel by Pietro Di Donato
Produced by Nat A. Bronsten, Edward Dmytryk, Rod E. Geiger
Directed by Edward Dmytryk

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

All Day has outdone itself with this release, an almost totally unknown film of excellent quality and considerable significance. The 1949 Christ in Concrete was hounded from American screens after one or two bookings. Its director, writer, and several cast members filmed it in England after being driven from Hollywood by the blacklist. This absorbing emotional experience is a socially conscious scream by artists not yet ready to surrender. The disc cover calls it a 'suppressed master work', which for once is no exaggeration.

Director Edward Dmytryk eventually recanted and named names, thus reclaiming a Hollywood career for himself while earning the scorn of those he betrayed. The result was that Christ in Concrete was never re-discovered. Except for two brief weeks in a tiny New York theater in 1949 and one museum showing in 1975, it has barely been shown in America -- and never shown on television. I doubt there are many who have heard of the picture. As English censors would not allow a title to go out with the word Christ in the title, it was changed to Give Us This Day at the last minute; All Day has stuck with the original title of the source book, a classic of 'proletarian fiction' that is thought to have been a core inspiration for the Italian neo-realism movement.

Beautifully cast, acted and directed from a sensitive and literate script, the picture plays like a classic. Unlike some other rediscovered oddities that could well have stayed hidden under the rug, this one's a keeper. All Day's excellent presentation is technically polished and ready to recommend to all.


Italian-American laborer Geremio (Sam Wanamaker) works as a bricklayer on dangerous construction jobs with his friends Luigi (Charles Goldner), Julio (Bonar Colleano), Giovanni (William Sylvester) and DeLucey (George Pastell "Nino Pastellides"). When Geremio's best girl Kathleen (Kathleen Ryan) refuses to marry him because he has no ambition beyond his work, he asks Luigi to send to Italy for the young Annuziata (Lea Padovani) to be his bride. Annunziata's one condition before coming is that Geremio must have a house of his own, but Geremio can't wait and lies to her in a letter. Their meeting and wedding is a joyous success. She forgives him and they start to save for a house from his meagre salary while living in a tenement and raising children. But economic events cripple their plans, and worse, tempt him to betray his fellow workers.

This is a superior movie and a moving, strongly felt drama that needs a major rediscovery. It's an unsentimental tale of very sentimental people struggling to subsist in a harsh world. Based on a classic 'proletarian' novel, it stays refreshingly free of nostalgic reveries and fatuous homilies about the virtues of hard labor. Geremio's community of bricklayers hangs together when pulling for the common good, and fails miserably when the depression pits them against one another. Geremio is no Communist, but he is part of a guild of workers who fully understand what exploitation is -- in this case, shaving profit corners by forcing unsafe conditions on laborers.

Christ in Concrete is a religious allegory. The artwork on the cover of the book is a crown of thorns around a pick and shovel. Direct Christ parallels usually fall flat on their faces but this one is handled beautifully. There's a visual reference to the Pietà, and a strange moment of self-mutilation clearly meant to represent a stigmata. Hero Geremio calls out in agony for help and forgiveness, conveying the idea that Christ's experience is in all of us.

In the blacklist-crazed late 40s a film didn't have to spout anti-capitalist slogans to be refused exhibition. Movies concerned with working realities always walked on thin ice. When old James Cagney pictures examined poverty, they treated it in Horatio Alger terms. Slums were a great place to learn character and were prime breeding grounds for priests and violin soloists. Movies implying that basic social change might be needed just didn't get made. Over at MGM, labor concerns were often portrayed as Red agitation i see 1935's Riffraff, where we are invited to cheer as thug Spencer Tracy roughs up a labor organizer. Christ in Concrete was met with protests and pickets (according to the liner notes) when weakling distributor Eagle-Lion tried to book it in the states. I wouldn't be surprised if the majors didn't tag the film as Commie Propaganda as soon as it was offered to them for release. The show doesn't narrow its viewpoint to the approved movie fantasy of happy American living.

Labeling individual movies as 'pinko' was a quiet game played in top studio offices and then screamed out in newspaper 'editorials'. Nobody actually studied films to see what was subversive. Individual artists were blacklisted by hearsay, innuendo and malicious rumors. It was decades before film scholars examined the films made by blacklisted leftists. When one scratches a Dalton Trumbo or an Abraham Polonsky film, one finds Humanist and Internationalist themesm not Communist propaganda. Although some of its bricklayers wear curious, unidentified badges, Christ in Concrete never mentions unions. It's more concerned with human basics, and even with its allegorical edge is more honest and direct about the struggle of those on the bottom of the American Dream than anything I've seen. It's the picture Barton Fink, if he had talent, would have given his left arm to write.  3

Christ in Concrete is almost shockingly well made. When one thinks of socially committed films by blacklisted talent, what comes to mind are well intentioned but comparatively amateurish efforts such as Abner Biberman's Salt of the Earth. For production and aesthetics, Christ in Concrete can stand alongside any of its contemporaries. The production is technically very sophisticated.

Except for some back plates behind the titles, the New York - set Christ in Concrete was filmed entirely at Denham studios in England. It's a remarkable job of recreation -- tenement streets, construction sites and family saloons of the twenties all look more authentic than they do in Hollywood pictures. Cameraman C.M. Pennington-Richards stages an opening scene 40 stories up in a building under construction using rear-projected plates of New York, and somehow makes the lighting look like bright daylight instead of a studio interior. At night the movie resembles a classic film noir, with ominous animated clouds moving behind sinister buildings. By day it's an Italian neo-realist film (but with a sturdier tripod).  2

The performances are sensational. Lead Sam Wanamaker (The Criminal, Superman IV) is compelling as the life-loving bricklayer who desperately wants a wife. Even when given slightly expressionist actions to perform, he comes through. Lea Padovani is the soul of the film -- the two of them easily give the best performances of 1949. Italian actress Padovani helps center the film on the Italian immigrant experience. The producers almost sent her back when they discovered she couldn't speak English, but she learned her part phonetically and kept the role. Kathleen Ryan plays the other woman faultlessly, adding a third classic noir performance to her work in Carol Reed's Odd Man Out and Cy Endfield's Try and Get Me!.  1

The supporting cast includes a number of great English talents. 'Bill Sylvester' is William Sylvester, the actor known for his calm performance in 2001: A Space Odyssey. Here he's lively and convincing as an Italian worker. And 'Nino Pastellides' is really George Pastell, the all-purpose Middle Easterner instantly recognizable from the later Hammer films The Mummy and The Stranglers of Bombay, and the Bond film From Russia With Love. Bonar Colleano is familiar as 'the American' in many English films, especially as a flyer in A Matter of Life and Death. Charles Goldner is a chameleon that steals as many scenes in this picture as he did in the Alec Guinness comedy The Captain's Paradise.

Only the child actor portraying the bricklayer's eldest son betrays an English accent. Sidney James (Trapeze, Quatermass 2, the Carry On Movies) sounds like a Yank instead of his usual Cockney. Scandinavian Karel Stepanek (Sink the Bismarck!) does an excellent job as the owner of the house our hero tries to buy.

Director Edward Dmytryk made impressive films before the blacklist, like Crossfire and Murder My Sweet, and mostly CinemaScope junk afterwards. Potential classic Raintree County was ruined by blah camera direction and The Young Lions just looks cheap. Here, working in a foreign country before his sellout to the HUAC, Dmytryk easily does his best work, both with the actors and with the camera. Angles and compositions are inspired and unforced, and the construction montages are amazing.

All Day's DVD of Christ in Concrete is their classiest presentation yet. The 35mm source element has some fine scratches and one slight splice, but is a sharp 35mm source given a very good encoding job. It's easy to appreciate the fine lighting and Benjamin Frankel's impressive score. It is isolated on a separate track, with commentary by original book author Pietro di Donato.

The other extras are a gold mine of insights and revelations. Norma Barzman, the screenwriter's widow, is the star attraction on a commentary shared with the author's son Richard di Donato, academic Fred Gardaphe, and All Day's own David Kalat, who keeps the sometimes contentious ensemble on task. Richard explains how Christ in Concrete was his father's attempt to tell the story of his grandfather, who died in a Manhattan construction accident in the early 1920s. He also positions the book as a key piece of literature in the Italian-American experience, a direct inspiration for the Neorealist film movement in Italy. Norma's story of the Blacklist is one of the best first-hand accounts I've heard. Still fiery on the subject, she's an original 'progressive' from the 30s who has opinions on everything from Edward Dmytryk's commitment to leftist ideals, to movies about the blacklist, like Guilty by Suspicion. The group has a fascinating anecdote or fact to offer for every scene.

On side B of the disc are even more extras. Eli Wallach recites a spoken word opera version of Christ in Concrete by Harold Seletsky, from a 1965 record. A short featurette is an illustrated interview with Peter di Donato by film scholar Bill Wasserzieher. There are also some home movie videos of Pietro di Donato from the early 90s, text talent bios and a photo gallery that includes a rare poster or two, plus snapshots of the lone Manhattan theater that played the film late in 1949. For the even more curious, there's a wealth of documentation about the film's development, production and distribution (or lack thereof) in a DVD-Rom supplement.

Just when a reviewer gets complacent, along comes a major DVD find like Christ in Concrete. This disc takes its place with All Day's 1,000 Eyes of Dr. Mabuse and Ganja and Hess, Anchor Bay's Queen of Hearts and Kino's Dementia/Daughter of Horror. Unlike the other titles, this stunning film is virtually unknown in cinema circles ... hopefully it won't be for long. The blacklist nightmare appears to have been a Black Hole into which careers and films disappeared wholesale; Christ in Concrete makes us want to examine more movies between WW2 and the early 50s, to find more gems at the edge of the political abyss.

On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, Give Us This Day aka Christ in Concrete rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Commentary, spoken-opera recital, featurette, home videos, photo gallery.
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: June, 2003


1. Irish actress Kathleen Ryan played the downtrodden girlfriend of James Mason in the allegorical Odd Man Out, which ends with a mercy killing. In the equally allegorical Christ in Concrete, she's a Mary Magdalene figure. In Try and Get Me! Ryan plays the innocent suffering wife of an unemployed man who sinks into robbery and murder. Kathleen Ryan is the unsung angel of late 40s subversive cinema.

2. Participants in the supplemental commentary assert that all of the film's exteriors were done on interior sound stages, when they really look like well-shot exterior scenes. On one four-story set of a crumbling building being demolished, the claim is made that the hard one-shadow lighting was achieved by four massed arc lights up in the corner of the stage. It's really tough to believe this, as there's no reason the sets couldn't have been built outdoors, in the space between the stages. But the wife of the screenwriter and the other experts seem very sure of themselves, and provide compelling details such as the fact that the London weather wasn't reliable enough to shoot outdoors. I've seen quad arc lights at work - they don't throw hard shadows like these. But I'm not a lighting expert, and I wasn't there, they were ...

3. Christ in Concrete has some things in common with It's a Wonderful Life. There's a similar flashback structure, with the hero caught in a terrible bind. Then we go back ten years or so to see how it came about. The flashback functions well here, because as the enthusiastic couple work toward their dream house, we already know something's going to prevent them from getting it, and their happy life might go down in ruins. Just like the Capra film, there's a key scene where the distraught hero can't deal with a noisy house of kids, and takes his problems elsewhere to make a bad decision (jump off a bridge/see another woman). The telling difference is that Annunziata encourages Geremio to go off by himself to think, whereas Frank Capra has the loving Mary Bailey break character and send George Bailey away with a harsh rebuke.

Note from Avie Hern, 6.19.03:
... as regards Christ in Concrete, I had the privilege of seeing the film in 1984 or '85 with Edward Dmytryk when he taught at AFI. Just to point out something that no one who hadn't been there that day would know or suspect, in the scenes that take place high in the building skeletons there are several, shall we call them, "glyphs" chalked on the I-beams, numbers preceded by the letters "C.P." Obviously to be taken by the casual viewer -- if he/she notices them at all -- as some kind of part or section numbers for the film's construction workers, "C.P." was actually shorthand for "Communist Party," as Dmytryk gleefully informed us. He was quite good at informing, as you well know; this before he recanted his Party membership and named names to HUAC in order to save his own skin.

DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2007 Glenn Erickson

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Release List Reviews Price Search Shop SUBSCRIBE Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise