Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Lidsville - Complete Series

Warner Music // Unrated // January 25, 2005
List Price: $39.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted January 26, 2005 | E-mail the Author
The Series:

Lidsville hit the nation's airwaves in 1972, courtesy of those wacky brothers, Sid and Marty Kroft, creators of such classic (albeit, trippy) kids shows as Land Of The Lost and H. R. Pufnstuf. If you thought those shows were odd, and they were, well Lidsville was even stranger. In short, it was the koo-koo-kookiest.

The basic idea behind the series is this:

A young man named Mark (Butch Patrick, better known as Eddie Munster from TVs The Munsters) decides to look inside a magician's hat after witnessing a magic show. The hat grows, and he falls inside of it and is whisked away to the strange land of Lidsville. In Lidsville, everyone is a hat except for an evil magician named Hoo Doo (Charles Nelson Reilly… this man needs no introdction and if you don't know who he is you're simply not doing your homework). Hoo Doo causes all sorts of problems for the population of Lidsville. He wants them to acknowledge him as their master and enforces his will by employing a gang of bad hats who act as thugs and do his dirty work.

At any rate, Mark finds himself stuck in Lidsville, unable to return to the normal world from which he was spawned. Luckily, he becomes fast friends with the citzens of Lidsville, as well as a genie who was formerly in Hoo Doo's employ. Each week a new adventure would present itself to Mark, more often than not in the form of a way for him to get back to his homeworld, and each week Hoo Doo would try and spoil it for him for one reason or another.

Aside from the obvious novelty of seeing a troupe of midgets running around in crazy giant hat costumes, many of whom are so racially stereotypical as to almost cringe inducing at times (just listen to the Native Indian hat and the Chinese Hat speak!), Lidsville also has some wacky Chroma-key effects, a strange theme song, and some very cool sets. Anyone who ever watched HBO's Mr. Show and remember the Drugatoushetts sketch will see some obvious similarities to Lidsville and some of the ideas here, like the tiny band that lives in Hoo Doo's headquarters, were very likely the inspiration for some of the bits used on Pee-Wee's Playhouse some twenty years later.

While the show is extrememly imaginitive and very much so a one of a kind series, sadly, this isn't top tier Kroft Brothers material. Butch doesn't make for a very charismatic hero (though he has very nice hair), and despite Charles Nelson Reilly's best efforts, he's not a particularly menacing villain either. The hats are pretty cool when they zip into fast forward to get things done on time and some of the more interesting hat characters, like the John Wayne ten gallon hat and the pith helment English explorer hat are a lot of fun, but then others like the grandmother on the motorbike are simply annoying.

Highlights to the series include Hoo Doo's flying hat attack, where Reilly zips around Lidsville in an upside down top hat shooting fireballs out of his hands at the citizens of Lidsville, Mark's spirally fall into the magical hatland in the opening credits, and seeing some of the bad hats menace the good hats in typical 'you dirty rat' fashion.

Disc One contains World In A Hat, Show Me The Way To Go Home, Fly Now Vacume Later, Weenie Weenie Where's Our Genie?, Let's Hear It For Whizzo, Is There A Mayor In The House?, and Take Me To Your Rabbit.

Disc Two contains Have I Got A Girl For Hoo Doo, Mark And The Bean Stalk, Turn In Your Turban – You're Through!, Alias The Imperial Wizard, A Little Hoo Doo Goes A Long Way, Oh Brother, and Hoo Doo Who?.

Disc Three contains The Old Hat Home, The Great Brain Robbery, and Mommy Hoo Doo.

The show was very much a product of its time and it has 'early seventies' stamped all over it from the clothes to the music to the special effects. This lends the series a nice nostaligic feel to it that elevates it a little bit when you actually think about the quality of the episodes themselves (which aren't all that good in reality). The show is fun and it has a few things working in its favor but it's far more likely to be enjoyed by seventies nostalgia buffs than some of the better Kroft shows which stand well on their own without the kitsch factor taken into account.

The DVD

Video:

The fullframe 1.33.1 image is merely adequate, and hardly spectacular. The stock footage used in the opening credits looks pretty rough (as does the opening credits sequence in general) showing some serious wear and tear and print damage. Once you get to the actual episodes, things do improve a bit, but still aren't exactly reference quality. The show was shot on tape and it shows, as the image is quite soft and slightly faded. Thankfully the print damage that plagues the opening credits isn't a problem on the actual episodes proper. The colors look like they could have been bumped up a bit in the brightness department and the skin tones look just a tad too pale (unless that's Butch Patrick natural complexion, and maybe it is – he was pretty pasty faced in The Munsters - ba dump bump – thank you, I'll be here all week).

Sound:

The English language Dolby Digital Mono track is of average quality for an older television show. There are no closed captioning, alternate language or subtitle options but the English track, which is the original mix, sounds good enough for what it is. There is some background hiss noticeable in a few spots but it's only minor even when it is there. The musical score, which starts to get really annoying after hearing it over and over again, does come through with a little bit of punch and fidelity but the dialogue is pretty flat as are most of the sound effects and foley effects used throughout the series.

Extras:

One disc one, World In A Hat has a commentary from Sid and Marty Kroft, while Show Me The Way To Go Home has a commentary with Butch Patrick. What is obvious at first in the Kroft Brothers commentary is that they loved this show. They're very happy to have been involved in it and seem to really enjoy the fruits of their labors in this series. They've got a few interesting stories to tell about where some of their rather odd ideas for the show came from as well as their roles in making it all happen, but more often than not they're just having a good time reminiscing about it all. Patrick's commentary is pretty interesting, if a little more straightforward – he's got a pretty good memory and has more than a couple of interesting recollections about the show. Seeing as he was a lot younger than most of the other cast members involved, his take on things is a little different than the adults who were involved.

One disc two, Have I Got A Girl For Hoo Doo has a commentary from Billie Hayes and Butch Patrick that is also pretty interesting. The two have a decent chemistry together and share a few good stories about working together on set.

On disc three The Old Hat Home has another solo commentary from Butch Patrick. Again, this is worth a listen, even if it is more of the same. Patrick has enough to say on each of his three commentaries that none of them ever get boring and this track is no exception. Also on this disc are video interviews with Butch Patrick, Billie Hayes, and the one and only Charles Nelson Reilly. Why Reilly wasn't tapped for a commentary is anyone's guess but it's a shame that he wasn't as he's just as strange and amusing on this interview as he ever was. I don't know that I'm so much a Charles Nelson Reilly fan, but he is an interesting man and this roughly fifteen minute interview is good, but a commentary or two would have been better. The interviews with Patrick and Hayes are also quite interesting, though sometimes they cover some of the same material that their commentary tracks did.

Rounding out the extra features are a batch of excerpts from Butch Patrick's scrap album detailing some of his experiences on set at the time that the show was in production – this is basically a still gallery.

Final Thoughts:

While the audio and video on Rhino's release of Lidsville – The Complete Series leaves a little to be desired, the extras are pretty interesting and equally amusing. How much you dig the show will very much depend on your tolerance for the Kroft's unique brand of Chroma-Key effects and bizarre puppets and costumes but Lidsville is definitely unique if nothing else. Kroft fans already know that they want this and it's a no-brainer for them, others might want to rent it first.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links