DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Ultra HD
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Sponsored Links

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Hoodwinked!
The Weinstein Company // PG // May 2, 2006
List Price: $29.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Bill Gibron | posted April 23, 2006 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly
The Product:
In the world of computer generated animation, there are at least three so-called standards. Each one bears the name of the company that created it. On one side you have the Pixar permutation – smart, imaginative and overloaded with delicious detail. Then there are the dreary Dreamworks dynamic – filmmaking bloated with stunt casting, pop culture references, and dated derivative jokes. Then there are the Fox facets – movies that are usually beautiful to look at, but completely flat when it comes to intelligence or humor. Perhaps these less than successful cinematic schemes explain why the recent independent animated film Hoodwinked! struck such a chord with moviegoers. Instead of functioning as a merchandising mechanism for a Hollywood studio's bottom line, filmmakers Cory and Todd Edwards have crafted an original, innovative take on the classic tale of Little Red Riding Hood. While they can't match the big boys in processing power, they are leaps and bounds above them in sly wit and a non-formulaic sense of fun.

The Plot:
When Red arrives at her Grandmother's house, she instantly senses that something's not right. The figure in the bed with the big eyes, big ears and big hands claims to be her aged relative, but the fur covered arms and massive mouth full of razor sharp fangs seems to indicate otherwise. Sure enough, the Wolf has taken Granny's place, and is intent on trapping Red for his own 'purposes'. But before he can make his move, a tied-up Granny breaks free from the closet and tries to protect her granddaughter. A melee ensues, and just as it seems that the Wolf will win, a woodsman breaks through the front window, axe raised…

Cut to a police car. Chief Grizzly and Det. Bill Stork soon arrive on the scene, asking a lot of questions about the dust-up and a so-called scourge known as the Goodie Bandit. Accusations fly, and soon everyone is a suspect. When private dick Nicky Flippers shows up to interrogate the group, he gets four different stories about the events that transpired – and they all seem connected to a rash of recipe robberies and the sudden shut down of most of the forest's snack shacks. Of course, each player in this surreal charade has a secret they are hiding, and it's up to Flippers to discover their cover before the Goodie Bandit destroys the region's cottage industry. Thankfully, this Rashamon-esque mystery is being handled by the one detective frog that won't be Hoodwinked!.

The DVD:
Buried somewhere in the morass between Pixar's perfection, Dreamworks dreariness and Fox's…well, Fox's follies, is Hoodwinked!. Clever, cloying and just a wee bit overconfident, this independent treasure argues for, not against, the future of the digitally created cartoon. While Disney tries to emulate its pixel partner with half-hearted efforts like Chicken Little, the outsider arena of animation has been trying to make inroads into the genre for years. Down in Florida, Bruce Barry and his Wacky World Studios have used the computer-based format to re-imagine Bible stories, all within an incredibly inventive insect society. The resulting efforts, found under the Roach Approach tag, prove that small budget attempts at animation can be just as creative – or more so – than their multi-million dollar equivalent. Now comes Cory and Todd Edwards. Novice filmmakers at best (Cory is a comic and actor, while Todd is a songwriter/musician), this duo (along with co-director Tony Leech) had a desire to emulate the productions of old (especially the resplendent Rankin-Bass oeuvre of '60s and '70s) and together with as much computing power that they could afford, they wanted to forge their own digital domain. They have definitely succeeded with this sunny, surreal take on that red hooded heroine and the whole wolf/granny ordeal.

This is not a big budget production, however. The last minute acquisition by the former Miramax men – Harvey and Bob Weinstein – gave Hoodwinked! an injection of legitimacy that helped it over some incredibly tough technical hurdles. It allowed Leech and the Edwards boys to invest their film with as much personality and style as possible. Instead of homogenizing everything to fit a predetermined marketing ideal, Hoodwinked! rambles on insanely. It tries things other cartoons wouldn't dare, and indulges in inside jokes and references that only the filmmakers could find funny. This means, of course, that the final product will be picked apart by those looking for loopholes in the lunacy. There will be many who mock the less than successful CGI, a sloppy sort of style that renders humans rather bulky and blocky while certain members of the animal side of things (especially Boingo the bunny) come across as completely convincing. Others will look at the script, loaded with tricky, topical humor and some danger-filled action scenes and question the age appropriateness of the content. But perhaps the biggest stumbling block for those who decide to give this indie offering a try is the fact that it's not a recognizable product from one of the big animation machines. It is its own eccentric animal, something we're just not used to in the world of computerized cartooning.

It has to be said that Hoodwinked! looks a little second rate, what with its lack of tactile textures and complex character mapping. A good example of this dearth of detail arrives in two of our main characters – Granny and Kirk the Woodsman. Our lumberjack in training has a moon-shaped face, complete with a bright red beard curling at the end of his chin. Yet during most of the movie, you can't tell if he's sporting facial hair, or just a stain left over from eating too much cherry cobbler. Granny's issues are a little more extreme. Since her character turns out to be an X-Games loving daredevil, we hope to see some sleek, slick action when the old bird hits the ski slopes. But since they were hobbled by bitrate issues, many of the more amazing sequences lack that little extra 'umph' that a company like Pixar or Fox adds to the approach. When we learn that the entire production was premised on the stop-motion animation holiday specials of the past, we become more accepting of the visual's limitations. Still, anyone who enjoys the photorealistic quality of a computer generated cartoon will undeniably find Hoodwinked! to be a disappointment. Oddly enough, the tech specs on display here are really no worse than those of the original Toy Story. In fact, some of the scenes out shine that initial effort from Pixar.

With all that said, there are still dozens of pleasures to be had here. Andy Dick delivers a knockout performance as Boingo the bunny (he was so good in fact, this critic didn't recognize the voice until he saw the comic actor reading lines as part of the making-of material). He gets completely lost in the well-meaning, if megalomaniacal character, and the animation matches his boffo performance note for note. Equally impressive is Xzibit, dropping most of his pimped out persona to deliver a solid spoof as the 'know it all' police officer, Chief Grizzly. Patrick Warburton plays the Wolf as a deadpan derivative of Fletch, even down to the many mindless costume changes, and David Ogden Stiers is sensational as Nicky Flippers, frog PI. Along with the exceptional acting, there is the equally amazing music. Todd Edwards has fashioned some fabulous jangle rock gems here, tunes that will instantly get your toes tapping and your heart pumping. Especially good are Red's "Great Big World" (it sounds like an outtake from a Jane Wiedlin solo album), the crazed horned goat hootenanny "Be Prepared" and the beautiful ballad "Red is Blue" (featuring the voice of none other than Ben Folds). While it's kind of a cliché that all animated movies must have music, Hoodwinked! is the first to make the songs less Broadway and more Brill Building.

Yet it's the crazy characters that will endure, staying with you long after the narrative and underscoring disappear from your mind. Boingo the bunny is so smarmy and self-centered that he comes across as a truly wicked wabbit. Similarly, the hyperactive squirrel sidekick of the Wolf, a chattering little cherry bomb named Twitchy, literally steals every scene he is in. The evil children that join the Woodsmen in his celebration of schnitzel are like the forbidden offspring of a Cabbage Patch/Garbage Pail marriage, and Japeth the Goat has the only interchangeable horns in the entire anthropomorphic world of cartoon characters. His set-piece song in which he shows off his collection of transposable head accessories is fantastic. Indeed, once you get past the problem of the film's look (which actually disappears upon second and THIRD viewings) Hoodwinked! becomes a quasi-classic, a refreshingly irreverent raspberry to all the 'filmmaking by committee' we see in the animated efforts of the bland big wigs. Instead of listening to test scores and focus groups, the creators behind this film have followed their own idiosyncratic ideals. The incredibly entertaining results put to shame the mostly mediocre movies being passed off as fun family fare.

The Video:
As one of the first DVD offerings from the Weinstein Company, the digital presentation of Hoodwinked! is excellent. The 1.85:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer (there is also a full screen disc available separately, but why bother) is sensational. The colors are crisp, the details are dense, and the overall production avoids standard image issues – flaring, bleeding, ghosting – to deliver a crystal clear picture.

The Audio:
Perfectly balanced between effects and dialogue, the Dolby Digital 5.1 mix is very well done. It offers up a nice woodland atmosphere during the outdoor sequences and delivers easily discernible dialogue in the interior scenes. The subwoofers do get a workout during the action elements in the film, and the songs sound great in this multi-channel presentation. As with the visual side of the disc, the aural aspect is also top notch.

The Extras:
Though the disc is rather light on overall added content, the bonus features found on Hoodwinked! are still a lot of fun. First up, we have a full length audio commentary with Cory Edwards, Todd Edwards and co-director Tony Leech. Genial, jokey and loaded with behind the scenes insight, the discussion dips and dives between true technical talk (the movie began with a $5000 investment and a couple of computers) and a bevy of insider information (who characters are based on, what it was like working with the actors). We learn about several deleted sequences (almost all missing for budgetary reasons) and how improvising helped build the character arcs. While not nearly as self-congratulatory as they imagine it is, this is still a proud group of men fussing over their amazing animated "child". The results can be a little overbearing, but in a totally good natured manner.

Additional material arrives in the form of some actual deleted footage, though sadly, most of it is nothing more than a few seconds snipped out of the film's songs (there is optional commentary included here as well). Along with a music video for the tune "Critters Have Feelings", and a few trailers, the most excited supplement is a 12 minute featurette on how Hoodwinked! came about, entitled "How to Make an Animated Movie". Here we learn about the total process, from conception to voice casting. The information is presented, Q&A style, via many in the cast and crew. Though it occasionally lapses into EPK territory, it's a nice overview of Hoodwinked!'s many trials and tribulations.

Final Thoughts:
Missing the vaunted DVD Talk Collector's Series scoring by a scant few tech and plot points, Hoodwinked! is still easily rated as Highly Recommended. This is a movie that truly gets better with multiple viewings, each one amplifying the effort and imagination that went into every aspect of the production. So while Dreamworks drags out Shrek for another tale within the ogre/donkey dynamic, and Fox finds more ways to meld art with ennui, and as Disney dreads the day Pixar really picks up its digital ball and goes home for good, there is no need to fret. Battling for recognition along the outskirts of the animation arena are films like Hoodwinked!. Just as with other genres inside the independent movement, the availability of professional quality technology will eventually mean that there will be more examples of this kind of cartooning, and (hopefully) less of the corrosion of conformity derived from animation via audience testing. Frankly, it's better to see something that's problematic if original vs. another example of safe, superficial storytelling. Hoodwinked! has its issues, but it definitely deserves to find its niche among film fans. It is a great deal of fun.

Want more Gibron Goodness? Come to Bill's TINSEL TORN REBORN Blog (Updated Frequently) and Enjoy! Click Here

Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2019 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use