DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Ultra HD
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Sponsored Links

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » The Vanishing: Criterion Collection
The Vanishing: Criterion Collection
Criterion // Unrated // September 18, 2001
List Price: $29.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Adam Tyner | posted October 29, 2001 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly
Ah, the things the ignorant can discover through the boundless source of information that is the Internet. Up until a few scant months ago, I hadn't the faintest idea that the 1993 Kiefer Sutherland vehicle The Vanishing was a remake of a Dutch film also directed by George Sluizer some five years earlier. Also known as Spoorloos and L'Homme qui voulait savoir, the 1988 Dutch/French co-production of Tim Krabbé's novel The Golden Egg had previously been released on DVD courtesy of Fox Lorber. The aged full-frame transfer impressed few, and Internet discussion forums were abuzz a few months ago when it was announced The Vanishing would be revisited as part of the Criterion Collection. Though the name 'Criterion' most often is associated with a slew of supplemental material, this relatively featureless disc offers such an excellent film and spectacular video quality that it's hard to feel disappointed at the lack of extras. Though I'm almost certainly welcoming a barrage of hate mail by saying this, I wouldn't mind seeing more discs like this from Criterion in the future. Supplemental material is nice and always welcomed, but given the choice between a handful of feature-packed, pricey collections and a larger number of meticulously restored films on barebones discs, I'd gladly take the latter.

The essentials of the plot don't sound terribly interesting or original on paper. Rex Hofman and Saskia Wagter are a young Dutch couple, cavorting around the French countryside with bicycles in tow. After a rather nasty situation where Rex leaves Saskia alone in a lengthy darkened tunnel in pursuit of gasoline, the two stop at a convenience store and relax a bit. Their argument long since smoothed over, Saskia offers to grab her love a beer, and Rex patiently waits outside for her return...and waits...and waits... A half-hour passes, and with no Saskia in sight, Rex frantically seeking help from everyone within earshot. No one takes his concerns seriously, dismissing the disappearance as a lover's quarrel, though Rex refuses to clutch onto that seemingly obvious answer. Obsessed with his quest, Rex spends the next three years feverishly searching, putting up numerous posters and making appearances on local talk shows, hellbent on uncovering answers wherever they may lie. His tunnel vision is more than his new love can stand, and just as the overwrought Rex seems on the verge of snapping, his torment may be at an end. His lover's assailant, who has stayed in constant and increasingly close contact with Rex, reveals himself, offering Rex the opportunity to discover Saskia's fate. The catch? Rex has to undergo exactly what Saskia endured or spend the rest of his life dealing with the uncertainty.

The 1993 remake of The Vanishing is almost universally reviled, though I didn't have nearly as negative an impression as most when I rented it years ago. Having this Criterion release in my hands now, I sorely wish I hadn't bothered with Sluizer's Americanized version. Most of the twists and turns in the original are duplicated, though to a far inferior extent, in the remake, which made it a bit more difficult for me to appreciate the ingenuity and more distinguished craftsmanship in Sluizer's first attempt at bringing this story to the silver screen. The majority of suspense films, particularly those of the past decade, follow the same hackneyed structure -- some lovely young lady is brtually murdered or spirited far away, her relentlessly pursued boyfriend/husband seeks the truth, numerous red herrings are tossed out to throw our easily misled hero off the trail, and the culprit's identity is revealed moments before a climatic battle resulting in the villain's gruesome and laughably over-the-top demise. The Vanishing tosses those conventions aside. The audience knows from the get-go who's responsible, and not because of bad storytelling. "Who?" rarely turns out to be as compelling a question as "how?" or "why?", and this is where the mystery lies. The linear unfolding so prevalent in its genre brethren is similarly eschewed, and though The Vanishing plays loose with time and various events, it never comes in the form of cornball flashbacks or a fade to a three-minute clip shortly before the sociopath gets his comeuppance. The film also isn't bogged down by the need for the sort of exceedingly happy Hollywood ending that spoiled its 1993 revisioning. The Vanishing is a brilliant, well-crafted psychological thriller in the truest sense, and its presentation on DVD from Criterion is nearly as free of flaws as the film itself.

Video: A couple weeks back, a member of DVD Talk posted a pair of screen caps comparing and contrasting the new Criterion release with the full-frame DVD from Fox Lorber. The differences between the two teeter on night-and-day, absolutely worthy of a repurchase by owners of the previous disc. Unfortunately, as I write this, those comparative images are gone, or else I'd have reproduced them here. I suppose you're stuck taking my word for it that the Criterion disc offers a remarkable amount of additional detail, as well as quite a bit of information on each side of the image. The source material used for this transfer, a 35mm low-contrast print, is in absolutely immaculate condition, with nary a flaw to be found. Even the presence of tiny flecks of dust is kept to a bare minimum, only recognizable for all of a few seconds near the end of the film, and even then not to any distracting extent. No print flaws, edge haloing, or compression artifacts were noticeable in the slightest, and the level of grain is appropriate and entirely unintrusive. Blacks are deep and inky, and the subdued color palette, with a handful of brief exceptions, seems to be an accurate reproduction. The level of detail is remarkable, a vast improvement over the soft, muddy, washed-out appearance of the Fox Lorber release.

Audio: The Dolby Digital mono soundtrack is driven almost entirely by dialogue, so there's little need for the roar of a subwoofer or numerous split-surround effects. As a mono track, it's perfectly serviceable, with no hiss or distortion whatsoever. Sounds are perfectly balanced, with the keyboard-heavy score and various effects never intruding on conversations and the like. Though dialogue is in both Dutch and French, there are thankfully no burned-in subtitles to distract from the optional English player-generated subs.

Supplements: The only extra on the DVD itself is a subtitled full-frame trailer, though an insert with a brief essay is included with the disc.

Conclusion: Though it's trite to compare modern suspense films to Hitchcock's impressive body of work, it's almost unavoidable in the case of The Vanishing. Though light on the sort of supplemental material on which Criterion has built its reputation, the film itself, bolstered with a stunning visual presentation and a respectable mono track, are far more than worth the $25 or so you're likely to pay for this disc online. Highly recommended.
Other Reviews:
Popular Reviews
1. Blue Collar
2. Black Angel
3. Holiday (1938)
4. Brick (remastered)
5. The Nude Bomb
6. Fritz Lang's Indian Epic (The Tiger of Eschnapur & The Indian Tomb)
7. Kill Them All and Come Back Alone aka Ammazzali Tutti E Torna Solo
8. Abominable

Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2020 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use