Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Cottage on Dartmoor, A

Kino // Unrated // October 2, 2007
List Price: $29.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by John Sinnott | posted October 18, 2007 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:


Directed by Anthony Asquith (who would later direct the hilarious The
Importance of Being Earnest
), A Cottage on Dartmoor is a suspenseful
film that is an early forerunner of film noir, a proto-film noir if you
will.  It has much of the dark atmosphere and tension that noir films
are known for.  As Eddie Muller from the Film Noir Foundation commented
in his introductory to this film at the 2007 SF Silent Film Festival, it
would probably be a much better know film if the title wasn't so bland. 
If it had only been named "Straight Razor to the Throat" people would have
spent more effort seeking it out.

The
plot, told through a flashback, involves a barber's assistant, Joe (Uno
Henning), who is in love with the manicurist where he works, Sally (Norah
Baring.)  Sally isn't really that interested in Joe however so she
kindly resists his gentle advances.  Harry (Hans Adalbert Schlettow),
a farmer from Dartmoor, has also noticed Sally and he starts getting his
nails done just so he can spend some time with the attractive girl and
Joe gets jealous.  He follows them out to the movies, and when Sally
comes into work one day sporting an engagement ring, the barber gets so
enraged that he's about to burst.  Unfortunately Harry walks in at
that moment and asks Joe for a shave.  In one of the more suspenseful
scenes in silent movies, Joe places a straight razor against his rival's
throat...

This movie has a lot of the trademarks that would later be identified
in noir films.  There is a lot of sexual tension, a love triangle,
and dark, stylized lighting especially at the beginning and end of the
movie.  Most of the story, as already noted, is told through a flashback. 
It's also very gripping and one of the most suspenseful silent films that
I've seen.  If this was made in the 40's, there's no doubt that it
would be known as an excellent noir.



Asquith crafts a wonderful film.  He uses shadows and lighting
very effectively to create a mood and the shots he sets up and often beautiful. 
He also has some very nice edits that help move the film along while creating
some interesting images and comparisons.  In one such scene an escaped
convict has been seen running across the countryside and finds a pond of
water.  He stops and kneels down, drinking the water from his cupped
hands.  The camera focuses on the small waves in the pond, and then
pulls back to revel the wavy water from a bathtub that a baby has just
been pulled from.

The acting is very good also.  Filmed at the end of the silent
era, Henning and Baring are both restrained in their roles but really bring
their characters to life.  Especially Henning who has expressive eyes
that reveal exactly what he is thinking.


The DVD:




Audio:

Stephen Horne provides the accompaniment to this film on piano. 
His playing was magnificent and the score he came up with meshed perfectly
with the movie.  He was truly inspired with the theater scene too. 
At one point Sally and Harry go to the movies, followed by Joe.  They
laugh and cheer to a silent short, and then a talkie comes on.  When
it does, Horne stopped playing his piano.  That simple act really
brought home how talkies were a step backwards in many ways.  As the
musicians on the screen took a break, the excitement died down, and so
did the amount of entertainment.  Mimicking this effect was brilliant
and effective.  (Originally the film had a record that was supposed
to be played during this section to mimic the unseen actors on the screen. 
The sounds were muffled and the dialog incomprehensible.  This was
done to poke fun at the low fidelity sound that accompanied most films
in those days, but alas this audio has been lost.)

Video:

The full frame black and white image was outstanding.  The film
has been restored by the British Film Institute and they did a great job. 
The contrast is excellent, the detail is great, and the blacks are nice
and solid.  There was some slight blooming in a couple of spots, but
this was rare.

I suspect that this is a PAL to NTSC conversion however.  There
was some slight ghosting in a couple of scenes, but since this shows up
in fast moving sequences it doesn't mar this film as much as it could.

Extras:

Along with the feature film, there's also a full-length documentary,
Silent Britain written and hosted by Matthew Sweet.  This was
a nice accompaniment to the feature film and traces the history of British
cinema during through the silent era.  The main theme of the piece
is that early British filmmakers haven't gotten the credit they deserve
and that's probably true.

The
documentary is filled with clips from many early productions and Sweet
makes a strong case that British silents and been unduly ignored. 
Unfortunately there are several parts where he either gets things wrong
or makes some fairly wild claims.  In one section he says that Birth
of a Nation
(1915) was the first epic film.  What about Quo
Vadis?
(1912) and Cabiria (1914), both early Italian spectacles? 
Later on he implies that block booking (the practice that a theater had
to agree to take a studio's entire output rather than just selecting the
big pictures to show) was done to squeeze out British film makers from
their own country.  While I'm sure that Hollywood was pleased with
that result, it wasn't limited to the British market.  Block booking
was the standard practice even in America at the time, and to suggest that
it was done only to hurt British companies was totally wrong.  (The
program also refers to this, incorrectly, as "blind booking" since the
theater owners had to *gasp* agree to show a movie that they hadn't even
seen.  Of course even without block booking theaters have to schedule
films that the manager hasn't seen, so that change of title only serves
to misrepresent the matter further.)

Another odd claim that the documentary makes is that success Hitchcock
had with his early British films wasn't due to his ability as a director,
but because of the detailed scenarios written by Eliot Stannard. 
The fact that Hitchcock created a whole body of high quality films, the
vast majority without Stannard, solidly disproves this idea.  That
fact is never mentioned.  It's also curious that the film would question
the talent of the one big success story to come out of the British silent
era.

Even with these questionable claims, the documentary is a wealth of
information about early British Cinema.  Sweet profiles the major
directors and producers but also includes information of stars that were
wildly famous at the time but are sadly forgotten today.  Sweet includes
interviews with several of these stars that were conducted in the late
60's and 70's, and those are wonderful.  One heart-breaking segment
was Joan Morgan telling the story of how she was offered a contract with
a Hollywood studio.  Unfortunately her father forbade her to accept
it and it was easy to tell even in 1978 that this was the one great regret
in her life.

There's no doubt that British cinema in the early days has been largely
ignored.  This documentary, flawed though it is, does a lot to correcting
that mistake.

Final Thoughts:

This film was a hit at the 2007 SF Silent Film Festival and I'm glad
that it is available on DVD.  This would make an excellent movie to
screen for someone who hasn't been exposed to early film.  The story
is engaging and very suspenseful, the acting excellent and the direction
wonderful.  The sound and video quality are both excellent and the
documentary that is included as a bonus, while not perfect, is a very nice
introduction to early British cinema.  Together this is a great package
that comes Highly Recommended.

 

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Highly Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews
1. Friendsgiving
2. Isn't She Great
3. The Last Remake of Beau Geste
4. The Short History of the Long Road - Special Edition


Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links