DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Sponsored Links

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Southland Tales
Southland Tales
Sony Pictures // R // March 18, 2008
List Price: $24.96 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Thomas Spurlin | posted March 17, 2008 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
Rent It
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly
More than likely, you're probably familiar with director Richard Kelly's Donnie Darko if you're taking the time to discover his newest work, Southland Tales. If that's the case, then the scene in which an obscure, inexplicable stream of metaphysical goo stretching from Jake Gyllenhaal's sternum probably sticks out as a memorable and taxing piece of cinema. If you haven't seen the film, don't give it too much thought; nothing much has been ruined since that scene, even with all its theoretical analyses packed in before and afterwards, still lingers as a curiosity that's not completely discernible.

Southland Tales is, in essence, a lot like scooping up a heaping load of that strange material, slapping it on a glass slide with patriotically hued dyes to show its contents, and magnifying just the unexplainable and pensive bizarreness from his previous film. Donnie Darko challenges its viewers with erratic, albeit quite thematically consistent, science fiction mannerisms and psychological obstacles; Southland Tales, splattered in red, white, and blue anarchy across another brainstorm from Richard Kelly, manages to be visually and idealistically imaginative, but without a lick of cohesiveness.

The Film:

Southland Tales exists amidst a state of mania in an altered version of the United States of America. Three years prior to the timeframe surrounding the core narrative (2008), a nuclear explosion erupted in Texas that devastated the country. Following this "attack", the government tightened its control on security measures and privacy monitoring. As seen through the eyes of the film's extensive narrator, Private Pilot Abilene (Justin Timberlake), this includes gunmen strategically stapled across city skylines prepped to shoot anything they deem threatening. Along with the government's shifts in police stratagems, they also utilize a new level of visual monitoring, US-IDent, to keep tabs on internet broadcasts, monetary transactions, and overall everyday activity. Throughout these stringent surface-level changes, an upheaval brews in the depths; a ragtag cluster of Marxist revolutionaries plot and scheme against the government's oppressive weight in attempts to control this election year's outcome.

Richard Kelly brought his brain to the playing field when assembling Southland Tales, that's for sure. Set in this marginally futuristic America in 2008 amidst a new universal experiment for alternate fuel usage, it opts to deride the focus on the disappearance of a precious celebrity, Boxer (Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson), and his pathway that leads away from the superficialities of the modern world. While stricken with amnesia after an accident and shacking up with ex-adult movie star Krysta (Sarah Michelle Gellar), now the lead of a reality-based TV show, Boxer and his new main squeeze throw together a film screenplay that, oddly, prophesizes the way that the world will end. In the midst of both Boxer and Krysta trying to piece together how their film will financially and thematically be made, Boxer has the government, as well as a cranky lover (Mandy Moore) and her US Senator father (Holmes Osbourne), scanning the American landscape in search for him. Somehow, with Boxer's prophetic script and the words of Abilene echoing in the distance, the weight of the film gravitates towards Roland Taverner (Seann William Scott), a California cop whose relationship with his Marxist revolutionary twin brother, Ronald, will impact the fabric of the world itself.

Southland Tales, in its uneven satiric tone, exists in a densely layered, excessively over-thought environment that oozes from its pours with symbolism and critique on American culture and government society. Here, very little dodges Kelly's scathing eye - fuel consumption, citizen discomfort with overly stringent governmental control, the unnecessary mental damage inflicted on soldiers through overseas wars, both left and right wing critiques, et al. As such, nothing exists in the film without a purpose that tries to latch neatly onto its mutinous and writhing motives. Even in spite of this, Southland Tales still really tries to be a comedic insight on these points. Several choices in actors, namely a tight grasp onto numerous veterans from NBC's sketch-based Saturday Night Live (Cheri OTeri, Nora Dunn, John Lovitz, etc), lean the heavy-handed critical tone away for split seconds at a time towards a more, well, quirky layer. No matter whether it's a compliment or a detriment that the film cannot sidestep its serious topics enough to be humorous, either way it makes Southland Tales tonally uneven. There's simply too much going on in the film for it to dig in and remain focused.

It's a shame, because I can make out the bombastic and colorful pathway, even with the obscure musical numbers and unusual set design, that Kelly was trying to create with Southland Tales. He means for it to be a hybrid clash between comedic tonalities and pensive thought, and he achieves sputtering success much akin to a faulty Roman candle. I found the visuals, the music, half of the performances, and a handful of Kelly's more fleshed ideas reasonably engaging; the way it all comes together, however, is a lot like dumping a cartload of bright colors into a mixing pot and expecting a pinnacle hue of brilliance - only to see that the erratic mix folds into itself to produce nothing more than a gray mass of unrealized potential. In the midst of expansive, fathomless depth within its theories and projected connectivity about America's faults and contrivances, Southland Tales lacks the evocative core that would make its audience compelled to such a degree that they'd invest enough into its overblown complexity to make perfect sense of it all.

Everything upon everything in Kelly's film lampoons one another, creating a fa├žade that feels more like a charade than an indulgence. An ex porn chick chugs an energy beverage with her visage on it, while a blockbuster celebrity stands and fiddles with his fingers nervously in any hectic situation; examples like these rouse a few chuckles and invoke a thought or two through their over-the-top nature, but they also break linearization and identifiableness with the audience. It's a hard balance, especially when both Sarah Michelle Gellar and The Rock do such a good job of spilling their characters from the seams with their almost plasticized caricatures. William Scott and Timberlake, oddly, deliver two of the more downscale and fathomable characters, even when the material surrounding them teeters on the flat-out unfathomable. After Abilene's narration and biblical scripture references accompanied by CG schematics that illustrate how the past 3 years went down at the start of the film, the fabricated satiric qualities later on appear, on the surface, tangible even though they lack the substantial delivery to pour flesh into its concrete shell.

Southland Tales does, in fact, share some trippy successes similar to Richard Kelly's vastly superior Donnie Darko. As it gallops towards the finish line after an exhausting two-and-a-half hour endurance run, it keeps you roped in with its handful of insane, yet attractive, qualities. Afterwards, I was left fairly vapid with a giant question mark over my head over all its oddly aligned elements. Yet, that's a similar reaction many, including myself, felt after watching Kelly's other work. Much like Donnie Darko, I found myself contemplating Southland Tales several days afterwards and, with a little gumption, felt a shade more warmth towards its convoluted wirings. It still is deeply flawed and misbalanced with its tonal awareness, not to mention just downright blatantly odd in certain patches, but Southland Tales at least musters up the cojones to think as it does. It deserves marks for its introspective psychosis, but suffers in the end from misfired execution.

The DVD:

Southland Tales comes from Sony Pictures in a standard keepcase presentation with very attractive American flag-esque coverart. A sturdy slipcover adorns the case, yet the DVD inside sports some rather generic discart.

The Video:

This 2.40:1 anamorphic image for Southland Tales looks, in so many words, utterly fantastic. Lots of color and a ton load of detail fit into the competently photographed film, and Sony's disc certainly steps up to the plate with a boldly solid print. There's a fair amount of desaturated elements and bold saturations across the film's palette, both of which are handled aptly by the disc. There's so much happening on-screen that it's difficult to gauge digital solidity; however, in certain points when the camera stops moving erratically for a moment or two, the digital strength really shows through. Flesh tone differentials, such as the contrast between Dwayne Johnson and Seam William Scott in the police car and the like, really shine through with a lot of strength. Part of the effective poetry within Southland Tales comes from its relatively basic but fluidly lurid visuals, and this disc from Sony really makes certain to display each and every detail with incredible proficiency.

The Audio:

Hell, even the Dolby Digital 5.1 audio surround presentation worked its magic across the board. Vocal clarity, musical accompaniment, and the scattering of sound effects all echoed well across the sound stage. Gunshots, which ring out in bursts here and there, all sounded crisp and clear. Any rising of voices or pinching highs held their clarity quite well. The surrounds get a pretty heavy workout as well, especially during more musical numbers. Most importantly, the narration from Timberlake holds a clean balance between highs and lows that gently dip down into the LFE channel. It's an active, engaging mix that aids in the pleasantries of the film's aesthetics. Subtitles are available in optional English, French, and Spanish languages.

The Extras:

Sadly, the extras are scarce, but still relatively interesting:

USIDent TV: Surveilling The Southland Featurette:
Dee Austin Robertson put together this 30-minute assembly featurette that delves behind the scenes for Richard Kelly's film. It features a lot of solid, in-depth footage, such as some set design construction and script supervisor participation. It's a nicely edited and intriguing piece, though the on-screen display that pops up and talks, much like the film, is a shade on the obnoxious side. However, the actual material shot and included, featuring several interviews and making-of clips for many scenes, offer a fantastic dive into Southland Tales.

This is the Way the World Ends Animated Short:
Sitting at around 9 minutes in length, this animated short tells the story of how war consumes our society and the aftereffects of a nuclear war. The story is told through the voice of an undersea creature to one of its youngsters. It's an interesting, haunting little oddity with a conclusion lacking much optimism, in case the title wasn't indicative.

Sony rounds out the rest of the disc with a horde of 16 previews, ranging in material from 30 Days of Night to Revolver.


Final Thoughts:

Southland Tales is a mental workout to the highest accord, but lacks the substantial follow-through in all its critiques and theories to land it as a success. Its quirky characters, played by Johnson and Gellar, as well as its more subdued personalities, covered by Timerlake and Scott, still help this convoluted barrage of ideas along as a compelling trip to coast through. Paired with stellar audio and video qualities and some moderately interesting extras, this will be a hearty and satisfactory Rental that'll probably net you at least a second go through to discover whether Southland Tales is something you can identify with.

Thomas Spurlin, Staff Reviewer -- DVDTalk Reviews | Personal Blog/Site
Other Reviews:
Popular Reviews
1. Jabberwocky: Criterion Collection
2. Planes, Trains & Automobiles (Re-release)
3. Kill and Kill Again
4. Rock-a-Doodle
5. Cease Fire - 3D
6. The Philadelphia Story: Criterion Collection
7. Misery: Collector's Edition
8. Le Samourai
9. An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth To Power
10. The Glass Castle

Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2017 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use