DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Ultra HD
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Sponsored Links

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » American Slapstick, Vol. 2
American Slapstick, Vol. 2
Facets Video // Unrated // July 22, 2008
List Price: $34.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by John Sinnott | posted August 17, 2008 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly
The Collection:

I love the art of silent films.  From the technical wizardry of
Last Laugh
and Metropolis to the eerie atmosphere of
Cabinet of Dr. Caligary
, the fun adventures of Douglas Fairbanks, and
even the melodramas that were so common at the time, I really enjoy most
of them.  My favorite type of early film, however, is slapstick. 
Yeah, it may be a bit low brow to admit it, but watching someone fall down
a flight a stairs or slip on a banana peel gets me laughing and the early
comedians were better at that than anyone since.  That's why I was
so excited to discover that All Day Entertainment was releasing a second
collection of shorts by some of the overlooked silent clowns.  Like
the first installment, American Slapstick Volume 2 is a hilarious
compilation of rare and mostly unseen films from the early days of the

This three disc set groups the shorts by subject, and each topic has
a very nice introduction that gives some background to the films that follow. 
This is a very nice touch, as even novice silent film viewers can appreciate
how the movies fit into the larger picture and the historical significance.

The first disc starts out with some shorts and fragments (several of
the titles presented in this set are only partial films... the rest presumably
being lost) from one of the great masters of silent comedy, Harold Lloyd. 
While many of Chaplin's and Keaton's earliest films survive, a time when
they were coming up with their characters and learning the how to be funny
in films, most of Lloyd's earliest shorts are missing.  His first
big success was playing a Chaplin-like character, Lonesome Luke. 
While this series of films was very popular, Lloyd didn't like the fact
that he was aping another comic.  He came up with the 'glasses' character
and over a series of shorts fully developed the everyman personality that
he would make famous.  Nearly all of the Lonesome Luke films were
destroying in a fire at Lloyd's Beverly Hills estate in 1943, and only
a few of the early 'glasses' shorts are still around.  This is a nice
treat seeing the star in the early days of his career.

Lloyd helped build Hal Roach Studios.  He was their big star, but
Roach new it was only a matter of time before his star moved on to a bigger
studio.  That, and the fact that the public had an insatiable appetite
for comedy shorts, had Roach looking for more clowns to feature in his
films.  Some of these second string comics were quite funny, as the
shorts in the next section, The Hal Roach B-Players, clearly illustrate. 
This section has films featuring Gaylord Lloyd, Harold's brother, James
Parrot (brother of Charley Chase) and the unique looking Snub Pollard.

The final group of films on the first disc feature Educational Pictures
product.  While most people think of Educational as the poverty row
studio where Buster Keaton ended up after his studio days were over, they
actually released some quality films in the silent era.  This selection
includes several noteworthy entries.  A Fresh Start with Larry Semon
and Oliver Hardy is a good, and funny, example of the Educational line. 
Larry Semon is probably best known for his silent adaptation of The
Wizard of Oz
featuring Oliver Hardy.  He was a silent clown though
and was very popular in his time.  He had some of the best stunt men
in the business on his payroll and his shorts were often filled with creative
stunts and elaborate gags.  In this film Semon is The Speed Kid
young man with a hot rod who races Hardy for the change to court the girl
of his dreams.  A frantic and enjoyable short, the section where Larry
races through town with a bed attached to the back of his racers was particularly

The undisputed king of silent comedy was Charlie Chaplin and the second
disc starts out with him.  Well, sort of.   It starts out
with a group of Chaplin impersonators.  Chaplin was amazingly popular
in the silent era.  For years he was the highest paid performer in
the world, and every time he negotiated a new contract he would break records
for highest salary.  The problem was that he was slow to produce. 
After all, you can't rush genius.  To cash in on the public's love
for the Little Tramp, many similar acts popped up as well as several copycats. 
This section pays tribute to those largely forgotten imitators.  It
starts out with a trio of cartoons featuring the Tramp.

Next up is a selection of Chaplin's best impersonators.  The king
of that particular hill was Billy West, a comic that Chaplin himself once
said came the closest to capturing his character.  Like Lloyd earlier,
West grew tired of impersonating someone more famous and developed another
character.  This one however never captured the public's fancy and
West eventually moved behind the camera as an AD at Columbia.

The disc winds up with a look at Charlie Chaplin's older brother Syd
Chaplin.  Syd was the one who got Charlie started in show business. 
He had joined Fred Karno's acting troop in Britain and had risen in the
ranks to become one of the company's stars and also a writer.  He
convinced Karno to give his little brother a shot, and the rest, as they
say, is history.  Before Chaplin left Mack Sennett, he convinced the
producer to hire his brother on, something the didn't take much convincing
since Sennett had been told by his partners in New York to give the British
comic anything he wanted.

Syd is best known for being Charlie's business manager and getting those
fantastic sums of money for Chaplin's films, but he was a good comic in
his own right.  This set presents two shorts and one of Syd's feature
films, Charlie's Aunt.  An amusing spectacle, the full length
film has Syd dressing in drag to act as a chaperon for his friends, only
to have amorous advances made to him.  It's a cute film and one that
would be a lot of fun to see with a large audience.

The final disc starts off with a trio of comedies that have all of the
maniacal mayhem that silent slapstick is noted for, including a funny piece
by Billy Bevans.  The real gem of this set follows:  a selection
of shorts by female comedians.  Louise Fazenda and Alice Howell were
both silent slapstick comics willing to do the silly stunts that their
male counterparts would do.  Little known today, the films in this
collection show that they are just as humorous, if not more so, as their
more famous counterparts.  The real find in this collection is a one
reel short called Hold Still staring Anne Cornwall.  This is
a gem of a film where Anne steals the show with her comic talent. 
Though feminists of today may boo the ending, Anne plays a plucky lady
trying to make it in a man's world.  It's too bad more of these women's
films are not available.  By one account 90% of Alice Howell's films
are gone.  This set is a rare chance to see some obscure but never
the less funny comedians.

The collection is wrapped up with a couple of unique offerings; early
talking films that tried to incorporate silent style slapstick comedy. 
They don't work quiet as well, maybe it's something about the scratchy
sound, or maybe it's that comedians weren't as talented as some of the
silent greats, but it is interesting to see how they tried to continue
the genre after the industry changed.

The films included in this set are:

Disc One:

Harold Lloyd:

Bliss (1917) - w/ Snub Pollard/Bebe Daniels/Billy Evans

By the Sad Sea Waves (1917)

Don't Shove (1919)

Hey There! (1918)

Luke Joins the Navy (1916)

Hal Roach B-players:

The Dippy Dentist (1920) - Snub Pollard/'Sunshine' Sammy Morrison/Gaylord

Dodge Your Debts (1921) - Gaylord Lloyd

Looking for Trouble (1919) - Snub Pollard/ Gaylord Lloyd/Mildred Davis

Shiver and Shake (1922) - James Parrott

Whirl o' the West (1921) - Snub Pollard

At Your Service (1921) - Sidney Smith

Educational Studios:

Breezing Along (1927) - Lloyd Hamilton

A Fresh Start (1920)

Kid Speed (1924) - Larry Semon

Jonah Jones (1924) - Lloyd Hamilton

Post No Bills (1923) - James Parrott

Disc Two:

Charlie without Chaplin:

Felix in Hollywood (?) - Cartoon fragment

Charlie at the Beach (?) - Cartoon fragment

Charlie Out West (1919) - full length cartoon

The Hobo (1917) - Billy West/Oliver Hardy

Oh! Shoot (1923) - Fragment. Bobby Dunn

Caught in a Park (1915) - Syd Chaplin/Chester Conklin

Gussle's Wayward Path (1915) - Syd Chaplin

Charley's Aunt (1925) - Syd Chaplin

Disc Three:

Hearts and Havoc:

Be Reasonable (1921) - Billy Bevan

Call the Wagon (1923) - Neal Burns/Charlotte Merriam

At Your Service (1921) - A Hall Room Boys' Comedy

The Ladies:

Cinderella Cinders (1920) - Alice Howell

Hold Still (1926) - Anne Cornwal

A Hash House Fraud (1915) - Louise Fazenda/ Chester Conklin

Faro Nell (1929) - Louise Fazenda


Hollywood Runaround (1932) - Monte Collins

Playboy Number One (1937) - Willie Howard

The DVD:


Most of these films are accompanied by original piano scores written
and performed by Ben Model, Andrew Earl Simpson, and Ethan Uslan. 
A couple had organ scores by Blain Gale, and a handful used generic music
soundtracks that were placed on them for TV broadcast presumably in the
50's and 60's.  The audio tracks in this last category were scratchy
and had some background hiss, and didn't fit the shorts nearly as well
as the compositions made for this set did.  The piano and organ scores
sounded good, and were a nice addition to the set.


The quality of the windowboxed image varies over a wide range from short
to short.  Some of the films are very good looking with only minor
print damage and wonderful contrast.  Others are scratched and damaged,
some have low contrast, several are from multi-generation dups, and a few
have signs of decomposition.  The fact that these films are available
at all is a slight miracle.  The most quoted figure is that only 15%
of silent films still exist, and a most of those are from the larger stars
and directors.  These shorts of lesser known comics are exceedingly
rare and even today there is not much economic incentive to restore these
films, so their shortcomings can be forgiven and even expected.  Overall
this set of films look pretty good.  They are generally rougher than
what you'll find in an American Film Archives set, which is to be
expected, but not as bad as some VHS tapes I've purchased back in the day.


There are no extras, but with a set like this, they really aren't called

Final Thoughts:

Kudos to All Day Entertainment for putting out a second set of wonderfully
funny and rare slapstick shorts.  David Kalat (yes, the same David
Kalat who provided the wonderful commentaries for the Dr. Mabuse
films of Fritz Lang) has selected a wonderful series of shorts that showcases
these forgotten comics.  The Syd Chaplin shorts as well as the movies
featuring the female comics were especially noteworthy.  While it's
too bad that the video quality on these films isn't better, it's amazing
that we can see them at all.  Highly Recommended.


Popular Reviews
1. Cary Grant Collection
2. Spawn of the North
3. Breezy
4. Clockwise
5. The Sign of the Cross
6. A Different Story
7. Dr. Who and the Daleks
8. First Snow
9. Carole Lombard Collection I (Fast and Loose / Man of the World / No Man of Her Own)

Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2020 DVDTalk.com All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use,