DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds

Sponsored Links

Search: For:
Reviews » DVD Video Reviews » Home Movies 10th Anniversary Set
Home Movies 10th Anniversary Set
Shout Factory // PG // November 4, 2008
List Price: $129.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Jason Bailey | posted December 4, 2008 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Printer Friendly
The Series:

I'm not sure how I managed to end up so late to the party on Home Movies. Fast-paced, funny, and inventive, this cartoon comedy was the follow-up project for many of the talents involved in the great Dr. Katz, Professional Therapist; producer/director/co-creator Loren Bouchard was heavily involved in Katz, as was executive producer Tom Snyder (no, not that Tom Snyder), and most of the voice talents of that show pop up over the course of Home Movies' four season run (many of them more than once).

I was a Dr. Katz fanatic--though apparently not enough of a fanatic to know that there was this whole other series that most of the parties involved had moved on to. At any rate, in reviewing the new Home Movies: 10th Anniversary Set, I consumed the series' entire 52-episode output in two days, which allowed the unique opportunity to watch an entertaining show search for--and ultimately find--its own unique, distinctive voice.

Home Movies concerns Brendon (voiced by co-creator/writer Brendon Small), a bright eight-year old obsessed by cinema. His regular after-school activity is shooting goofy homemade movies with his video camera, assisted by his school chums Melissa (Melissa Gasky) and Jason (H. Jon Benjamin). School soccer coach Jon McGurk (also voiced by Benjamin) provides wildly inappropriate adult guidance, while Brendon's single mom Paula (first voiced by Paula Poundstone, then Janine Ditullio) provides support and occasional (distracted) discipline. The resulting brew is a mixture of sly movie in-jokes and parodies, childhood angst, and dysfunctional family values.

Like Katz, the humor of Home Movies is based less on traditional "joke writing" than on characterization; there is very little in the way of set-up/punch-line and more of an emphasis on timing, pauses, situation, and reaction. As a result, the series' sense of humor is often bone-dry, which can be off-putting to fans of more mainstream comedy.

My favorite of the show's four seasons is Season One, though I'll admit that this is probably due to that season being the closest, stylistically, to Katz. The first season utilizes that show's signature "Squiggle-vision" animation, in addition to the "retro-scripting" writing process, in which actors improvise their dialogue from a rough outline, with the show coming together afterwards thanks to extensive audio editing.

The result is smart, loose, and funny. The movies-within-the-show are consistently clever, perfectly capturing the handheld charm of amateur videos. The characters take some time to establish, although Coach McGurk is uproarious from the show's very first scene; this is a truly terrific character, and Benjamin's bizarre quirks and unparalleled skill at spouting a non-sequitur serve the role well (and, most impressively, he manages to use those same skills in an entirely different--and appropriate--fashion in his portrayal of young Jason).

The show premiered on the struggling net-let UPN, which unceremoniously yanked the show after five episodes due to low ratings (even for them). Luckily, the show was quickly picked up by Cartoon Network, which used it as an anchor program for their new [adult swim] line-up. It some ways, the turnaround was probably for the best--it's not surprising that a show whose sixth episode centers around a rock opera based on Kafka's "Metamorphosis" might not connect with a mass audience. Poundstone left the show during the transition, and while her distinctive humor was missed, Ditullio quickly made the character her own.

There are plenty of great episodes in the first season, but my favorites are "Yoko," in which Brendon's potential girlfriend Lonny (voiced by Katz regular Laura Silverman) threatens to break up the group; "Method of Acting," in which Brendon takes acting lessons at a community theatre; "School Nurse," which gives us a taste of McGurk's dating style; and "Mortgages and Marbles," which features several welcome duet scenes between Benjamin and his Dr. Katz co-star Jonathan Katz (their two-scenes were that show's highlight, and Home Movies wisely puts the pair together at least once a season, with delightful results).

The show goes through some growing pains at the top of Season Two. For a variety of reasons (critic and fan feedback, the crew's desire to establish their own post-Katz identity), the second season dispenses with the two elements most identified with Dr. Katz: the "Squiggle-vision" animation and the "retro-scripting" writing process. The first isn't a particularly big deal; some folks actively disliked the look of the squiggly animation (I never minded it, but also didn't miss it when it disappeared), and the Flash animation that replaces it is crisp and aesthetically pleasing. It does, however, make the show look a little more like any other animated show, a problem that is augmented by the more conventional scripting. The bonus materials insist that improvisation was still encouraged, but the writing feels tighter and more restrictive (at least at the beginning of the season), and as a result, the show loses some of its shambling, low-key charm. Early season two episodes feel more written and less captured, more the product of clever writers than inventive actors. The desire to separate the show from its predecessor is certainly understandable, though I'm not sure if it's better to be the one show like Dr. Katz or one of the many shows that's like every other show.

On the plus side, stellar comedic talent continues to flock to the series; Andy Kindler makes a welcome semi-regular addition to the cast, as does Louis C.K. (one of the finest stand-ups working), who brings some charm to the role of Brendon's absentee dad. The show starts to find its new footing five episodes in with "The Party" episode, which nicely inter-cuts the three kids' adventures at the birthday party of epically spoiled brat Fenton (nicely overplayed by Sam Seder). "Class Trip" is another highlight, cleverly juggling the trio's attempt to shoot a movie during a field trip to a hotel with a subplot that finds Coach McGurk working as a barista. "History" features one of the show's best movies (with the kids playing Washington, Picasso, and Annie Oakley as evil geniuses bent on world domination), and the season comes to memorably cheerful conclusion with "The Wedding."

Season Three stars very strong with the "Shore Leave" episode, in which the story elements split the kids up before crashing them back together with rapid intercutting and intersecting plotlines that would have done Seinfeld proud. "Four's Company" again puts Katz and Benjamin together, with predictably uproarious results, while the "Renaissance" episode manages to send up Ren-Fair nerds and sci-fi geeks without going into the trite or familiar (thanks, at least partially, to a spot-on guest turn by the always-funny Patton Oswalt). And "Time To Pay The Price" is one of the finest episodes of the entire series, packing in a trove of the trio's productions, all of which share a strange recurring theme.

On the downside, this season finds more and more screen time turned over to Walter and Perry, a pair of obnoxious kids in a bizarre, homoerotic relationship. The duo have their fans, but I'm not among them; they're more irritating than funny, more odd and off-balance than genuinely amusing. Also, Paula's character shifts somewhat in this season and the final one into a more vocal critic of her son's work; I, for one, found her unwavering support in the earlier episodes to be both funnier and more endearing.

Those complaints aside, the third season is a strong one; the show feels looser and more freewheeling, and the season finale (the Halloween episode "Coffins and Cradles") finds big laughs (and the slightest bit of warmth) for just about everyone.

Just about everyone involved knew that Season Four would be the show's last (many thought it wouldn't make it past season three, and that season's finale was conceived as a possible series send-off), and you can feel the crew taking the show in some different directions over the course of these 13 episodes; there's a sense of trying to get everything in before they run out of opportunities, so we have the kids going to camp, Brandon directing the school play, the trio adopting a puppy, and so on. As a result of these storylines, which often bend the film-centric storylines of earlier years, the fourth season is perhaps the richest. It also feels like more improvisation has crept in (not as much as season one perhaps, the most we've seen since then), with the show finally achieving, on a regular basis, the proper mix of scripted cleverness and off-the-page interaction.

Coach McGurk provides consistent comedy gold throughout the fourth season. He goes to traffic school, blows out his pecks, dabbles in religion, and goes temporarily blind after laser surgery ("I smell burning eye. Is that a problem?"), and yet his stories never play like the kind of forced wackiness they could turn into--Benjamin never stoops to playing him for sympathy, but you just can't help but feel for the big idiot.

Memorable episodes here include "Curses" (another show heavy on Katz-Benjamin collaboration), "Psycho-Delicate" (with a guest spot by another Katz semi-regular, Todd Barry), "Those Bitches Tried To Cheat Me" (which gives teacher Mr. Lynch some of his best moments of the series), and an extended riff on Hitchcock's Rear Window, "Definite Possible Murder." The show's final episode, "Focus Grill," is especially strong, drawing the series to a fine full circle, both structurally and thematically. It's an affectionate send-off, bittersweet and kind of wonderful and therefore perfectly in tone with this charming little show.

The DVDs

Home Movies: 10th Anniversary Set collects Shout! Factory's four previous full-season sets into one cardboard box, with a flip-top that opens like a film slate. The twelve discs (three for each season) are housed inside, each in its own clear plastic ThinPack. The set also includes the 52-track CD of music cues from the show (previously included as an extra in the season four set). The discs are exactly as presented in the earlier sets; the only added value in the new collection comes in the form of swag: a small Home Movies slate and a black tote bag, emblazoned with a drawing of Coach McGurk. It is a good-looking set, though, and will make a nice addition to your shelf.


The full-frame presentation is, for the most part, very good. The first, "squiggled" season is a bit more pixilated than the later, cleaner Flash years, but overall, the image is bright and vivid, bursting with solid, bright colors and sharp edges. Kudos to Shout! for a solid transfer.


All four seasons are presented in their original 2.0 stereo mix, but it's nowhere near as flat as most television soundtracks. To begin with, dialogue is startlingly clear, free of any distortion or excess noise; a glance at the special features confirms how seriously these folks take their dialogue recording. The show's frequent music cues are also crisp and well modulated, punching up the mix and helping out a very pleasing aural experience.


Shout! Factory is known for their exhaustive supplementary materials, and the Home Movies set is no exception. First, we have Audio Commentaries spread out across all four seasons, starting with season one tracks by co-creator/director Loren Bouchard, co-creator/writer/actor Brendon Smalls, and actor H. Jon Benjamin. Their tracks (which are provided for most, but not all, episodes) are frequently hilarious, but the mix is unfortunate; the show audio has been laid in too heavily, leading to a muddy track that is sometimes hard to make it. This problem is thankfully fixed in the season two commentaries--this time, Benjamin is out and producer/actor Melissa Galsky is in, adding a nice female flavor to the high-spirited discussion. Bouchard and Smalls go it alone on the season three commentaries, but all hands are on deck for season four, which offers at least one, but sometimes two or even three commentary tracks by less-heard cast members and crew, in addition to fan tracks by members of the bands Modest Mouse and the Shins, as well as the editorial staff of The Onion. The guest tracks are fun, but the commentaries by core crew remain the funniest and most enlightening.

Animatics are also provided for several episodes throughout the discs; these "video storyboards" show original drawings accompanying the locked audio tracks. They run about the length of a full-length episode, rendering them useful to animation enthusiasts but less interesting to casual fans. Animation Galleries also make their way onto several discs, showcasing character designs, early sketches, and other "random stuff."

The season one discs also include solo Interviews with Bouchard (23:48), Small (18:44), and Benjamin (20:47). Bouchard's sit-down is straight-forward and very informative, detailing the creation of the show and the process for putting it together, while Small and Benjamin have a little more fun with the format, spinning yarns and making up ridiculous stories (less than three minutes in, Benjamin is rambling about hanging out with Vangelis). The trio then sits for an interview together (16:08), which is a little more, you know, fact-based.

Other season one extras include a goofy Small short film entitled "The Thor Von Clemson Advance Fast Hand Finger Wizard Master Class" (5:44), and "Baby Pranks" (4:39), a funny "Punk'd" parody by Benjamin and Bill Buckendorff.

The second season extras kick off with the "Winner of the 'Small Shorts' Film Competition," apparently a contest to concoct a film in the style of the movies on the show. The winner isn't half-bad, and certainly in the spirit of the show. Next we have "Memories: Guest Stars Remember Home Movies" (10:48), a very funny featurette (credited to Small himself) with (mostly tongue-in-cheek) reflections from a number of the comic talents that voiced the show. "Brendon Small Interviews Melissa Galsky" (11:18) promises exactly what it delivers, with a fun (and slightly flirty) one-on-one between the male and female lead. Both also appear with Bouchard in a separate Interview (14:04), which is a mostly serious discussion (in spite of Small's strange paper mustache) about the changes of the second season.

Bouchard conducts the season's most valuable and interesting special feature, "Audio Anatomy of a Scene" (9:14), a fascinating split-screen tutorial, showing how the audio elements come together during production. Speaking of audio elements, we're also given some so-called "Musical Treats"--Small's "Play The Home Movies Theme In One Easy Lesson" (3:20), a snarky but amusing music tutorial, plus two audio-only music tracks (rendered a bit obsolete by the inclusion of the aforementioned audio disc). Finally, "Home Movies Writer Bill Braudis Speaks!" (4:05) offers Small's co-writer a (brief) moment in the spotlight; his interview is interesting if a little dull.

Special features are a little slimmer in the third season, though they're certainly inventive. There's the "Decide Your Doom Game: Revenge of the Dorks," a full-on interactive game spun-off from the "Renaissance" episode. Benjamin contributes "A Featurette For People Who Don't Necessarily Like Home Movies," (07:52) which is a couple of minutes of strangeness, followed by an uproariously funny featurette covering the making of the previous featurette. This meta-extra is one of the set's best features, beautifully sending up the pomposity of most behind-the-scenes packages. "Some Home Movies Fans: A Music Video" (1:14) is a brief montage of fans at a DVD signing, while the audio-only "WFMU Radio Interview with Jon Benjamin and Loren Bouchard" (1:11:42) rounds out season three's extras.

Season four also goes a little light on the featurettes, devoting most of the extra energy to the extensive commentaries (including tracks by the animators to accompany the animatics). But we do get "The Beginning of the Genesis of the Origin of Home Movies," (22:34) a wonderful featurette by Bouchard, again in the split-screen style of "Audio Anatomy of A Scene," this time going back to the first recording sessions for the show. It's a lot of fun, and packed with interesting details. I also enjoyed the "Home Movies Audio Outtakes Jukebox" feature, which allows the viewer to punch a "random" button on an on-screen jukebox and hear some playfully silly pieces from the recording sessions that didn't make the show.

Final Thoughts:

Home Movies isn't perfect, but that's part of its charm; while it struggles to find and refine its own comic voice, it is always likable and utterly charming. The 10th Anniversary Set offers the opportunity to watch that evolution and enjoy the hard work of a very talented group of people. Those who purchased the individual seasons will find little in the way of added value here, but those (like me) who missed the boat should jump on this set and latch on to this smart, droll, witty program. Highly Recommended.

Jason lives in New York. He holds an MA in Cultural Reporting and Criticism from NYU.

Popular Reviews
1. 2001: A Space Odyssey
2. The Adventures of Hajji Baba
3. Andrei Rublev: Criterion Collection
4. Creepshow
5. Superman: The Movie
6. Teen Titans Go! To the Movies
7. I Married Joan: Classic TV Collection Vol 4
8. How the Grinch Stole Christmas: Ultimate Edition
9. Fire Birds
10. Starchaser: The Legend of Orin

Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use