Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



Summit Entertainment // PG-13 // July 7, 2009
List Price: $34.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Jason Bailey | posted July 1, 2009 | E-mail the Author

So I know I'm late to the party on this one, but when did Nicolas Cage turn into such a terrible actor? And by that, I don't mean bad in bad movies; he's clearly aware that Bangkok Dangerous and Ghost Rider and those National Treasure movies are garbage, and appears to "act" accordingly. But it was once safe to assume that, given a decent script (like Adaptation or Lord of War or Matchstick Men), he'd put forth a little effort. However, his latest film, Knowing, is a serviceable enough sci-fi thriller with a fairly ingenious concept at its core, and his is a horrifyingly poor performance. In scene after scene, he veers between his two modes (sleepwalking and bug-eyed yelling), recites his lines dutifully but without inspiration, and generally seems to wish he were somewhere else. From his work here, you'd never guess that this was an Academy Award-winning actor and well-paid movie star; you'd think he was the secretary of the drama club, who stepped into the leading role of the high school play when the star got mono.

It appears that he's gotten so used to phoning it in that he doesn't recognize a flawed script that he could help by doing a bit of acting. Or maybe he just got confused, as Knowing's plot sounds, at first blush, like a cross between Next and National Treasure. A grabber of an opening reveals the basic premise: in 1959, a young girl (Lara Robinson) puts a page of seemingly random numbers into a time capsule that her grade school is burying, to be opened 50 years later. Flash forward to the present day; MIT professor John Koestler (Cage) has a son (Chandler Canterbury) who attends the school, and when each of the current students is given a letter from the past, he gets the scrawl of numbers. Koestler starts to examine the document, and when a series of numbers spelling out 9/11/2001 pops out at him, he goes to the Internet and starts to crunch some numbers. He finds, to his horror, that the young girl predicted every major catastrophe of the subsequent half-century, down to the number of people killed. And there are three events, one of them major, within the next few days.

Knowing is helmed by director Alex Proyas, of the impressive Dark City and the far-less-impressive I, Robot. His style is slick and trim; he is undoubtedly a capable technician, and has a couple of virtuoso sequences here. The first, where Koestler takes the document apart and realizes the data it contains, has a thrilling, paranoid kick to it. It's reminiscent of similar great scenes in Blow-Out or The Conversation, even if it contains too many familiar visual cues--when someone's discovering crazy shit, they surely must be holding a highball glass full of booze, so that when the biggest shock reveal occurs, it can crash to the floor in slow motion. That Proyas can still score with that stock shot speaks volumes about his skill as a craftsman.

His other standout moment comes when Koestler realizes he's about to witness the next prophesized event, and Proyas shoots it all in one shot, Children of Men-style. It's a jaw-dropper of a scene; it takes your breath away, the technique is so absorbing. That scene depends considerably on computer effects, but most of them work, though a later scene on the New York subway doesn't fare nearly as well. I've not seen CGI that slack since Air Force One--it's like we're suddenly watching a second-tier video game.

That fumble aside, Proyas' direction is mostly tight and serviceable, though he should have recognized that the screenplay needed more work. The plot itself is so ingenious that you heartily wish the other aspects of the screenplay weren't so undercooked. Much of the dialogue is clunky and obvious, leaving the actors to trip over awkward exposition and declarative nonsense. Rose Byrne can't seem to figure out what the hell to do with her underwritten role, though Canterbury is a likably no-frills child actor. He takes the script's odd (and unsuccessful) turn to the supernatural with a shrug and does the best he can with it.

But its switch to science-fiction in the shoot-the-works third act doesn't play, primarily because the effectiveness of the film to that point is tied directly to its grounding in our specific (often explicit) reality. It rather paints itself into a corner in terms of the logical outcome (and gives us at least part of a ballsy ending on the order of The Mist), but tries to have it both ways with the somewhat fraudulent "twist." And the climax might have worked on paper, but not with Cage melodramatically falling to his knees and wandering around in a bug-eyed stupor as Marco Beltrami's bombastic score wanders in and sits on the movie's head. Proyas deserves credit for attempting to work in more subtext and philosophy than expected throughout the picture, and for trying to push it into a darker, less expected place by its end. But the sequence misses its punch, and ultimately dithers away its last chance at pulling its interesting pieces together.



Here's the good news: Knowing's 1080p MPEG-4 AVC transfer is just plain terrific. The sharp 2.35:1 image is sharp and startlingly crisp, filled with lush colors (you want to reach out and crinkle the brown leaves), deep, inky blacks, sharp contrast, and excellent depth. The detail work is particularly noteworthy--check out the overhead wide shot that begins Cage's first scene, or the reflection of the trees on his side window as he and his son approach Byrne's home. Rich and textured, this is an outstanding video presentation.


The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix is also sterling, beautifully reproducing the film's intricate sound design. It shines brightest in the scenes with "whispering"--an overlapping series of inner (or perhaps external) voices heard by a few characters, similar to the chorus of psychic voices heard by Sookie on True Blood. Those voices envelop the viewer, as do many of the other environmental sounds (a violent rainstorm, a roaring subway train, and plenty of big explosions). Dialogue is crystal clear and well-modulated, though (as mentioned earlier), the score occasionally threatens to overwhelm the track.

A Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 track is also offered, as are English SDH and Spanish subtitles.


For a recent (and reasonably successful) big studio picture, this 50GB Blu-ray disc is surprisingly scant on bonus features. The primary extra of note is Proyas' Audio Commentary, in which he chats with an unidentified second voice (perhaps a producer?) about the film. It's an informative, insightful track; Proyas perhaps give s the film a bit more credit for intellectualism than it deserves, but he explains his themes, his methods, and his notes on the production compellingly.

"Knowing All: The Making of a Futuristic Thriller" (12:36) is a typical piece of EPK-style fluff, with filmmaker and cast interviews, clips, and footage from the shoot. There's nothing too enlightening here (though it is presented in HD and looks great). More interesting is "Visions of the Apocalypse" (17:15), in which experts and scholars use the film's end-of-the-world themes as the jumping-off point for discussions of the psychology and history of apocalyptic theory. It's a well-assembled and fascinating addition.

The disc is also BD-Live enabled, though no features were available for review at the time of this writing.


Knowing is full of interesting ideas and clever notions, but the fundamental thinness of the screenplay and the stunning ineptitude of the Nicolas Cage performance keep it from going much of anywhere. Director Proyas can put together a slam-bang set piece with skill and deliver occasional jolts, but the film doesn't amount to much more than a weeknight rental--though the disc's reference-quality video and audio make it a tempting purchase.

Jason lives in New York. He holds an MA in Cultural Reporting and Criticism from NYU.

Buy from






Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links