Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info


Rain Man

MGM // R // February 15, 2011
List Price: $19.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Jason Bailey | posted March 7, 2011 | E-mail the Author

Charlie Babbitt is a hustler, plain and simple. It's not spelled out, the way it would be in a lazy movie; we put it together ourselves, in flashes of temper and quiet moments observed. He's a shady businessman, involved in some sort of complicated scheme to import sports cars that aren't quite up to EPA standards. His relationship with his girlfriend (Valeria Golino) is strained and distant. He's estranged from his father, and has been for a long time; when he gets the call that the old man has dies, he registers no emotion whatsoever. "Sorry about the weekend," he tells his girlfriend, as he turns the car around.

Charlie is the main character in Rain Man, Barry Levinson's Academy Award-winning comedy/drama, and he is played by Tom Cruise, providing the first real hint that he might be more than just a pretty face. Dustin Hoffman co-stars as Raymond, Charlie's autistic savant older brother, and he won Best Actor for his work; Cruise wasn't even nominated. That's the Oscar way--"good acting" is too often conflated with "most acting," and for several years in the late '80s and early '90s, the bulk of the trophy winners and nominees were those actors who played characters with some kind of physical or mental handicap*. Hoffman is good in the film. But it is a stunt performance, a piece of gimmickry, "an acting exercise," Pauline Kael wrote, "working out miniscule variations on his one note." Of course, the very nature of the character is that he cannot, in any significant way, change ("What difference does it make?" Charlie asks, "he's gonna be just the same!"). But Charlie can, and does. If the film works--and I maintain it does, still, brilliantly--it is because it is not about Raymond, but about Charlie.

Charlie was, in many ways, a cracked, damaged version of the flashy hotshot that Cruise had already made a specialty of in films like Top Gun, Cocktail, and The Color of Money. Here, in the hands of director Barry Levinson, he pushes that smug, cocky confidence man just a little further and gives him a quality that must've made the suits plenty nervous: he makes him unlikable. Charlie is pushy, he's devious, he's impatient ("Can I finish?" he snaps at his sympathetic girl), and he's often downright mean. On the very afternoon that he meets his heretofore unknown brother, who is heir to their father's considerable fortune, Charlie barely acknowledges any feeling of loss or disappointment that his brother was hidden from him. He's mainly just mad about the money. So he kidnaps his brother, and quickly proves himself the worst imaginable caretaker for him.

But then, about halfway into their trip across the country (Raymond refuses to fly), there is a scene in a motel bathroom where Charlie has a memory of his brother, the "rain man" who used to come and sing to him. Levinson frames their conversation in a sustained two-shot; the camera is barely there. He lets the two actors set the rhythm of the scene, because it's about them. It is (in a way that is perhaps easy and perhaps formulaic but moving nonetheless) a breakthrough; as Charlie puts his brother to bed after that encounter, there are things happening in Cruise's eyes that you can't even begin to put your finger on.

If you've seen Rain Man a few times (as I have), you begin to see the structural integrity of Ronald Bass and Barry Morrow's screenplay, the marvelous way that the movie pivots on that scene, how it knows that their relationship has changed, and how it acts accordingly. Cruise's performance evolves as well--there's a quiet honesty to his poolside scene with Dr. Bruner (Jerry Molen) late in the film, an understated desperation, and understanding of who this guy had become, and why that was unacceptable. Ultimately, Charlie is the one who finds the emotional truth between them at the story's end.

Levinson, who was in the midst of a real hot streak when he made Rain Man (it was preceded by Tin Men and Good Morning Vietnam), directs with a smooth, unimposing style; he's still got his comedy writer's sense of timing (the overlapping dialogue is fast and smart, particularly when the director himself pops up at the end) and he fills the edges of the scenes with marvelous little touches, like the old man doing the history lecture in the waiting room of the small town doctor's office. It's a dialogue-driven movie that never feels visually static; he plays a big highway argument in a huge wide shot and somehow makes it work, and knows when to pull in a haunting image (like the shots of Ray walking ahead of the car as it gets off the main highway). He also makes fine use of his then-signature editing move, the slow fade to black followed by the hard cut in to close-up, which here provides a crucial transition to the climactic Las Vegas scenes.

The film's got an ever-so-slight third act drag; the dancing business is lovely but probably could have been trimmed without any damage, and the big music cue and "dressing up the boys for Vegas" montage is one of the few places where the film now feels dated (god, every movie had one of those scenes for a while). Then again, it's hard not to get wrapped up in the excitement of the scene; as far as these things go, it's a pretty good one, and the Vegas sequences--as criticized and parodied as they came to be--work. And there's one great moment, right in the middle of them, that no one seems to notice: the way Charlie regards the Vegas escort who has approached Raymond at the bar. Look at the little sparkle in Charlie's eyes. He knows another hustler when he sees one.



The MPEG-4 AVC transfer is certainly an improvement over the DVD, but not by much. Grain and compression are heavy to a point of distraction; Cruise's monologue about his break with his father and the late scene inside the train station look particularly shoddy. Skin tones tend to skew towards the pink side, while skin textures are occasionally waxy. Wide exterior shots, like the picturesque highway photography, fare much better--the open road, the red sunset, the dark dirt and so on are lovely--and most of the dialogue scenes are fine, if unexceptional. I'm just not certain that it's a film that particularly benefited from the HD upgrade.


On the other hand, the English 5.1 DTS-HD Master audio track is quite impressive; Hans Zimmer's moody score reverberates throughout the soundstage, making particularly effective use of the LFE channel, and busier soundscapes (the highway accident scene, the clanging casino) are immersive, while the scary sound design of Ray's fits are properly overpowering. There are, however, moments of slight distortion in the dialogue track--I noticed it particularly in the scene at the "wheel of fortune."

French, German, Italian, Russian, and Spanish 5.1 DTS tracks, Czech and Polish Dolby Digital 5.1 mixes, and Hungarian, Japanese, Portuguese, and Spanish 2.0 tracks are all available, as are English SDH, French, Spanish, Portuguese, Japanese, German, Italian, Croatian, Czech, Danish, Dutch, Finnish, Greek, Hebrew, Hungarian, Indonesian, Korean, Mandarin (Simplified), Mandarin (Traditional), Norwegian, Polish, Romanian, Russian, Slovenian, Swedish, Thai, and Turkish subtitles.


The bonus features from the 2004 special edition DVD have been included, beginning with a trio of Audio Commentaries: one by director Levinson, one by writer Barry Morrow, one by writer Ronald Bass. They've all got interesting things to say, but boy that's a lot of audio commentary; I can't imagine why the three tracks weren't edited together into one (particularly considering how much silence is in each), instead of assuming that anyone has the time or inclination to sit through six-plus hours of commentary tracks. Also ported over is a single Deleted Scene (2:13) of Raymond's unfortunate visit to a convenience store, as well as the original, memorable Theatrical Trailer (2:13).

Two featurettes have been added for the Blu-ray release, though neither are in high-def: "The Journey of Rain Man" (22:07) and "Lifting the Fog: A Look at the Mysteries of Autism" (20:13) were apparently prepared for the 2004 DVD, but not included in the domestic release, for whatever reason. The former is a too-brief but well-made look at the creation of the film, with input from most of the creative team and from Golino and Molen (though, disappointingly, nothing from Cruise or Hoffman); the latter examines autism and its evolving perception, with special focus on the real people who inspired the film and the Raymond character.


Rain Man was so overexposed, overplayed (yes, TNT, please run it again), and over-imitated (the Raymond impression was in every hack '80s comic's toolbox) that it ultimately came to be seen as overrated--a fate that frequently befalls high-grossing Best Picture winners. But the fact of the matter is, it's a good film, perhaps a great one, and it still plays; what's more, it's worth a look as a reminder of what Tom Cruise was capable of, before his career became a pile-up of lazy vehicles and questionable PR decisions.

*Meanwhile, the actors in the more challenging roles opposite them--Robin Williams in "Awakenings", Denzel Washington in "Philadelphia", Cruise here--were ignored. Return

Jason lives in New York. He holds an MA in Cultural Reporting and Criticism from NYU.

Buy from






Highly Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links