Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Epidemic

Home Vision Entertainment // Unrated // September 21, 2004
List Price: $29.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted September 23, 2004 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

Lars Von Trier and Niels Vorsel play a par of screenwriters who seclude themselves in their small European apartment to complete a cram session in which the finish a script about an epidemic that hits the area. Eventually the two drive across the border to Germany, where they hang out with Udo Kier and it's during these moments where we begin to see snippets of the film that they are writing. As the film, and the film within a film, progress we realize that what the two Danes have been writing about has actually been happening in the outside world – or so it seems. It could actually all be a figment of Von Trier's bizarre imagination.

Epidemic is weird. And sometimes I think it's just weird for the sake of being weird, not because it necessarily needs to be. I'm all for trying new things and experimental filmmaking – without those the format would stale and sour and dull. But in the case of Epidemic the experiments don't necessarily work. I appreciate what Von Trier and company were attempting with the film and I appreciate that they were abiding by their own unique set of rules as set forth in their manifesto but that doesn't necessarily make a boring film more interesting. The biggest problem with Epidemic is that it really takes awhile to get going. Not much at all really happens in the first forty-five to fifty minutes of the film besides the two writers bouncing ideas back and fourth, smoking, and losing their original script for a completely different film due to a computer problem.

And then there's the red Epidemic 'bug' that sits in the top left corner of the screen for pretty much the entire film. I realize this is supposed to signify some sort of impending doom but does it really need to be there the entire film? No. A few minutes would have gotten the point across quite nicely and without providing a distraction for when things really do start to get moving towards the end of the movie.

That being said, the film isn't terrible. It's just odd and some of the ideas that the writers were running with kind of fall short of the mark. The 'film within a film' segments are great, especially in regards to the cinematography. Watch for a remarkable shot of the main character seemingly gliding along the contaminated lands holding onto a red cross flag, then let the camera reveal to you just how that's happening – it's a truly remarkable shot! The subplot with the doctors going underground and hiding from the general populace so that they can remain unaffected by the outbreak rather than abide by the Hippocratic Oath that they swore to uphold after graduating medical school is an interesting twist. The 16mm 'real world' footage is also interesting in some regards, if a little rough in look and feel. We do get a 'fly on the wall' perspective as the two go about their creative process, smoking and drinking and having a fun time as they do.

The DVD

Video:

Seeing as the film was shot on both 16mm and 35mm, viewers are bound to notice some differences in quality between the two intertwining stories that the film presents. Obviously the 35mm footage is cleaner and slicker looking while the 16mm footage is grainier and scratchier looking. Both stories are told in stark, high contract black and white (save for the aforementioned EPIDEMIC bug) and Home Vision's transfer renders the imagery very well. There isn't anything to complain about as far as compression artifacts are concerned and there are only faint hints of edge enhancement visible. The only real flaws in this presentation are those that are naturally occurring on the 16mm footage, which is grainier than most DVD viewers will be accustomed to. Other than that, Epidemic looks pretty good.

Sound:

The Dolby Digital Mono soundtrack is clean and clear when discussing the English dubbed audio that graces the 35mm footage, but rather flat and a little muffled when discussing the Danish language 16mm footage. There is a very fine layer of hiss over the entire film as well. Optional English subtitles are included for the Danish footage that are clean and easy to read and also free of any noticeable typos.

Extras:

Aside from a two page insert in which Von Trier states his what his intentions were in making the film and how they made it happen, there's also a Von Trier filmography. The main extra features though are a feature length commentary with Von Trier and Niels Vorsel as well as a roughly fifty-two minute long documentary on the Dogme 95 school of filmmaking.

The commentary track is an affectionate one in that the two men seem to have had a great time working on this and a few other projects together. They're obviously friends outside of their working relationship and that leads to some fun humorous moments in the track. Sadly, neither one of them have a whole lot to say about the actual movie itself aside from some basic surface information or comments about what is transpiring on screen, and this leads to some dreaded 'dead air' in a few spots throughout the duration.

The documentary, entitled FreeDogme is a real time discussion between Von Trier and fellow filmmakers Wim Wenders, Jean-Marc Barr and Lone Scherfig moderated by Swedish film critic. Each of the four directors film themselves in real time using camcorders which gives the documentary a fast paced and personal feel in that it's almost like you're listening in on it as it transpires. Of course the subject is the Dogme 95 Manifesto and those who were involved in it, and there are some interesting insights into this school of filmmaking slapped alongside some truly unusual camera work from each of the self-directing participants. It's an unconventional and very unusual feature, but in the context of the main feature on the DVD it makes sense to have it here and it might help to explain some of the initial confusion that those unfamiliar with this line of thinking and filmmaking may have after watching Epidemic.

Finally, included as an Easter Egg is Nocturne, an eight and a half minute short film that Von Trier directed as a student in 1980 which marks the first collaboration between he and Tomas Gislason. It's an odd little short but kind of interesting and it not only comes with an optional commentary from Von Trier and Gislason, but some amusing audio commentary outtakes as well.

Final Thoughts:

Epidemic, like I find a lot of Von Trier's work, is hit or miss. It's not without its moments of suspense and entertainment but the segments in between can come off as dull or even (unintentionally?) pretentious at times. Home Vision has done a pretty nice job with the DVD release though, and the documentary included makes the disc worth a look, though it's probably best thought of as a rental for all of those except for die hard Von Trier or Dogme film fanatics. Rent it.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links