Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Naked - Criterion Collection

The Criterion Collection // Unrated // September 20, 2005
List Price: $39.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted September 23, 2005 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

Twenty seven year old Johnny (David Thewlis) is a man who is fed up with the socio-economic policies of Thatcher's England and he's hard pressed not to dwell on all of the very obvious flaws that, to him, are responsible for a lot of misery in a lot of different peoples' lives. His frustration is so all encompassing that he has a very regular tendency to take it out on people who he happens to come into contact with, whether he intends it to happen or not. After he has what he considers to be very rough sex with a girl (who in turns claims it was rape), he's forced to get out of Manchester and go into hiding in London where he shacks up at the apartment of Louise (Leslie Sharpe), an ex-girlfriend of his from a few years ago.

Rather than acknowledge Louise for her hospitality and thank her for helping him out of a tough situation, Johnny's politics cause him to lash out at even her, for working what he considers within the system. He sees her now not as a regular person but as part of the dreaded upper class who he holds in such ill regard. Johnny's superiority complex becomes readily apparent to Louise once this happens, and he shows no promise of even attempting to hide it in order to avoid future problems stemming from it. Johnny is able to take some solace in the arms of Louise's roommate, Sophie (Katrine Cartlidge), who at least shares some of the same frustrations with society as he does. She also happens to have a rather serious drug problem. The more their relationship develops the more obvious it becomes that Sophie is starved for attention. Perhaps clueing into this, Johnny finds he's able to give it to her but at the same time, he uses her as a bit of a scapegoat and a punching bag to let out his aggression. He's simply using her, and she's letting him.

Eventually Johnny loses all interest in both Sophie and Louise and he leaves their apartment, choosing instead to wander the streets of London on his own. He meets and befriends a watchman named Brian (Peter Wright) who, remarkably enough, he's able to get along with, and he also runs into a strange Scottish man named Archie (Ewan Bremner). While he's out wandering around the city, Sophie and Louise have to deal with their landlord and his misogynist ways, who makes his way into their apartment that isn't really theirs at all, and has his way with poor Sophie. It all leads up to a particularly earthy conclusion and it's interesting to see how their lives all intertwine.

Naked is, in short, a very intense and some might say a very mean spirited film. Johnny is a right bastard through and through and the utter contempt that he shows for almost everyone that he comes into contact with can be a bit hard to wrap your head around at times. He's a bit of a drifter and a social outcast but his behavior makes him so completely unsympathetic that it's hard to see him as anything but alienated from everyone else and at times it almost seems like he relishes wallowing in his own misery. David Thewlis does an absolutely amazing job of bringing this despicable character to life in a performance that won him the Best Actor award at the 1993 Cannes Film Festival (Leigh also took home Best Director that year). The strength, power, and realism of his disturbingly natural performance carries the film and in the hands of a lesser performer, the film could very well have flopped. The film isn't completely Thewlis' show, however, as the rest of the cast all turn in admirable performances as well, especially Leslie Sharpe and Katrin Cartlidge, both of whom struggle to maintain their respective relationships with Johnny. The interplay between the three central characters is an important dynamic in this film which the bulk of the story hinges on and all three parties deliver.

Leigh, wisely in this case, relies upon his performers to let the story flow naturally rather than on a heavy handed and tightly wound script. This loose format allows his characters to develop right alongside those who portray them and this method could very well be a large part of the reason why these characters seem so realistic. Leigh's camera doesn't point the finger at Johnny, which makes this at times difficult content as he really isn't called out for his obviously half insane behavior. The fact that he has a penchant for hurting his partners intentionally during intercourse will hardly endear him to the audience but again, Leigh lets us watch and make up our own minds about him rather than force feed us his own personal politics through Johnny's words and actions.

In the end, Naked is exactly that – it doesn't cover itself up or disguise itself at all, it simply portrays a side of humanity that many of us would rather not consider at all and it grabs our attention with its base and primal display of emotions, however misguided some of them may be. As horrible as some of the people are in this film, Johnny in particular, Leigh's film never loses sight of the fact that they are human beings. It's a very dark, very ugly film but one that contains such a powerful lead performance and is directed in such an interesting, if at times very simple, manner that you can't help but appreciate the skill that went into making it. Not everyone will be comfortable with the subject matter as it does get pretty grim at times, but there's no denying how expertly some of the very talented people behind the project have done their jobs and it's not a film that you'll soon forget.

The DVD

Video:

Criterion has done a great job of cleaning up Naked to the point where it looks exceptionally good, yet still maintains that gritty look and feel that is so important to the film itself. Aside from some film grain, there aren't any noticeable defects with the image in terms of dirt or print damage and the picture is quite clean in that regard. The black levels stay strong and very deep but don't end up burying anything and the level of both foreground and background detail present in this transfer is very revealing. Contrast levels are set dead on, color definition is strong, the red levels don't bleed at all and skin tones look lifelike and natural throughout the movie. There is some very, very mild line shimmering noticeable on occasion but other than that this is an exceptionally good 1.851. anamorphic widescreen transfer that does justice to the strong cinematography that the film makes such excellent use of.

Sound:

What with Naked being such a dialogue heavy film and all, it's important that the performers be as audible and clear as possible in the Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo mix that adorns this DVD, and thankfully, Criterion delivers in this department as well. For those who have trouble with the accents in the film, a concise English subtitle option has been made available. The score in the film sounds excellent and is quite eerie in spots and it does rise up in the mix fairly heavily but again, it doesn't overpower the actors, and neither do the sound effects. Portions of this mix sound quite hollow, which makes the delivery of certain lines almost like a machine gun in spots, and at times things sound more 'spitted' then actually said but this is obviously completely intentional on the part of the filmmakers and it goes a long way towards building the atmosphere and mood that broods over this movie so well.

Extras:

On the first disc, in addition to the film's theatrical trailer, there's a feature length commentary featuring director Mike Leigh and performers David Thewlis and Katrin Cartlidge. Cartlidge passed away in 2002 so it's probably a safe assumption that this commentary track was carried over from Criterion laserdisc release of the film from 1994, but not having that disc in my possession I can't personally confirm that. At any rate, this is a pretty interesting discussion and examination of the making of Naked. Leigh proclaims his surprise at the critical acclaim that the film garnered upon release, and goes into some detail about the reception that it got at Cannes where it was nominated for the prestigious Palme D'Or, while Cartlidge and Thewlis talk about some of the issues that they had with their roles and how to get their heads around certain aspects of the characters that they were hired on to play.

The second disc is where the bulk of the supplemental materials are stashed, starting off with Neal Labute On Naked, a roughly thirteen minute long discussion in which the director of Nurse Betty explains his admiration for the film and for Mike Leigh in general. This is a brand new feature, recorded this year, and it's interesting to hear Labute's interpretation of the film and some of the specific events that take place in it. This one is a bit spoilerish, so be sure to watch the feature before you delve into this chat.

The Short And Curlies is a short film that Leigh directed in 1987 starring a very young looking David Thewlis. It's a quick, funny little look at a man and a woman who are only able to really communicate with each other through the use of humor and the problems that this type of communication entails. At eighteen minutes in length, this fun little color production is kind of a nice bonus worth checking out but it doesn't really give us much of a look towards the future as far as Leigh's later output is concerned and it is a very different film from Naked. Considering the relative obscurity of the movie, it's great that Criterion has included it on this release.

The last of the video supplements is an episode of a British television show called The Art Zone. Recorded in March of 2000, this is a thirty six minute conversation between Mike Leigh and British author Will Self as they sit in a smoky pub and talk about Leigh's body of work, specifically Naked. This is an interesting peek inside Leigh's head as Self asks some very poignant questions that get the director to open up about his films and his filmmaking style. Along with the commentary track, this is the most interesting of the supplements in a pretty loaded set and fans of Leigh will certainly want to put aside the time to check out this supplement.

Inside the keepcase is a length insert booklet of liner notes containing two essays – one a piece from Derek Malcolm and Amy Taubin respectively.

Final Thoughts:

It's releases like this that have earned The Criterion Collection their reputation for excellence. Mike Leigh's Naked is a bleak and at times rather ugly film but it's also exceptionally well made and very well acted as well. It's a dark, depressing work but ultimately a very rewarding viewing experience that, when coupled with the abundance of excellent supplements and the stellar audio and video quality of this two disc set, makes for a very nice package overall indeed. Highly recommended.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links