Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info


Hart's War

MGM // R // January 30, 2007
List Price: $39.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Mitchell Hattaway | posted January 29, 2007 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:
You ever wish someone would remake Stalag 17 and hire John Grisham to write the screenplay? If so, I've got just the movie you've been waiting for.

Lt. Thomas Hart (Colin Farrell) is a fortunate son; his father, a United States senator, has seen to it that Hart has spent World War II behind a desk. But the reality of the conflict comes crashing down on him when he is captured by German soldiers while playing chauffer to a superior officer. Hart is tortured by his captors until he reveals the location of several strategic fuel dumps, after which he's sent to a POW camp. The ranking American officer in the camp is Colonel William McNamara (Bruce Willis); intuiting that Hart broke under interrogation, McNamara orders him to bunk with the enlisted men. Hart almost immediately runs afoul of Vic Bedford (Cole Hauser), a former cop who is the camp's resident schemer/black market kingpin. Hart's relationship with his fellow detainees is further strained by the arrival of Lamar Archer (Vicellous Shannon) and Lincoln Scott (Terrence Howard), two Tuskegee Airmen who were shot down behind enemy lines. Despite their rank, McNamara also orders them into the enlisted men's quarters. The racist Bedford refuses to acknowledge Archer and Scott as superior officers or fellow human beings, even going so far as to frame Archer for concealing a weapon underneath his bunk. After the weapon is discovered, Archer is hauled out into the courtyard and ordered executed by Colonel Visser (Marcel Iures), the camp commandant. Bedford is found murdered a short time later, and the evidence points to Scott as the killer. Hart, who was a law student before being drafted, is ordered by McNamara to serve as Scott's counsel during the subsequent court-martial. Both Hart and Scott realize they're simply pawns in what is nothing more than a kangaroo court, but neither is aware of exactly what McNamara has planned.

Given the source material, Hart's War turned out a hell of a lot better than it had any right to. Screenwriters Terry George and Billy Ray took the smart approach when it came to adapting John Katzenbach's novel: they kept the basic plot, chucked the laughable dialogue, and tinkered with the characters. (Katzenbach is a serviceable plotter, but he has no idea how people think or talk.) Combine their efforts with those of a skilled director who cut teeth in episodic television (in this case Primal Fear's Gregory Hoblit), toss in a game cast, and what you end up with is a movie that never quite completely rises above its fast food fiction origins (a feat both Jaws and The Godfather were able to accomplish), yet still manages to be a rather compelling, entertaining piece of work.

The setup of Hart's War is better than the payoff, but the payoff ain't bad. The buildup to the courtroom sequence far outshines the trial itself, and the last third of the story requires a healthy suspension of disbelief, as logic is tossed out the window on a couple of occasions. That being said, the quality of the first two acts will likely win you over enough to make some of the more farfetched aspects of the final forty minutes a little easier to take. Truth be told, my only real complaint against the movie is its somewhat lackadaisical pacing. The story doesn't really kick into high gear until Shannon and Howard arrive onscreen; there's a stretch between the opening sequences and their arrival that drags just a bit and would have benefited from a trim or two.

I think the filmmakers and cast are to be commended for not going the easy route and making all the characters stereotypes. Given that the tale is populated by a racially diverse group of soldiers and several Nazi officers, as well as a bigot or two, you'd expect everyone to've been spit out by an automated cookie cutter, but thankfully that's not the case. Sure, the characters aren't as complex as your average real-life human being, but they are developed enough so as not to be merely cogs employed to drive the machinery of the plot. And there's no simple delineation between Good and Evil here; while I was able to figure out the killer's identity fairly early on, his motives remained unclear until the climax approached. (I have to admit that shading all of the characters did lend a head-scratching quality to much of the ending's talk about honor and duty, but so be it.) And, in a move that shocked me, the speechifying is kept to a minimum. Any point a particular character attempts to make generally--but not always--comes in the form of a line of clever, pointed dialogue. Unfortunately, these days that's something of a lost art.


As was the case with the standard definition release, the sole flaw in the 2.35:1 transfer (MPEG 2 encoded on a single-layer disc at 18 Mbps) is some fairly mild edge enhancement. The movie was digitally color corrected in order to give it a drab, muted look, and this look is excellently conveyed by the transfer. The color palette is dominated by icy blues and whites, which look uniformly excellent (the opening scenes in the Ardennes are breathtakingly gorgeous). Depth, clarity, and detail are strong, even in the darker scenes.

Hart's War arrives on Blu-ray sporting a lossless DTS 5.1 Master Audio track. The story is driven by dialogue, and thankfully the dialogue is generally clear and intelligible; there are a couple of exceptions, but this has as much (if not more) to do with line delivery as it does the presentation itself. The surrounds are primarily employed to channel the movie's score and the occasional ambient effect, but the entire soundstage is employed during a couple of brief action sequences. Both surround integration and low-end action in these scenes are excellent, providing a nice contrast to the rest of the movie. French and Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks are also included, as are English and Spanish subtitles.

The standard edition disc contained a decent selection of bonus features, but the only extras included here are the movie's rather misleading theatrical trailer and a few previews for other new-to-BD MGM releases.

Final Thoughts:
Conviction and dedication on the part of everyone involved help put this one over the top. Hart's War is by no means a great movie, but it is a solid, satisfying, entertaining one. Recommended.

Buy from







E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links