Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns




Sudden Impact

Warner Bros. // R // June 3, 2008
List Price: $14.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Ian Jane | posted June 5, 2008 | E-mail the Author
The Movie:

The only film in the Dirty Harry series directed by star Clint Eastwood and the only film in the series not set in San Francisco, Sudden Impact stands easily as the darkest picture of the five.

The film follows a woman named Jennifer Spencer (Sondra Locke) who, along with her younger sister, was gang raped outside a carnival one night years ago. Her sister was left catatonic and Jennifer wants revenge. While Jennifer starts murdering the rapists one at a time, San Francisco Police Department Detective Harry Callahan (Clint Eastwood) has left the courthouse where his case against a hood named Hawkins (Kevyn Major Howard) was thrown out to grab a coffee at his regular diner. While he's in there, an attempted robbery plays out by Harry stops it thanks to his handy .44 Magnum.

Shortly after, Callahan pressures a mobster named Threlkis (Michael V. Gazzo) at his granddaughter's birthday party and the old guy dies from a heart attack. Callahan's superior officers take issue with his tactics and force him to take a vacation but not before Harry gets to investigate the murder that Jennifer was responsible for from the other night. While out trying to get some rest and relaxation, Callahan is attacked by Hawkins and a few of his pals. The top brass finally bring Callahan back on the force and send him to San Paulo to investigate a rash of killings that have taken place there, and it just so happens that Jennifer has gone that direction herself, supposedly to paint the local carousel. As Callahan starts putting the pieces of the puzzle together the bodies start pilling up. He finds himself not only trying to solve the murder case but also trying to survive attacks from Threlkis' men and having to play nice with the local police on top of that.

Sudden Impact is an interesting film in that it forces Harry Callahan to evaluate the case and to in turn decide for himself what true justice really is. One side of him sees things through the eyes of a police officer and needs to enforce the law, while the other side is completely sympathetic to Jennifer's quest for vengeance. This gives Callahan a little more humanity than we've seen prior and as his relationship with Jennifer evolves throughout the film we're able to understand where he's coming from enough that it all fits. That's not to say that Sudden Impact doesn't pack as much of a punch as the earlier entries in the series as it's literally action packed to the point where so much happens to Callahan that it almost becomes farcical.

Eastwood's penchant for directing violent cinema is very apparent here but on the flip side, so is his sense of control and this is evident not only in the action scenes but also in the quieter moments in the film and in the character development. This makes Sudden Impact an atypical Dirty Harry film as it really gives Callahan a lot more personal growth and depth than we'd seen up until this point in the series. Many of the typical elements are still there - the one liners ('Go ahead, make my day.'), the shoot first and ask questions later mentality, the poignant violence, and the attitude - but we see Callahan as a man more than a machine.

On top of the interesting character development the film is stylish and slick looking. The cinematography is great and the picture contains some truly tense scenes (the flashback to the gang rape is particularly harrowing). Eastwood is as strong a lead as he's ever been here and he plays Callahan incredibly well. His interplay with Sondra Locke is honest and believable and the supporting performances all fit in nicely with story and the atmosphere. Lalo Schifrin's score suits the picture perfectly and adds to the sense of menace that make some of the key scenes as effective as they are and ultimately Sudden Impact holds up very well as a quality slice of drama and action.

The DVD

Video:

Sudden Impact hits DVD in a very nice anamorphic widescreen transfer framed at 2.35.1 preserving the film's original aspect ratio. Compared to the previous release (which looked just fine), this new transfer is a noticeable improvement as it shows better detail and more robust colors. There aren't any problems with mpeg compression artifacts nor is there much in the way of edge enhancement to complain about. This is a very dark film, stylistically speaking and in terms of content, so it's important that the black levels are strong and thankfully it would seem that those responsible for the transfer kept that in mind as the dark scenes look just fine here. There's a little bit of grain and the odd speck of print damage here and there but not enough of it to warrant a complaint. Overall, fans should be quite pleased with the way that the movie looks on this DVD.

Sound:

Audio options are supplied in English language Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound with alternate language Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo tracks provided in Spanish and Dolby Digital Mono tracks in French, Japanese and Portuguese. Optional subtitles are available in English (closed captions), French, Japanese, Portuguese and Spanish. While the original English stereo mix should have been included, the 5.1 track here is pretty faithful to the original mix and it sounds quite good. The rears aren't over used but they do add some depth to the movie and they kick in at the right times to pump up the action scenes a little bit. Subwoofer action and bass response seems spot on and features the requisite amount of kick and Lalo Shifrin's fantastic score sounds near-perfect here.

Extras:

The first supplement on this disc comes in the form of a feature length audio commentary from Eastwood biographer Richard Schickel. The film scholar and author of Eastwood: A Biography delivers a fact filled commentary that does a very good job of putting this film into context amongst the Dirty Harry films and Eastwood's other pictures and notes not only the remarkable aspects of the film but also some of the more ludicrous moments in the picture. He also covers the history of the film and some of the characters with most of the emphasis obviously on Callahan (and rightfully so) and he makes some interesting notes about how this film fits in with Eastwood's other directorial efforts. In short, Schickel knows his Eastwood and his track provides a fantastic mix of keen observation, insightful criticism and fact filled trivia.

From there, be sure to check out the all new 2008 featurette, The Evolution Of Clint Eastwood (25:39). The focus of this featurette is on Eastwood as a director and it does an interesting job of examining Eastwood's rise by including interviews with Eastwood, Michael Madsen, Hal Holbrook, the Hughes Brothers, Tyne Daly, Tom Fontana, John Milius, Reni Santoni, Paul Haggis, Jack N. Green, James Fargo, Joel Cox, William Beard, Steven E. de Souza, Joe Carnahan, John Calley, Richard Schickel, Michael Butler, Neil King, Shane Black, Emanuel Levy, Peter Hyams, John Lee Hancock, and David Ayer. The participants provide a thorough discussion of Eastwood's influences (such as Sergio Leone and Don Seigel) through to his own directorial efforts through the decades. Plenty of clips from the films that Warner Brothers owns are used to provide some visual flair and there are some great, vintage behind the scenes photos here to look at as well. All involved give their two cents on Eastwood's obvious talents as a director and explain what it is that they like about his work and why it is significant and culturally relevant.

Rounding out the supplements are some stylish static menus, chapter selection, and anamorphic widescreen trailers for all five of the Dirty Harry films. With that said, mad bonus points to Warner Brothers for the great job they've done on the packaging for this series.

Final Thoughts:

A fantastic presentation coupled with an excellent commentary track and a very interesting half hour featurette make this a worthy double-dip for even casual Eastwood fans. Sudden Impact may not be the best of the films in the series but it definitely holds its own and this release comes highly recommended.

Ian lives in NYC with his wife where he writes for DVD Talk, runs Rock! Shock! Pop!. He likes NYC a lot, even if it is expensive and loud.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Highly Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links