Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



Kino // Unrated // December 6, 2016
List Price: $19.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Thomas Spurlin | posted March 19, 2017 | E-mail the Author
The Film:

Even to those dedicated fans of the Harry Potter series who have read every book and seen every movie, it can be tough to imagine how a magical sport like quidditch could operate in the real world without flying golden balls with wings and players soaring around on broomsticks. Some might be inclined to view it from the same perspective as they would with live-action role-playing, or LARPing, where spells and other mystical elements are "imagined" into existence. However, those who have seen this game in action know that the creators have condensed quidditch into a practical, physically taxing sport, where players cope with holding a shortened broom between their legs as a limitation or challenge instead of something fanciful. Explaining the sport's moving parts and legitimacy becomes one of the primary reasons for the existence of Mudbloods, which documents a year in live-action quidditch from the perspective of UCLA's squad, but its need to do so restricts some of the film's expressive potential about niche athletics and the complications of getting something new off the ground.

Mudbloods takes place in 2011 amid the fifth-year anniversary of the quidditch World Cup, in which teams from across the world gather together to play this real-world version of the sport so whimsically portrayed in J.K. Rowling's books and in the series of Harry Potter films. One group trying to get there is UCLA's team, who constantly struggle with raising funds -- notably travel expenses -- and earning the respect of others on campus. Part of that stems from the fact that many people can't get beyond the "geeky" aspect of what they do to appreciate the dedication that the sport entails, and there's a lot: dubbed a cross being dodgeball and rugby, quidditch involves full-contact physicality and quick navigation and awareness of their playing field. While elaborating upon these facets, the documentary discovers its momentum in seeing whether the UCLA team can get to the tournament in New York and whether those efforts will ultimately be worth it when, or if, they get there.

Mudbloods has a firm grasp on its audience -- people who don't look at you funny when they hear the word "Quidditch" -- and doesn't really try to be accessible to those who don't have a basic understanding of how it factors into the Harry Potter universe. Instead, the documentary explains how the sport transitions from book/screen to real life, touching upon the various positions and mechanics of the game in a fusion of game footage and cartoon visuals, and the rhythm of this comes across more like an instructional or recruitment video for the sport instead of an insightful documentary. From the perspective of someone who actually does know a thing or two about quidditch but who doesn't know anything about its live-action counterpart, that's not necessarily a bad thing: there's entertainment value to be found in the recognition and deciphering of its similarities and differences, in how it remains a co-ed game and how it grounds certain elements like the winged-ball Snitch.

Documentaries need momentum as well, and that's a struggle for Mudbloods. The production has a destination in the form of the Quidditch World Cup located in New York, which gives the UCLA team -- as well as the coordinator of the event itself, league founder Alex Benepe -- something to constantly pursue amid the training, fiscal woes, and struggles with dismissive folks who don't get their passion. While there's an element of mild suspense in seeing how the underfunded, underdog team will get there and perform, the editing alongside the illustrated descriptions of how the sport functions yield something that's lacking in focus and emotional resonance with every hurdle crossed. There's interesting context and subtext in the camaraderie and struggle involved with getting quidditch, a facet of something as globally popular on a mainstream level as Harry Potter, recognized as a functional and valid sports league; however, that gets lost within the documentary's superficial, drawn-out exposition and diversions, including the intermittent catching-up with the person who's considered to be the greatest Harry Potter fan out there, Katie Aiani.

Director Farzad Sangari deserves plenty of credit for what he's able to do with the Quidditch World Cup once Mudbloods gets there, though. Mirroring the likes of Friday Night Lights and Varsity Blues, he captures the sundown, spotlights-on enthusiasm that generates around an underdog team's arrival at the "big dance". The quidditch matches themselves are depicted with tumbling, kinetic no-frills handheld photography that frames the event in the kind of buzzing energy and expectation found in any other momentous sports event, bolstering the documentary's central aims in presenting this fanciful concept as a valid, demanding, and competitive sport. Unfortunately, not unlike certain other sports movies, Mudbloods must cope with an inherently anticlimactic finish to the UCLA team's journey, one that drags down the film's energy with the less-satisfying elements of regulations and tournament brackets. The resonance of this disappointment could be seen as the documentary scoring a goal in how it presents the live-action quidditch league, even if overall effectiveness remains just outside its reach.

Video and Audio:

Mudbloods features a lot of handheld footage, show on digital cameras roughly half a decade ago and constantly in motion to follow along with the sport's activity. The photography isn't a whole lot to look at, but the mostly 1.78:1-framed (it shifts to 1.33 at a few points), 16x9-enhanced transfer captures the color shades, contrast, and preservation of motion needed to reach the film's objectives. Navy blue, grass green, burgundy and goldish-yellow are the predominant shades of color one can spot in the image, all of which pop from the image without overdoing it, while skin tones are reputable enough throughout. As one can expect, low-light situations render muddy and noisy black levels, but for the most part the contrast balance yields appropriate shadows and enhances the depth of image. Strong details aren't in high abundance, but they can occasionally be spotted in the bristles of brooms and the strokes of the animated artwork within, though some edge enhancement and noise crops up throughout. In general, it looks fine.

The audio is equally as perfunctory, presented in a relatively stable Dolby Digital 2.0 track. There isn't a whole lot of fidelity going on with the image, of course, and the recording devices pick up plenty of unintended environmental effects. Dialogue remains audible and responsive to the limited sound design throughout, though, of course, muffling does occasionally happen. Rhythmic music and some voiceover project some fine clarity that fills the two front channels, and there's little distortion beyond what's inherent in the recording itself.

Special Features:

An Audio Commentary featuring Farzad Sangari and a collection of guests -- Matt Knudsen from We Live Movies mediates Sangari, team captain Tom Marks, and founder Alex Benepe -- really digs into how the film got made, why they made certain decisions in terms of how to portray the sport, and the tricky balance between drawing attention to real-life quidditch and avoiding too much snide commentary on the "geeky" nature of its subculture. The track reveals a lot of interesting insights about some of the participants in the film -- how many of the books the UCLA team captain has read; how theater production experience played into the commissioner's running of the sport -- as well as the trajectory that the sport has taken following the film's release. The rhythm of the track isn't terribly scene-specific, and it turns into a fairly general chat about the film itself with intermittent comments about what's going on on-screen, not to mention the back-slapping tone of the commentary considering the pre-established camaraderie between the mediator and the director. Considering those things, however, it's a fine listen, even if it loses steam about halfway through.

There's a surprising number of additional tidbits available in the special features, even if they're all fairly quick. A Brief Tour of Katie's Room (3:49, 16x9) offers a lengthier glimpse at all the memorabilia housed in the bedroom of the voted-upon "biggest Harry Potter fan", while Wizards With Attitude (4:00, 16x9) expands a little bit more upon the rapping quidditch players in the film and Making-Of Snitchcenter (3:04, 16x9) dips into the construction of a quidditch-themed web series. Kino have also included some World Cup Games Footage (5:58, 16x9) involving a match between UCLA and Michigan, as well as a Trailer (2:14, 16x9).

Final Thoughts:

As a primer to the sport of Quidditch and a glimpse at some of the hurdles its players must cross to compete in and validate their sport, Mudbloods offers an insightful and vaguely entertaining glimpse at a specific team's trek toward the fifth annual tournament for their league. As a sports drama that might transcend the documentary medium into something greater, however, Farzad Sangari's film comes up short, lacking the momentum and longevity to sustain any interest beyond curiosity into what the Harry Potter-inspired sport is all about. It's certainly worth a Rental.

Thomas Spurlin, Staff Reviewer -- DVDTalk Reviews | Personal Blog/Site
Buy from






Rent It

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links