DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info


Newest Features
Article Index  Review Index
Favorite Discs of 2013

[Savant Links] [Year Five Report]
Write Savant (Glenn Erickson) at

Tuesday April 15, 2014
... Back from TCMfest just in time for Tax Day

Savant's new reviews are:

Let the Fire Burn

Jason Osder's powerful documentary is made almost exclusively from on-the-spot news video from Philadelphia TV stations. The MOVE organization's ongoing battles with neighbors and the city authorities finished in 1985 in a shootout and siege that escalated into a massacre -- with most of the separatists dead and half a neighborhood burned down. It's beautifully assembled to show the intolerable abuses of the MOVE people as well as the highly questionable police policy, which comes off looking like revenge. In DVD from Zeitgeist Films.

Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia

Sam Peckinpah either found the perfect expression for his nihilistic world view with this movie, or he went absolutely freaking nuts. Warren Oates plays a Peckinpah-like opportunist who determines to take on a nasty job for a powerful Mexican landowner, for big money. A trek across the desert turns into a bloodbath, followed by a grotesque, sordid delivery mission that would put Edgar Allan Poe off his feed. Accompanied by several new documentary extras. In Blu-ray from Twilight Time.

The People versus Paul Crump

Finally out on DVD, this is the legendary show that became a major career steppingstone for William Friedkin. In 1962 Friedkin was a low-echelon local TV director until he made this exposé of the story of Paul Crump, a robber and murderer whose conviction was based on flimsy evidence. The picture is so packed with recreations of the crime and Crump's torture by the police that in modern terms it can barely be called a documentary -- it's an one-sided crusade to free a man from Death Row. A pamphlet of liner notes by Susan Doll gives a context for the film -- and clues us in to a major surprise about the unfortunate Paul Crump. In DVD from Facets Video.


Men in War

This well-received "lost patrol" combat film is an intense low budget effort made by top talent: Philip Yordan, Ben Maddow, Anthony Mann and Ernest Haller. It got its reputation by sticking to a tough-minded, realistic script (no babes in swimsuits) and giving free rein to an excellent cast. Robert Ryan is the exhausted, concerned Lieutenant trying to get his men back to their own lines and Aldo Ray is a one-man-army interested only in saving his Colonel, who's in a state of paralyzed shock. Several classic sequences lead to the inevitiable battle in a narrow mountain pass. With Philip Pine, Robert Keith, James Edwards, Nehemiah Persoff and Vic Morrow. In Blu-ray from Olive Films.


I'm back up and running thanks to DVDtalk's John Sinnott and Michael Anders. The fix was reasonably quick but the coordination took a couple of days.

As I'm free of TCM Festival issues I'm going to try to accelerate the number of reviews. I've received a wealth of great product to cover and am going to do it all -- the vendors deserve to get reviews out while the discs are fresh.

Links, yes links ... Gary Teetzel sends along a YouTube link to a vintage Hammer Films TV featurette about the making of the top-rank thriller Frankenstein Must Be Destroyed, which includes lots of behind-the-scenes footage and interviews with James Carreras and Peter Cushing.

Hill Place has written a nice review of a Savant favorite, Michael Ritchie's Smile. I'm linking to it not only because it's good, but because the site got a written response from one of the amateur actresses who played a 'Young American Miss' contestant in the film. It's worth checking out. Just scroll through the responses down to 'zuzusays'.

And Joe Dante has been circulating this link to an article at The Comics Journal, Superman: The Golden Age Sundays 1943-1946 One of the comics featured has Superman face off with Hitler, Goering, Goebbels and a fourth Nazi -- Himmler? Bormann?

Thanks for reading! Glenn Erickson

Monday April 14, 2014

Well, I'm back from the TCM Classic Film Festival, which was 3.5 long days of work but also quite a lot of fun. I spent most of the time running between theaters and writing and only saw three movies in their entirety. I Never Sang for My Father was much better than I expected it to be, while the 1949 The Great Gatsby was excellent, as was the previously unheard-of Edgar G. Ulmer picture, Her SIster's Secret.

Celebrities? Paula Prentiss was charming. Michael Schlesinger gave the best introduction by far, for Johnny Guitar. Thelma Schoonmaker's intro for A Matter of Life and Death found an appreciative audience. Arianné Ulmer Cipes spoke candidly about her father's unusual career. Kim Novak addressed the cruel reaction to her Oscar appearance, while Alan Arkin proved to be just as sharp-minded and warm as one would expect.

That stretch of Hollywood Blvd. feels like a carnival midway, only less organized. The mobs of festival attendees packed onto the sidewalks already crowded with tourists, costumed characters, hip-hop performers, tour bus hawkers, etc., made moving around very difficult at times. The fun part was occasionally feeling a like a member of an old-time press room up on the 2nd floor of the Roosevelt Hotel. Hosts, photographers, managers and talent wranglers came and went, and a central table had catered food. Myself and local TCM bloggers Nathaniel Thompson, Richard Harland Smith and Jeremy Arnold tapped away on our laptops along with Atlanta TCM writers Anna Davis and Stephanie Thames. We also got to hear the celebrity gossip.

When Robert Osborne was interviewing some personality down in the hotel foyer we were too deadline-busy to go look. All we would hear is a whoop of applause and cheering every forty seconds or so. It sounded just like the French Revolution out there, with the guillotine working overtime. And every couple of hours we had to run out to catch another screening or event. We're supposed to record the experience of TCM, not just write about the movies. We at least need to show up to listen to the speakers and report on whether the presentation was film or digital, what the crowd was like, etc.. Jeremy was laughing when he came back from My Sister Eileen. In it Rosalind Russell has to leave town because she falsified a newspaper review of a school play she didn't want to attend. It seemed more than relevant to our situation.

That's the good news. Right now I'm posting this because my review uploading connection to DVDtalk has broken down again. They're very good now about getting these problems straightened out so I have every hope that I can get DVD Savant up and running again today. When I do I'll post a nice blurry photo a friend grabbed of Kim Novak from Saturday. The reviews will be for Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia, Let the Fire Burn and Wonderwall.

Thanks for your patience! Glenn Erickson

Tuesday April 8, 2014

Savant's new reviews today are:

Columbia Pictures
Film Noir Classics IV


This is a delayed review, but who could pass up a film noir collection? Sony/Columbia's latest stack of murder and mystery contains two top rank thrillers, one police drama and two Cold War domestic espionage sagas: So Dark The Night, Johnny O'Clock, Walk A Crooked Mile, Between Midnight And Dawn and Walk East On Beacon! Stars include Dick Powell, Evelyn Keyes, Lee J, Cobb, Dennis O'Keefe, Raymond Burr, Mark Stevens, Edmond O'Brien, George Murphy, Ellen Drew and Nina Foch, and we see films from directors Joseph H. Lewis, Robert Rossen and Gordon Douglas. In DVD from TCM Vault Collection / Sony.


Stranger on the Prowl

I don't know anybody who's seen this rare movie until now. On the run from a subpoena from the HUAC, Joseph Losey directed this Italian movie about a criminal (Paul Muni, very good) fleeing from the law in a port town. Combining noir attitude with Italian neorealism, the show is both grim and sentimental. Joan Lorring has a good part; Ben Barzman wrote the script. Great locations as well. In Blu-ray from Olive Films.


I'm getting ready for the TCM Classic Film Festival, which may mean my posts to DVD Savant will be sparse next week ... it's a lot of work to do in a compressed period of time. This year it looks like I'll be reporting on appearances by Michael Schlesinger, Nancy Schoenberger Paula Prentiss, Merrie Spaeth, Thelma Schoonmaker, Quincy Jones, Illeana Douglas, David Ladd, Kim Novak, Arianne Ulmer Cipes and Alan Arkin. I'm not a celebrity hound but must admit that it's a nice group of personalities, notables and screen legends.

Meanwhile, Joe Dante sends along this great (and brief) funny video clip, An exclusive alternate scene from Gravity.

Also circulating on the web and located by Gary Teetzel is an unusual Promotional Featurette for Dr. Strangelove that would appear to be narrated by Stanley Kubrick. It's viewable in halves, Part One and Part Two.

Thanks for reading! -- Glenn Erickson

Alain Resnais' masterpiece is a highly accessible puzzle film that (eventually) takes a warm view of its characters. John Gielgud is a famous writer suffering from a possibly fatal condition, who occupies his mind by imagining and re-arranging scenarios using his grown children and other family members as characters. It's an amazing performance in a complex story -- which is also very easy to follow. Dirk Bogarde is Gielgud's son, in a performance that requires him to change characterization as his father rethinks his scenarios. David Warner, Ellen Burstyn and Elaine Stritch fill out the cast. In Region 2 PAL DVD from Jupiter (France).

King Kong vs. Godzilla
Universal's re-cut and re-dubbed version of Ishiro Honda's lavish original is even more of a farce. Goofy dialogue and Universal stock music peg the classic confrontation of the atomic dragon and the hairy ape as a kiddie attraction plain and simple. The spectacle is there, along with effects that range from sensational (a really impressive octopus) to terrible (ocean skies painted on brick walls). Godzilla is in color for the first time, and his wrestling match with a flimsy, patchwork Kong is played for laughs. In Blu-ray from Universal Home Video.

The Hidden Fortress
Akira Kurosawa's freewheeling samurai-era adventure is much, much more than the inspiration for Star Wars. Toshiro Mifune must trick two foolish runaway soldiers into helping him sneak a princess through enemy lines. It's high adventure in good humor, breaking even further with formal Japanese historical storytelling practice. It's also Kurosawa's first film in Tohoscope, and he uses the wide screen like a master. A Dual-Format edition in Blu-ray and DVD from The Criterion Collection.

Riot in Cell Block 11
Don Siegel made his name as a maker of hard hitting genre thrillers in this prison riot/exposé of prison conditions. Producer Walter Wanger assembles a terrific cast of character actors given (for once) meaty leading roles: Neville Brand, Emile Meyer, Frank Faylen, Leo Gordon, Robert Osterloh, Paul Frees, Alvy Moore, Dabbs Greer. The extras tell the whole story of the making of the movie, which is almost as entertaining as the movie itself. This one's been long neglected. A Dual-Format edition in Blu-ray and DVD from The Criterion Collection.

The Bamboo Saucer
This 1968 picture came out after 2001: A Space Odyssey and simply couldn't compete -- it's a low budget throwback to the Cold War 1950s, with the only updated idea being that America and Russia ought to join forces against the real enemy, Chairman Mao. The awkward story is half "lost patrol" movie and the rest half-baked Sci-Fi: American and Russian spy teams find a functioning flying saucer in Red China, and must learn to fly it before the Chinese Army closes in. But good playing from Dan Duryea, John Ericson and Lois Nettleton is scuttled by some of the worst special effects in Sci-fi film history. Beautifully transferred in Blu-ray from Olive Films.

Howard Hawks' big hit for 1962 is a relaxing African vacation with John Wayne's international crew of wild animal catchers. A casual atmosphere and typical Hawks social camaraderie are the norm, in between exciting rhino and giraffe pursuits, comedy sequences like the Baby Elephant Walk and bits of romantic horseplay. With Hardy Kruger, Elsa Martinelli and Red Buttons. With a music score by Henry Mancini, that some feel outlasted the film in popularity. In Blu-ray from Paramount / Warner Home Video.

The Killers
Don Siegel's tough minded, influential remake of Ernest Hemingway's crime story gets a new lease on life in this impressive HD release from England. Hit men Lee Marvin and Clu Gulager track down mobster Ronald Reagan and his frail Angie Dickinson to find out why their last victim John Cassavetes didn't put up a fight or run away. This rude & violent picture was made for TV, but booted upstairs to the big screen after it was deemed too violent for the tube. With some great extras. A Region B Blu-ray from Arrow Academy (UK).

The Eddy Duchin Story
Elegance and class drips from this dramatic musical biography of the New York pianist, an adaptation that doesn't smooth over the rough parts of his story. Tyrone Power is the optimistic star made bitter by tragedy and Kim Novak his beautiful uptown bride. Director George Sidney gives the picture a handsome look, with glossy romantic scenes filmed on overcast and inclement days in New York's Central Park. In Blu-ray from Twilight Time.

March 2014
 The Last Days of Sodom and Gomorrah  Cry Danger  Blu-ray  The Front  Blu-ray  The Swimmer  Blu-ray + DVD  Gunfight at the O.K. Corral  Blu-ray  Free and Easy + Estrellados  Roadblock  The Hunchback of Notre Dame  Blu-ray  Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom  Blu-ray  American Hustle  Blu-ray  The Americanization of Emily  Blu-ray  Thief  Blu-ray  Dead Kids Strange Behavior  Blu-ray  Elaine Stritch: Shoot Me Theatrical Review  The Nuisance  Invitation  5 Fingers  ...Et mourir de plaisir (...und vor Lust zu Sterben, Blood and Roses)  Region 2 DVD  Crimes and Misdemeanors  Blu-ray  Tess  Blu-ray + DVD  The Blue Max  Blu-ray  Foreign Correspondent  Blu-ray + DVD  Margin for Error  Jupiter's Darling
February 2014
 Thunderbolt and Lightfoot  Blu-ray  Thirst  Blu-ray  Du Rififi chez les hommes  Blu-ray + DVD  Heart of Darkness   Come Back, Africa - The Films of Lionel Rogosin, Volume 2  Blu-ray  Gravity  Blu-ray  Khartoum  Blu-ray  Savant Q&A Interview: Greg Kintz of The 3-D Film Archive on Man in the Dark  Dusty and Sweets McGee  Thor: The Dark World  Blu-ray  It's A Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World  Blu-ray + DVD  This Woman is Dangerous  The Vincent Price Collection: The Fall of the House of Usher, Pit and the Pendulum, The Haunted Palace, The Masque of the Red Death, Witchfinder General, The Abominable Dr. Phibes  Blu-ray  Million Dollar Baby  Blu-ray  Zulu  Blu-ray  Trans-Europ-Express  Blu-ray
January 2014
 Grey Gardens  Blu-ray  The Lady from Shanghai  Blu-ray  Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1920)  Blu-ray  Fearless  Blu-ray  Taxi  The Killing Fields  Blu-ray  Throne of Blood  Blu-ray + DVD  Martin Scorsese's World Cinema Project: Touki-Bouki, Redes, A River Called Titas, Dry Summer, Trances, The Housemaid  Blu-ray + DVD  Man in the Dark 3D  Blu-ray + 3-D  I Cannibali  Blu-ray  The Jerry Warren Collection Volume 1: Man Beast, Curse of the Stone Hand, The Wild World of Batwoman  Captain Phillips  Blu-ray  Royal Flash  Blu-ray  Young America  More Than Honey  Blu-ray  Sabata  Blu-ray + Region 2 DVD  Vivacious Lady  Many Wars Ago (Uomini contro)  Blu-ray  Corruption  Blu-ray  Lee Daniels' The Butler  Blu-ray  The Beast of Hollow Mountain  Blu-ray  The Neanderthal Man  Blu-ray  The Big Gundown Region A  Blu-ray  Stella Dallas

  Reaching further back in time?
A Chronological List of DVD Savant's Reviews for 2013
... and for 2012 ... and for 2011

 Savant's DVD Wish List FINAL NOTE 2012

Hundreds more Savant reviews at the Other End of this Link!


Don't forget to write Savant at dvdsavant@mindspring.com.

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Savant Text © Copyright 1997-2007 Glenn Erickson - Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise