Release List Reviews Price Search Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise
DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD/Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk TV
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



Newest Features
Article Index  Review Index
Favorite Discs of 2007

[Savant Links] [Year Five Report]
Write Savant (Glenn Erickson) at
dvdsavant@mindspring.com!
(dvdsavant@mindspring.com)

Saturday July 5, 2008

Savant's new reviews today are

Phase IV
Legend

and
Sophia Loren Four Film Collection
Attila, Carosello Napoletano, Madame Sans-Gêne, I Girasole
Lionsgate

Greetings! Big news in the world of Science Fiction today, as reported to me by corps of interested readers, correspondents and friends-- Aitam Bar-Sagi, Gary Teetzel, Darren Gross, David Zeil, Robert Gutowski, Guido Bibra, Mark Forer, Scott Henderson, Lee Broughton, Marshall Crawford, Sergio Mims and John Mastrocco. An almost intact 16mm dupe negative for the full-length original Metropolis has been found in Buenos Aires by Paula Félix -Didier. The Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau Stiftung company is figuring out what to do with it ... stills online look pretty bad as it's a not very good dupe in heavily -- heavily scratched condition. Aitam Bar-Sagi forwarded this letter from Martin Koerber, which is the clearest explanation of the discovery I've read so far.

"Dear all, I was just about to put this link into a message, when Tom beat me to it.

Paula Felix-Didiér of the Museo del Cine in Buenos Aires indeed came to Berlin last week to show us what she found, and it is the real thing, no hoax this time. The material is terribly banged up, being a 16 mm dupe negative made from a no longer extant nitrate print, which was duplicated some decades ago after many years of heavy use. Nevertheless one can now see the director's cut of Metropolis, 80 years after we all believed the original version was destroyed. Contrary to our thinking, obviously at least one print of the original cut made it into distribution, albeit in Argentina.

Only one of the missing scenes (the monk in the cathedral) remains missing, because it happened to be at a reel end that got badly torn. The rest is there.

The images you will find at the links Tom gave will show you some scenes, and also expose the amount of damage. They look indeed a little worse than the real thing, as they are frame grabs from a DVD transfer of the dupe.

About 10 pages of information and frame enlargements from many more missing sequences are in the printed edition of DIE ZEIT, which is coming out today. I guess you can find this at the news stands in most countries in Europe, don't know about the international edition overseas. Flip through it before you buy it, the articles about Metropolis are in the somewhat glossy "Zeit Magazin Leben" which comes with the paper. It will surely become a collector's item.

Kudos to Paula Felix-Didiér and her initiative to unearth the material and share the information.

A lot of thinking is now necessary to find ways to incorporate this material into the existing restoration, released on DVD by Transit Film and Kino International, among others. It has titles and black leader where the missing parts once were so in principle one could just insert whatever is new at those inserts. The good news is that Friedrich-Wilhelm-Murnau-Stiftung intends to do just that once access to the material has been granted.

The critical edition of Metropolis on DVD, which Enno Patalas derived from the 2001 restoration in order to create a "full" version of Metropolis has even more information about the missing scenes, and has the option to fill the missing scenes with not only black leader, but information from the script and other sources. When ran in synch with the material found in Buenos Aires, it is amazing to see how everything falls into place now.

The critical edition can be found here.

Martin Koerber
Leiter der Abteilung Film - Curator Film
Deutsche Kinemathek - Museum für Film und Fernsehen Berlin

That's it for now --- Happy 4th of July, as we proud Americans watch our fireworks displays -- which are mostly manufactured in Communist China! -- Glenn Erickson


Tuesday July 1, 2008

Greetings! A little late-ish but still under the wire. Savant's new reviews today are

The Furies
Criterion

and
Classe Tous Risques (At Any Risk)
Criterion

Well, I wanted to get Phase IV up tonight but I had to work late and the clock's running out, along with my energy level. It's a promise for Saturday.

More interesting news. Sony is launching its own DVD line of 'hip and cool' library titles called, for some undisclosed reason, "Martini Movies". Not all of them sound exactly hip, but the list definitely whets the appetite. The Anderson Tapes, The Garment Jungle, The New Centurions and Nickelodeon are planned for September 23, while this list of "future titles" was offered: Affair in Trinidad, The Comic / Enter Laughing, Five, Getting Straight, Gumshoe, The Heat's On, Husbands, I Never Sang for My Father, Nightwing, Our Man in Havana, Vibes. A good list by any measure.

DVD Beaver is reporting on a new region-free import Blu-ray of Michael Powell & Emeric Pressburger's Black Narcissus. The frame grabs comparisons are eye-opening; you can see them here.

I guess I'm going to be in trouble again. I've been receiving irate emails (well, 2 1/2 emails) berating me for praising the look of Patton on Blu-ray. Now that I've written a review (it's up at film.com as of tonight) saying that the new Blu-ray of Dirty Harry is wildly processed away from the drab prints I remember from 1971, the same web pundits are now praising it as a beautiful, authentic transfer! My review/article does agree with the basic web feeling that older titles on Blu-ray are being over-enhanced, to make the format look good. Thanks for reading! Glenn Erickson


NEWEST FEATURE ARTICLES
Phase IV
Saul Bass goes Sci-Fi ethereal, with this ecological, apocalyptic tale of researchers battling a super-intelligent ant colony. Nigel Davenport, Michael Murphy and Lynne Frederick star. Legend.   7/05/08

Sophia Loren Four Film Collection
Lionsgate takes a dip in a selection of vintage Sophia Loren pictures: Attila, Carosello Napoletano, Madame Sans-Gêne, and I Girasole. No top pictures, but a couple of surprises.   7/05/08

The Furies
Anthony Mann's earliest Western epic contains great performances by Barbara Stanwyck and Walter Huston, in a story that plays out like Greek drama crossed with Bonanza. Great dialogue, surprising violence, cruel turns of fate -- a real keeper.   7/01/08

Classe Tous Risques (At Any Risk)
Claude Sautet's crime drama balances exciting action with the penalties of life on the run, as Lino Ventura and Jean-Paul Belmondo try to smuggle themselves back to Paris. This is the kind of gritty, no-nonsense French thriller that may have inspired the American cop movies of the 70s. In glorious B&W, with plenty of Criterion extras.   7/01/08

Journey to the Far Side of the Sun
We like it, it's a childhood favorite, but Gerry and Sylvia Anderson's far-out space picture is a bare concept that goes absolutely nowhere. Psychedelic space naps, actors without marionette strings, rockets, things blowin' up. Boom! Universal.   6/28/08

The Restoration of The Quatermass Xperiment
Savant dropped in on an audio layback session for a new HD master of this Val Guest classic, and lived to write it up. An article that first appeared at film.com.   6/28/08

Heartbeat Detector
A strange French film featuring the star of The Diving Bell and the Butterfly. Pulled into an office power play, a human resources director finds that his company's history -- and his own personnel management style -- owe a lot to the Nazi past. New Yorker.   6/28/08

Hitler: The Last Ten Days
Legend reaches into Paramount's vault again to present this respectable true story of the final week + of the Third Reich, holed up in a battered Berlin bunker. The big attraction is Alec Guinness' interpretation of Adolph Hitler -- he gets high marks for a difficult role.   6/24/08

 Shinobi no mono 2: Vengeance  The Night They Raided Minsky's  The Man Who Could Cheat Death  The Professionals Blu-ray  Django - Die Totengraber Warten Schon (Johnny Hamlet) and   Im Staub der Sonne (Shoot, Gringo, Shoot) Region 2 PAL reviews by Lee Broughton  Starting Out in the Evening  Patton Blu-ray  High Noon Ultimate Collector's Edition  The Fire Within  There Will Be Blood Blu-ray  Indiana Jones: The Connect the Dots Game  Cloverfield Blu-ray   Icons of Adventure: The Stranglers of Bombay, The Terror of the Tongs, The Devil-Ship Pirates, The Pirates of Blood River  Day of the Outlaw  The Willow Tree  Company: A Musical Comedy  Tobor the Great  The Andromeda Strain 2008  Grace Is Gone  Night of the Living Dead 40th Anniversary  Desperate Characters  Carve Her Name With Pride  Easy Living  The Sand Pebbles Blu-ray  The Secret Invasion  The Man With The Golden Arm   Frank Sinatra The Golden Years: The Tender Trap, The Man with the Golden Arm, Some Came Running, None but the Brave, Marriage on the Rocks  Some Came Running  Baby It's You  The One That Got Away  The Thief of Bagdad  Man of the West  The Movie Orgy (Special Screening Notes)

 DVD Savant 2007 Favored Disc Roundup

 SAVANT'S DVD WISH LIST 2008

Hundreds more Savant reviews at the Other End of this Link!


Archives

Don't forget to write Savant at dvdsavant@mindspring.com.

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Savant Text © Copyright 1997-2007 Glenn Erickson - Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)

Release List Reviews Price Search Shop SUBSCRIBE Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray/ HD DVD Advertise