DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

The Deep
Savant Blu-ray Review


The Deep
Blu-ray
Sony
1977 / Color / 2:35 widescreen / 124 min. / Street Date July 7, 2009 / 28.95
Starring Robert Shaw, Jacqueline Bisset, Nick Nolte, Louis Gossett, Eli Wallach, Robert Tessier.
Cinematography Christopher Challis
Production Design Tony Masters
Film Editor David Berlatsky
Underwater Director Al Giddings
Original Music John Barry
Written by Tracy Keenan Wynn and Peter Benchley from his novel
Produced by Peter Guber
Directed by Peter Yates

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

After a couple of early 1970s shows that became enormous blockbusters --Love Story, The Godfather -- Universal's Jaws dominated the summer box office in 1975, inaugurating the trend toward massive crowd-pleasing event movies. The direct follow-up to Spielberg's shark attack picture was 1977's The Deep, another seagoing adventure starring Robert Shaw and based on the best-seller by the Jaws scribe, Peter Benchley. In June of 1977 nine out of ten moviegoers could probably be found lining up for Star Wars for the 4th or 5th time. But just down the street The Deep was doing respectable business as well, earning back 2/3 of its nine $ million budget in its first weekend.

The Deep is a commercially conceived, professionally filmed action thriller with a very weak story. On the plus side are good performances from attractive stars, plus some truly outstanding underwater cinematography. But even patient audiences balked at buying a plot that just didn't seem to make much sense. Of course, today's action thrillers are so lame-brained that The Deep would score above-average marks for sophistication.

Romantic vacationers Gail Berke and David Sanders (Jacqueline Bisset & Nick Nolte) dive on the wreck of the WW2 steamer Goliath, finding samples of two kinds of treasure -- a Spanish medallion and an ampoule of morphine, one of thousands being sent to the front lines in Europe. They're soon kidnapped and threatened by Henri Cloche (Louis Gossett), the local Haitian crime lord. Seeking aid from famed treasure hunter Romer Treece (Robert Shaw), Gail and David join forces to collect the morphine (to buy off Cloche) while investigating a second wreck of an 18th century treasure ship. But skullduggery is afoot -- Romer's pal Adam Coffin (Eli Wallach) is feeding information to Cloche behind Romer's back.

The Deep can't be beat for diverting entertainment. The Bermudan locations are as beautiful as the actors, who give their thinly written parts considerable star-power depth. Robert Shaw is an educated, less salty version of his shark hunter from Jaws. In his feature breakout showcase, Nick Nolte is masculine and intelligent, and quite likeable. Jacqueline Bisset is a spirited and capable in the role of "the girl" in a masculine adventure. Bisset is also the film's most impressive special effect -- she plays the entire first episode in a wet T-shirt, a spectacle guaranteed to make most males light-headed. It's a clear victory for the talented Bisset -- she's such a classy actress that she transcends definitions of exploitation.

About a third of The Deep involves underwater scuba-diving scenes that still haven't been beaten. In the extras we discover that the three stars and director Peter Yates did their own diving, even some of the stunts. Most movie scuba scenes soon lapse into boredom, even in the James Bond movie Thunderball, the previous champion in the swim fins 'n' bubbles genre. Yates and underwater director Al Giddings build terrific sequences in the wrecks of sunken ships. We don't need expository voiceover -- careful direction allows us to follow everything that goes on quite clearly.

The production is so attractive that we're over an hour into the show before questions of common sense arise. I remember audiences laughing at the ability of the divers to communicate in one scene, just by "shouting" underwater. The film's overall technical credibility keeps me from calling it an oversight. But a number of other questions arise to undermine the film's overall effect.

Romer Treece lives in a trendy converted lighthouse just a couple of miles from a fabulous unexplored wreck that lies within sight of a resort hotel. Everyone knows that the Goliath contains a fortune in drugs because Adam Coffin was one of its crew. The wreck has been off limits because of the danger of munitions on board. In thirty years, no maritime authority has blown up the wreck to remove the obvious threat to nosy tourists. Romer is able to park his boat over the wreck for days on end without attracting any local law enforcement. The movie claims that the treasure has been uncovered only recently, but we think Romer and Cloche would have been out there looking on a weekly basis.

Gail and David are kidnapped and threatened; Gail is strip-searched and terrorized with a voodoo ritual. Yet the couple calmly goes about their treasure hunting. David even leaves Gail alone and unprotected in her hotel room knowing that Cloche's hoods are at large. 1977 audiences didn't buy that at all. They were also amused by the casual portrayal of the bad guys as sinister blacks. Live and Let Die had an all-black gang of criminals, but it was a comedy and at least half the jokes were at the expense of James Bond and other white clowns. The villains in The Deep are all colorless nobodies except for Louis Gossett, and he isn't very clever either.

Finally, we aren't sure what Romer & Co. intend to do with the zillions in hot morphine. The Deep underplays its drug angle but the trio certainly seem willing to risk letting all that dope get on the market. The treasure hunt adventure is pretty much a criminal enterprise even for the heroes, and Peter Benchley's story doesn't seem to have an opinion about that one way or another.

As long as one accepts the TV mystery plotting The Deep is very enjoyable. The film uses a giant Moray Eel as sort of a Serpent Ex Machina, but it packs a terrific shark attack scene among its numerous underwater thrills. The three treasure hunters do some fun historical searches in Romer's library. Not only does Romer possess original manifests and other Castillian gold shipment records, all three heroes apparently read archaic Spanish! And there's some vicarious fun in the belly of a sunken ship, using a dredge vacuum to suck the sand away from a fortune in bobbing bottles of dope. We immediately identify with David when he drops his facemask to squeeze through a narrow slot to reach a priceless gold bauble poking out of the sand.

A question for drug-o-philes: does liquid morphine have an expiration date? It would be fun to see Cloche murdering half the island to secure possession of the dope, only to find out that it has all turned to sugar water. That's a problem worth investigating. You go ask your pharmacist. I'll check out the first underwater scene in The Deep again, just to see if there are any clues there. Maybe I'll watch it two more times, to make sure!  1


Sony's Blu-ray of The Deep is a viewing pleasure -- two hours of exciting action in an exotic location without a trace of CGI. Good action thrillers have become so rare that The Deep's modest virtues shine by comparison. The movie stars really swam, in real water! The producers had to go to Australia to film the shark scenes! It's (gasp) a real movie.

The HD picture looks great at all times. Colorful fish surround the divers as they snoop for buried treasure, and the enormous close-ups of Ms. Bisset revive Old Hollywood notions of glamour. Composer John Barry's main theme isn't very memorable but nobody betters him for dreamy underwater atmospheres ... his shifting tones improve on his already sterling work for Thunderball.

The disc has two good extras. A 1977 making-of CBS Special is a glorified promo that may have hurt the movie's box office by giving away practically all of its surprises. Robert Shaw hosts what could be called "The Deep for Dummies"; we see Peter Guber, director Yates and the stars suiting up for the demanding underwater work.

The Deep was expanded for a longer TV version, which is not included on the disc. But a "select scenes" extra gathers four or five sequences from the longer show, none of which are needed. IMDB doesn't list him, but unless I'm mistaken Cameron Mitchell plays the captain of Goliath in a deleted prologue. The other deleted clips are mostly longer dialogue scenes. In one very confusing addition, the under-used Eli Wallach tells Jacqueline Bisset that Robert Shaw's Romer Treece character was once a drug runner, or maybe a crime kingpin -- he and Cloche "have a history" together. That biography doesn't mesh well with Treece's present non-job as an eccentric treasure hunter -- unless his previous crime spree involved stealing the contents of Spanish libraries!  2


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, The Deep Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Very Good ++
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: CBS TV special from 1977, deleted scenes.
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: July 3, 2009

Footnotes:

1. Reader Edward Sullivan has the morphine ampoule answer, 7.04.09:

Hello Glenn ... These studies indicate that concentrated Morphine solutions are stable for 3 months under all conditions tested, but should be stored at 22°C to avoid precipitation.

"The solubility of morphine and the stability of concentrated morphine solutions in glass, polypropylene syringes and PVC containers."

and

"Looks like tablets are a lot more stable; 36 months plus (if dry and dark)."

Of course, ampoules make for a much more sexy MacGuffin... Ed Sullivan
Return

2. A note from Chris Baker, 7.04.09:

Hi Glenn, Regarding your review of The Deep: the film is set in (and mostly shot in) Bermuda, not the Bahamas. Bermuda's frequently confused with the Bahamas, and/or thought to be in the Caribbean, whereas in fact it's the second-most-isolated island (actually group of islands) in the world. (The first-most-isolated is St. Helena, where Napoleon was exiled)

I was living there at the time and watched some of the filming; my friend Scott had a job as a driver and was very impressed with Robert Tessier, the (usually bald) heavy specialist who'd had a lot of biker roles and discussed stuntwork with him.

The locals overall didn't care for the movie on release, largely because it didn't differentiate Bermuda from other places: it was presented as being a mashup of Haiti, Jamaica, the Bahamas; none of the accents were correct, and the culture was largely ignored or misrepresented. Haven't seen it for years so I don't recall too many particulars.

I do remember that the shark feeding-frenzy scenes were decried: there is no major shark activity of that kind in the area, and the footage was from Australia. Local officials were extremely upset that tourists -- and there is essentially no industry except tourism -- would now think they were taking their lives in their hands if they visited. Of course the officials were probably so dazzled by having the stars around that they didn't vet the script as they should have.

My mother got paired with Robert Shaw at a golf tournament at the Mid-Ocean Club and she got him to autograph a scorecard for me: "Hi Chris: your mother's a great putter". !!!

I always enjoy (and trust) your reviews and information, so keep 'em coming. Thanks! -- Chris Baker
Return



DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2009 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are often updated and annotated with reader input and graphics. Also, don't forget the
2009 Savant Wish List. T'was Ever Thus.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)

Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise