DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD/Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
XCritic.com
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

Columns



DVD SAVANT

4K Restoration
Twilight Time
Savant Blu-ray Review



Journey to the Center of the Earth
Blu-ray
Twilight Time
Limited Edition

1959 / Color / 2:35 CinemaScope / 129 min. / Ship Date March 10, 2015 / available through Screen Archives Entertainment / 29.95
Starring Pat Boone, James Mason, Arlene Dahl, Diane Baker, Thayer David, Peter Ronson, Peter Wright
Cinematography Leo Tover
Art Direction: Franz Bachelin, Herman A. Blumenthal, Lyle R. Wheeler
Film Editors: Stuart Gilmore, Jack W. Holmes
Original Music Bernard Herrmann
Written by Charles Brackett, Walter Reisch from the novel Voyage au centre de la Terre by Jules Verne
Produced by Charles Brackett
Directed by Henry Levin

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

Twilight Time released a dandy Blu-ray of the major childhood favorite Journey to the Center of the Earth just three years ago, but that limited edition run soon sold out. A second go at the title isn't just to make more available for collectors: since then a new 4K restoration has been conducted on this CinemaScope dazzler. Now properly equipped, I'll compare the versions later in the review.

20th Fox's 1959 Christmas release is an engaging and amusing foray into big-time adventure. It's also one of those happy accidents in which a major studio created great entertainment from a story that begged to be cheapened. For that we can thank Walt Disney's uncompromised adaptation of 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, which set the standard for high-budget Jules Verne fantasies. Producer Charles Brackett signed up Disney's Captain Nemo, James Mason and surrounded him with a capable cast that included teen crooner Pat Boone, who is not at all bad. Best of all, the adroit sense of humor in Brackett's script maintains a reasonable level of seriousness while allowing tongue-in-cheek tone. The result is fantastic escapism with something for everyone.

Verne's story proposes the existence of a vast prehistoric world existing beneath our feet. A mysterious volcanic rock leads freshly knighted professor Oliver Lindenbrook (James Mason) to Iceland to seek Arne Saknussem's secret trail to the center of the Earth. Braving a rival who tries to steal his expedition and a haughty, duplicitous Saknussem heir (Thayer David), Lindenbrook goes bravely forward into the unknown, accompanied by his protégée Alec McEwen (Pat Boone), guide Hans Belker (Peter Ronson) and the widow of his rival, the redheaded, single-minded Mrs. Carla Goeteborg (Arlene Dahl).

When searching Verne properties to exploit, Journey to the Center of the Earth must have seemed a risky proposition. Nobody had touched the tale since a long-lost silent Spanish version, and previous spelunking adventures hadn't really caught on as movie subject matter. Except perhaps for Tom Sawyer and Becky Thatcher's spooky cave experience in the 1938 Tom Sawyer stories set inside the Earth were of the forgettable kind: Superman and the Mole Men, The Night the World Exploded. The show that came closest to borrowing the Verne concept was 1951's Unknown World, a sober but forgotten adventure about a vehicle called a Cyclotram. Drilling its way into the Earth's mantle, it finds... essentially nothing.  1

Jules Verne's fanciful prehistoric world still thriving at the core of our planet is a concept that doesn't mesh well with 20th-Century science. The best decision by producer Charles Brackett (Billy Wilder's ex-partner) was to retain the original's 19th-Century period trappings. George Pal found success updating H.G. Wells' War of the Worlds, but Verne's antique tales are rooted in 19th century whimsy -- Nemo's Nautilus would pale next to the real, atomic version already in service in 1959. With the story firmly rooted in the fantastic, the biggest problems are neatly sidestepped with enthusiastic silly-science. Verne's inner Earth isn't a furnace of molten rock. Our explorers encounter fresh air, surface gravity and pressure, right down to the real nitty gritty. Most convenient is the discovery of luminous crystals that allow both unassisted sight and Color by DeLuxe to function, long after the hikers' lamps have rusted out.

Journey to the Center of the Earth compensates for its lack of scientific accuracy with Adventure with a capital A, the kind that finds brave souls stepping off into the unknown with no reasonable expectation of coming back alive. It's the daring spirit that the great explorers and even Conquistadores must have shared: life is short, cities are dirty and work is dull, so why not go for broke and risk all on a mad quest? The Scots and Icelandic explorers may argue over provisions and double-dealing, but all respond to the challenge of adventure, even the dastardly villain.

Journey to the Center of the Earth carefully prepares us for its fantasy, something modern films no longer have patience for. By the time they descend into the crater below Scartarus, our characters are firmly established. Pat Boone is an uncomplicated fellow with a girl left behind in Edinburgh (the underused, terrific Diane Baker of Strait-Jacket and Silence of the Lambs). Peter Ronson is the non-macho strong man and climbing expert (in real life as well, a nice touch). He's given a pet duck named Gertrud as a fob to the Disney audience. Ronson provides needed balance against Boone's persistent singing and rosy-cheeked optimism ("Hi Hi! Professor!").

James Mason's respected professor Lindenbrook sputters and throws the occasional tantrum. But he also beams like a five year-old at new discoveries and dances a jig upon hearing good news. Mason holds the picture together with his commanding voice, which smoothes over the roughest episodes. When the center of the globe turns out to be a wholly illogical whirlpool in a wholly illogical ocean (which direction is UP?), we're distracted by a cutaway to Diane Baker back up top and diverted by expertly delivered dialogue. Mason treats his line, "This is it! The magnetic center of the Earth!" as beautifully as his, "Matters of this sort are best settled from a great height" from North By Northwest.

The writers make an excellent case for bringing the requisite 'woman' along for what was originally an all-male safari into a hole in the ground. Ex-MGM beauty Arlene Dahl was best known for some spectacular redheaded close-ups in other people's musicals. Her character's sense of dignity helps convey a convincing period setting. The engaging banter between the widow and her dead husband's rival is given its due instead of being used as filler. A real romance builds, along with our affection for all the adventurers, something rare in movies of this kind. And of course, every movie with dinosaurs at the center of the earth, needs a woman to scream at them.

The sense of class and balance in the light mood of Journey to the Center of the Earth compares well with the later Spielberg Indiana Jones movies, one of which borrows Earth's giant rolling rock gag. But most new action adventures tend to run fast and stupid, impatient for anything but a shorthand beeline to 'the good stuff.' When a Spielberg-era thrill ride movie is over, we indeed feel as if we're being hustled out of the carnival tent to make way for the next batch of suckers. This old Fox film is more satisfying. It has a feeling of substance, even with an ending that wraps things up with the convenience of a ride on an express elevator out of Alice's rabbit-hole -- itself swiped for yet another Indiana Jones movie.

The final clincher, and a main reason why Journey keeps its sparkle, is the thunderous score by Bernard Herrmann. Away from the picture it's a tad repetitive, but in context it brings to life every facet of the journey, even when the scenery edges toward the phony side. Journey, like Brackett & Herrmann's earlier Garden of Evil, is a 'music & landscape' picture -- his staccato rhythms lend the western the flavor of a fantasy film. Here the music is a dynamic dirge, sinking ever deeper, lower. In the original 4- track stereo release, and here on this lossless HD track, the opening chords dip lower and heavier, and still lower -- making one's stomach rumble like SenSurround!



The Twilight Time Blu-ray of Journey to the Center of the Earth 4K restoration has built-in appeal -- there's no better family sci-fi adventure -- but owners of the previous Twilight Time disc will want to know how it compares. I thought the older disc was an good scan that corrected a lot of problems with what must be very faded film elements.

But I'm not kidding -- the new 4K scan is such an improvement that one would think the old disc was a DVD. EVERYTHING is sharper, cleaner and less grainy. Color values are perhaps a little cool, but they were on the old disc too. The biggest improvement is in the effects, which look more natural in almost every case. Most all of the grain on the matte painting composite shots is missing. The color matching in some scenes may seem a bit less bright, but it works to tie the sequences together. The only real grain I saw was in the sandy 'jumping lizard' sequence, and those shots are very possibly optical blow ups. Some people complain about the lizards (particularly how they are mistreated) but the scenes are helped considerably by cutting to many angles -- it doesn't look as if the direction 'chokes up' in the Dimetrodon scenes.

It's a much-improved presentation altogether... I can see why Twilight Time was eager to give it another go. It reminds me of the incredible restored 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea we saw at AMIA in 2011 or 2012 ... I surely wish Disney would release that.

The DTS-HD MA audio track will still rattle loose objects lying around the room. Herrmann's descending chords in the title sequence will certainly get the attention of viewers with powerful home theater equipment. I remember seeing Journey to the Center of the Earth in the theater at age seven -- it was my 'special birthday treat' -- and being aware that the audio was overpowering. I certainly didn't know what stereophonic sound was.

Twilight Time again includes their Isolated Score Track, with its built-in appeal to the Bernard Herrmann faithful. The cues I heard were from file tracks, complete with vocal IDs. Also here is the English language original trailer, but in a 1:85 version. TT's previous disc had two trailers in CinemaScope -- this English one stylishly narrated by James Mason (with preferred billing for Gertrud the duck!), and a Spanish trailer with terrific text cards like "ABAJO -- ABAJO -- ABAJO!"

Julie Kirgo's dependably informative insert pamphlet essay has been repeated on a newly designed that carries artwork that mirrors that of TT's First Men in the Moon, released at the same time. If they were posters, they'd stack quite handsomely. Interestingly, both movies begin with scenes in which something mineral (a rock, a molten metal compound) is heated in a giant furnace.

A new extra is an audio commentary in which Nick Redman hosts actress Diane Baker and Bernard Herrmann scholar and biographer Steven C. Smith. Ms. Baker's part in the film is fairly brief, but she has a lot to say that's relevant on the experience and her fellow actors. Journey was just her second film, straight from the set of The Diary of Anne Frank. As part of Fox's publicity, she went on two lunch dates with King Hussein of Jordan. Redman and Smith also provide interesting info on how the movie came to be, and how Pat Boone's $ participation in the show turned into an accidental gold mine for him -- even though he didn't want to be in it. Maybe he didn't want to play opposite a duck. Ms. Baker and Smith seem to hit it off, and although much of the track is devoted to her career, it's a great listen.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor,
Journey to the Center of the Earth Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Excellent
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Isolated Score Track, audio Commentary with Diane Baker, and Steven C. Smith & Nick Redman; trailer, Julie Kirgo liner notes
Deaf and Hearing Impaired Friendly? YES; Subtitles: English
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: March 23, 2015




Text © Copyright 2015 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are often updated and annotated with reader input and graphics.
T'was Ever Thus.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © DVDTalk.com All rights reserved | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)

Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise