DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD / Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Adult
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Special Offer
Search: For:
Reviews » Blu-ray Reviews » The Tree of Life (Blu-ray)
The Tree of Life (Blu-ray)
Fox // PG-13 // October 11, 2011 // Region Free
List Price: $39.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Thomas Spurlin | posted October 8, 2011 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
The Film:



Terrence Malick's means of communication -- both visually and tonally -- often relies on the underlying power of the periphery beauty surrounding the stories he tells. Rolling wheat fields in Days of Heaven reflect on the splendor of America's agricultural cornerstone in the early 1900s, while serving as a lingering precursor for events to come. The New World divides its focuses among the gloriousness of season- changing, from falling leaves and rushing brooks to the starving severity of snow, as it tells the familiar story of the war (both internal and external) among Native Americans and settlers. So, what happens when Malick takes on the full breadth of life itself? Something grand and flooring is expected from The Tree of Life: a symphonic poem that'll rock the soul with its artistic allure while saying plenty about its subject matter. But even as Malick accomplishes this, the span of his vision proves too sprawling, rendering his latest into a stunning, abstract, yet imprecise and scattered work of allegorical beauty.

With his signature perspective-shifting narration and sweeping aesthetic focus in tow, the magic and mystery of life's trickle-down effect becomes the root structure underneath Malick's non-linear challenge, where he aims to juxtapose the genesis of existence as we know it -- or, at least, as it's theorized on a scientific level -- against a portrait of '50s domesticity. Grand images of swirling nebulous (biological, lava-based, water-based) and, yes, several full-bodied (computer-generated) dinosaurs occupy the film's earlier moments, following shortly after images of a family grieving an unknown calamity. After we've seen the creation of life on a broad scale, we're shown another version of the creation of life on more intimate terms: the growth, development, and contorted maturation of three brothers under the parentage of a delicate mother (Jessica Chastain) and a loving but stern bread-winner father (Brad Pitt). Malick also interjects modern-era images of a man (Sean Penn) going about his own version of a domestic life and, intermittently, walking through canyon passages, while reminiscing on these past images -- memories? -- playing before us.

Everything centered on the family dynamic is powerful, breathtakingly so, in a way only Malick can orchestrate. Slight facial nuance and instinctive camera movement through rustic Americana remains an evocative playground for the director, where he follows the family's ebbing and flowing, during affectionate times and volatile, with a concise eye for the emotional spectrum. Memories of childhood, fatherly conversations, and the simple scene of boys sprinting on a dirt road possess an emotional clarity that's purely his doing, mostly centering on the eldest son Jack and how the firm hand of his growingly-terse father -- and the weak hand of his mother -- alters his composure in regards to obedience and destructive tendencies. In essence, his morphing outlook becomes a portrait within a portrait, where one can see flickers of Malick's own Badlands in the shrewd slow-boil of destructive tension and rebellion as aftereffects. Taken on its own terms and considering the astute performances, especially from a warm, stony, then menacing Brad Pitt and the disarming moral compass-spinning of newcomer Hunter McCracken as Jack, the heart of the film strikes a deft chord as it captures the passing of temperament from parents to children.

But that's not the sole point to The Tree of Life, which harbors a much more complex motivation. Malick also throws his full creative hand on the table by constructing his view-from-the-top perception of life's enduring essence, which renders images of time and space that hearken to both the free-form imagery of Stan Brakhage to the formalistic steadiness of Stanley Kubrick, all within the boundaries of the director's own cinematic meter. I understand the point that Malick attempts to arrive at -- or, at least, how I interpret what he's after -- by juxtaposing the two versions of life's development against each other. He's illustrating the gradient of growing pains in both biological and emotional forms (and, at times, one in the same), connecting the similarities of nature-dictated development spanning across time in terms of environmental shaping. And he concurrently, and daringly, dabbles in contemplations of higher-being faith, fear, and the inherent differences amongst people in the process. There's a lot going on, and it's mesmerizing in a quasi-meta sort of way.

The components of The Tree of Life, however, don't cohesively snap together as a whole, the all-embracing perspective spread out like a net cast too far and wide without catching a unified viewpoint. Some will look at the non-linear abstractness of bubbling primitive creation paired against wispy, dramatic Americana and revel in the mysterious and imaginative expression resonating in its divided parts. It's clear, though, that Malick has attempted to assemble a montage with a firmer overlying message than segmented impressions, yet the connecting-of-dots occurs in a way that isn't readily apparent -- and, even after further introspection, still isn't. He overextends his avant-garde sensibilities, from the too-lengthy churning cosmos that separates the past from the present to the clumsy usage of Sean Penn's place in the narrative as an older iteration of Jack, and by the end the big picture left me more exhausted than enthralled by Malick's enigmatic contemplations. Considering that his films are already deliberate in pacing, focus, and visual manner, stretching his topic wider in this way without clearer concentration waters down its poignancy. It's graspable, or at least parts of it, but the cinematic reward for doing so doesn't balance against the effort it demands.

While trying to figure The Tree of Life out, and depending on the level of investment that the viewer places into the film, its beauty and clandestine magnetism still casts a spell through its expressiveness, and the time passes somewhat effortlessly because of it. Aesthetically, it's beyond what's expected; the cinematography from Children of Men photographer Emmanuel Lubezki astounds with its graceful flow through '50s Texas (and elsewhere), while the elegantly-handled mix of familiar and original scoring from Alexandre Desplat creates a sweeping aural experience that marries the visual's tone flawlessly. This orchestration of sonic and dramatic potency might provoke thought inside what Malick has judiciously pieced together, due purely to his cinematic style, or it might infuriate with its scope -- or, like with me, it might do a bit of both at the same time. There's no denying his captivating vision, though, and that's to be celebrated even in the wake of strewn realization, where a great 110-minute work of art strains within 135+ minutes of entrancing overexertion.


The Blu-ray:




In an interesting turn from Fox Home Entertainment, The Tree of Life arrives exclusively in a three-disc Blu-ray package contained within a standard-width, overlapping-tray case: Disc Two is a bare-bones DVD of the film, while Disc Three is the Digital Copy offering. Inner artwork handsomely dresses the package's inside, with film credits adorning the left-hand side of the package, while a cardboard slipcase replicates the front and back designs.


Video and Audio:

While the content of The Tree of Life may be polarizing, even dividing more devoted fans of Malick's work, there's no arguing the caliber of excellence in Fox's Blu-ray. Really, if I could get away with copy-'n-pasting the words "perfect" and "astonishing" over and over, then it'd just as accurately summarize the impressions left. Framed at 1.85:1 to preserve the film's theatrical distribution ratio, this 1080p transfer is a work of art, capturing a full spectrum of interior and exterior shots and free-form cosmos with razor-sharp robustness and impeccably film-like presence. The most significant element to the visual tone is the shifts from daytime to dusk and night, and how it changes the lighting in the household and rural expanses; the contrast levels, saturation in grass and stained wood, skin-tone balance and textures in close-ups, and the ability to present rays of light pouring into shadowy areas is spot-on. Conversely, the under-the-microscope swirling imagery projects unyielding colors and contours, while you'll find nary an instance of distortion, compression hiccups, anything. Describing it sounds like hyperbole, but it's not.

The quality carries over into the audio treatment, to which this 7.1-channel DTS-HD Master Audio track delivers a literal symphony for the ears. Classical music intermingles with Alexandre Desplat's original scoring, and the fluttering of strings, pianos, and percussion instruments approaches the goosebump-inducing potency delivered from reference-level music discs. Where I noticed the most staggering, surprising elements of the sound delivery, however, arrived during the early years of creation, around the cackling of fire and brimstone around volcanoes; throaty, exquisitely-balanced bass marries with the staggering breadth of mid-range elements as lava churns and rocks tumble. But when it comes to the bread-and-butter of the track, dialogue slipstreaming along the subtle sound effects of domesticity and outdoors playing, Fox's Blu-ray really delivers. You'll hear the sound of footsteps along hardwood floors that echo against the walls, the crash of a windowpane and the pop of a BB gun, and the rushing of water sprawling out among the channels into an astonishingly complete aural experience. A 2.0 track can also be selected, while English and Spanish subtitles have been made available.


Special Features:

Exploring The Tree of Life (29:55, HD AVC):
Around the time of the film's theatrical release, a short conversation with Christopher Nolan and David Fincher was released where they discussed the fabric and potency of Terrence Malick's directorial style -- and what he's accomplished with The Tree of Life. Turns out, these interview snippets were part of the bigger-picture piece available here, which mixes reflections of the cast, producers, and the two previously-mentioned directors as they analyze and confer about Terrence Malick's production. Jessica Chastain talks about the audition process, Brad Pit delves into Malick's note-taking, the actors who play the brothers revisit the home a few years after shooting and discuss working with movie stars (and what was difficult about acting), and they all discuss Smithville, Texas, the shooting location. Such a shame to not see/hear Sean Penn's thoughts on the film, though (even if it's expected, given his confusion and frustration with some of Terrence Malick's artistic aims with the film: Link). It's a free-flowing, calm, and insightful piece, which it should be given that it's the only special feature and not terribly long.

Complimenting the featurette, a fine Theatrical Trailer (2:07, HD AVC) illustrates the tone and purpose of the film eloquently.


Final Thoughts:

The Tree of Life, much like Terrence Malick's other films, isn't a casual cinematic experience. Beautiful, involving, yet deliberate and challenging, his vision explores the connection between the creation of life on a primal level with the growing pains of domesticity in the '50s, and it's a singular exploration that allows audiovisual purity and thematic essence to engulf the audience. But while it'll mesmerize, and the entirety of the '50s Texas household life is handled to a pitch-perfect degree (alongside exquisite performances), the disparity between the two "halves" of Malick's point make for a cluttered, unfocused juxtaposition that can't quite discover a clear marriage of ideas within its sprawling focus. The abstractness, the grace of its emotional visual temper, and its overall resonance do make subsequent viewing well worth the time, though -- said from someone who has seen it three times now, and was left stirred in some fashion with each one. You really need to check out this Blu-ray if you're going to see it, as it'll take some truly potent year-end discs to dethrone it as the most robust high-definition experience I've seen this year. Recommended.



Thomas Spurlin, Staff Reviewer -- DVDTalk Reviews | Personal Blog/Site
Other Reviews:
Find the lowest price for 'The Tree of Life (Blu-ray)'
Popular Reviews
1. Godzilla (2014)
2. Hannibal: Season Two
3. South Park: Season 17
4. Arrow: Season 2
5. The Rover
6. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
7. Eraserhead
8. The Great Train Robbery
9. Flesh + Blood
10. Any Given Sunday: 15th Anniversary


Special Offers
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Special Offers
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2014 All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use