DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



The Day the Earth Stood Still
3-Disc Special Edition
Savant Blu-ray Review

The Day the Earth Stood Still
Fox Home Entertainment
2008 / Color / 2:35 widescreen / 104 min. / Street Date April 7, 2009 / Three-Disc Special Edition 39.99
Starring Keanu Reeves, Jennifer Connelly, Kathy Bates, Jaden Smith, John Cleese, Jon Hamm, Kyle Chandler, Robert Knepper, James Hong.
Cinematography David Tattersall
Production Design David Brisbin
Film Editor Wayne Wahrman
Original Music Tyler Bates
Written by David Scarpa from a screenplay by Edmund H. North
Produced by Paul Harris Boardman, Gregory Goodman, Erwin Stoff
Directed by Scott Derrickson

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

Although the new The Day the Earth Stood Still wasn't embraced by movie audiences, its strong opening weekend numbers reinforced the notion that movie remakes are still a good business bet. Fox's problem is that, short of a work of genius, any revisit of Robert Wise's beloved 1951 classic is bound to be an exercise in futility. When director Scott Derrickson's remake follows screenwriter Edmund H. North's original outline it seems lazy. But most of its new ideas pale before the inspired simplicity of the original.

The key to problem can be found in a Blu-ray extra on the genesis of the new film's alien robot. Derrickson's designers worked seemingly forever on elaborate, wholly unimpressive new designs, only to give up and acknowledge the superiority of the original's featureless metal man. At a loss for new ideas, this Day the Earth Stood Still flounders under the vague task of "doing it again, only newer and better."

The new galactic emissary Klaatu is played by star Keanu Reeves, who was reportedly the producer's preferred choice. The casting announcement was received with groans and jeers, indicating a further disconnect between the filmmakers and the public. Reeves' inexpressive acting style only makes this new Klaatu seem more of a non-character, The Dull Man Who Fell To Earth. Reeves' flat line readings repeatedly give away what should be the film's surprises:

Klaatu: "If the Earth dies, you die. If the human race dies, the Earth survives."

This Klaatu's mission is rather confused. Abandoning his initial effort to address the United Nations, the man from space appears to conclude that all humans are all like his government captors. He consults with his predecessor, an alien sleeper agent (James Hong) who reports that humanity has good qualities. Ignoring that assessment, Klaatu puts into motion a genocidal Plan 9.5 From Outer Space. Klaatu acts superior, but he's really just a hanging judge who denies us puny Earthlings our day in court.

As could be predicted, the emphasis in the new Day the Earth Stood Still is on more and fancier special effects. With the idea that dramatic scenes of impending disaster and alien combat are the solution to every Sci-Fi problem, Day makes certain that fantastic visuals are on hand at all times. Clouds boil and the mist parts as gigantic spherical spaceships land all over the Earth. The largest touches down in Central Park, disgorging a new-model GORT robot (the name is now a Pentagon-speak acronym). GORT neutralizes our weapons and shoots out the expected energy rays from a slit in his featureless face. He later proves to be made of zillions of tiny nanobots, chromium insects that, like a plague of locusts, consume anything man-made and people themselves. That concept is fairly fresh, but neither the clouds of nano-devourers nor the robot himself are all that frightening. Robert Wise's original robot expressed perfectly the doomsday fear of its time. The new GORT lacks this poetic menace almost entirely.

Not helping is the fact that the new Day never clicks on the human level. Now a respected astro-biologist, heroine Helen Benson (Jennifer Connelly, who seems to get more lovely as she ages) is spirited off to help the government prepare for a disaster that turns out to be the arrival of an alien space ship. Helen bravely extends the first hand of friendship to Klaatu, but we become uncomfortable when she switches loyalties to shield the space man from his government captors. She's soon playing Soccer Mom, driving the uncommunicative Klaatu on his highly suspicious mission. During what becomes an extended chase, the spaceman gets his only glimpse of normal human life at a local McDonald's. We almost expect Keanu to narrow his eyes and remark: "Hmm. Gratuitous product placement. This planet must be destroyed."

The last straw is Helen's adopted son Jacob (Jaden Smith), an annoying jerk with a lousy attitude; we can't believe that the movie is forcing us to spend time with him. The new professor Barnhardt is given one brief scene to plead unconvincingly for the survival of mankind. Barhnhardt is played with sincerity by ex-Python John Cleese, who misses the chance to show Klaatu that eliminating humanity is a bad idea because we're all so lovably funny. Without people we really care about, the essentially humorless movie makes a poor case for saving the human race -- Tim Burton's enjoyably silly Mars Attacks! has more likeable characters.

Most of the other humans on view are uptight secret service agents and robotic special forces too easily typed as Bad Guys. Security troops shoot down Klaatu before he can utter a word. C.I.A. experts interrogate him as if he were a helpless Guantanamo suspect. Secretary of Defense Regina Jackson (Kathy Bates) invites audience scorn for refusing to allow Klaatu to take his case to the U.N.. Another security operative who panics under pressure wears a highly visible flag pin, in what seems a rather knee-jerk condemnation of the U.S. Government.

(Major Spoiler) The Day the Earth Stood Still's aggressive ecological agenda is not very well thought out. Klaatu alters his mission at the eleventh hour, stopping the nanobot plague that threatens to eradicate the human race. He instead apparently takes away mankind's ecologically destructive energy sources, including electricity. The original Klaatu proved his powers by making the Earth "stand still" for all of thirty minutes, but this gag appears to be permanent. The movie ends before anybody has time to contemplate the coming Age of Primitivism. It looks like we'll have to do without microwave ovens and video games.

However, it soon becomes clear that Klaatu isn't doing us much of a favor. If he has the miraculous power to neutralize electricity and make oil useless for burning, why can't he just fix our environmental problems, arm the whales and make us ride bicycles? Without mass agriculture, transportation or communication, Klaatu's solution will starve most of the world's population to death and turn civilization back a thousand years. Klaatu is just a bully from outer space. Why doesn't he just bring us the gift of an eco-friendly energy source, like an intergalactic Prometheus?  2

The Day the Earth Stood Still ends up being just another threat from space, dressed up as a stern ecological sermon. Klaatu's interplanetary gangsters try to expunge us for not living up to their (debatable) higher standards. If they really respected other life forms they'd show some charity toward their unenlightened neighbors in space. Hey, Mr. Spaceman, things are tough down here too. Instead of reaching out her hand to greet Klaatu, Helen Benson should have held up a sign: "Brother, can you spare a dime -- and the Secrets of the Universe?"  1

Fox Home Entertainment's 3-Disc Special Edition Blu-ray of The Day the Earth Stood Still looks fine in HD, allowing us to admire the fantastic spectacle of giant buildings and other man-made structures being "erased" by swirling plague clouds. But the key imagery lacks the impact of the original simply because there are no standout designs -- the alien spaceships are just boiling gaseous globes. Much of the original's mood and menace derived from Bernard Herrmann's eerie music score, and the remake has no equivalent.

Fox's generous extras begin with a commentary by the screenwriter David Scarpa. A couple of deleted scene clips lead off a selection of featurettes that address the screenplay adaptation, the reworking of the Gort concept, the life-on-other-planets issue and the environmental angle. Galleries display stills, publicity & production art and storyboards. One Picture-in-Picture track examines props and artifacts made for Klaatu that weren't used in the film, and a second is an amusing Build Your Own Gort "interactive experience". The disc is also tricked out for D-Box motion control systems, for viewers with specially rigged theater seats!

Disc two is a digital copy of Day compatible with PCs, Macs and iPods. The third disc makes the Special Edition even more attractive: it's a Blu-ray of the original 1951 The Day the Earth Stood Still that came out last Christmas.

On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor,
The Day the Earth Stood Still Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Good - / Fair +
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: April 7, 2009

Republished by arrangement with Film.com


1. Amusingly, this new Klaatu has quite a bit in common with the hero of the nearly homemade 1959 Sci-Fi turnip Teenagers from Outer Space. The title alien comes to Earth to feed his giant lobster monsters on a diet of human beings, but relents when he meets a cute Hollywood co-ed and learns that people who need people are the luckiest people in the world. We're also reminded of The Cosmic Man, one of several pictures that imitate Day the Earth Stood Still. In that film, alien John Carradine's spaceship is a modest sphere, that causes the U.S. Army (one general, two jeeps) great concern.

2. (Definite SPOILER) I don't mean to be morbid, but Klaatu's original solution for our ecological irresponsibility has an appeal to the imagination. With Man gone Earth would indeed be a more beautiful place. If the Things of Man and men themselves were to be selectively scourged from the face of the earth, it surely wouldn't take forever for the planet to recover, particularly if Klaatu's nanobots consumed all of our untidy fissionable material already presenting a storage problem. I thought Klaatu's globes might kidnap not just the representative fauna, but a few thousand people as well, and maybe hold them in suspended animation for a few centuries, to be returned when the earth had "healed". One just hopes that by that time the planet isn't being run by Monsieur Boulle's sentient monkeys.

DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2009 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are often updated and annotated with reader input and graphics. Also, don't forget the 2009 Savant Wish List. T'was Ever Thus.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)