DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
HD DVD/Blu-ray
International DVDs
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



The Way We Were
Twilight Time
Savant Blu-ray Review

The Way We Were
Twilight Time
1973 / Color / 2:35 widescreen / 118 min. / Street Date November 12, 2013 / available through Screen Archives Entertainment / 29.95
Starring Barbra Streisand, Robert Redford, Lois Chiles, Patrick O'Neal, Bradford Dillman, Viveca Lindfors, Murray Hamilton, Sally Kirkland, Connie Forslund, James Woods, Susan Blakeley .
Harry Stradling Jr.
Film Editor John F. Burnett
Original Music Marvin Hamlisch
Title Song Marvin Hamlisch, Marilyn and Alan Bergman
Written by Arthur Laurents
Produced by Ray Stark
Directed by Sydney Pollack

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

The Way We Were remains one of Barbra Streisand's most popular pictures. It wants to be many things but best succeeds as a high-end vehicle for its leading lady, the talented powerhouse who conquered most every career challenge available in show business. This was Barbra's penultimate commitment to producer Ray Stark, so it was difficult to find a script that was both commercial enough for him and challenging enough for her. The original screenplay by Arthur Laurents has autobiographical aspects, and embraces a "daring" theme dear to the New Liberals of the '70s Hollywood establishment: the hot-button topic of the Hollywood Blacklist. Woody Allen's The Front (coming next February from Twilight Time) may have been the next blacklist-themed major release, and that was several years later. After six years in movies and wielding impressive clout, Streisand made most of the major personnel decisions on the picture, not just the choice of cameraman, Harry Stradling Jr.. Streisand wanted Sydney Pollack, and through him enlisted as her co-star the ideal male heartthrob of the moment, Robert Redford. The creative infighting between Pollack, Redford and Streisand turned the making of The Way We Were into a high-powered Hollywood battleground.

Arthur Laurents' screen story was almost abandoned in re-writes, yet mostly reinstated before filming began. Eastern college girl Katie (Streisand) is a Red-sympathizing college activist who becomes infaturated with a white-bread Adonis, aspiring writer Hubbell (Redford). He barely notices her. Years later during the war Katie is an energetic contributor to the war effort and FDR's social programs. She finds Hubbell in a white Naval uniform drinking in a bar, and takes him to bed. Katie encourages Hubbell to live up to his potential. They eventually marry and move to Hollywood, where Hubbell's influential friends find him studio screenwriting work. Katie has dropped her political activities, but when the Cold War witch hunts begin she feels the need to take a stand. Hubbell doesn't see what's to be gained by getting involved. He strays and Katie gets pregnant. Katie decides that their relationship is doomed by politics and just plain fate.

The Way We Were was sold in glamorous 1940 fashion, as a stellar collision of the romantic personalities Streisand and Redford. Like almost all Barbra Streisand movies, the focus never leaves the star. One of Redford's complaints was that the Hubble character is functionally passive, a supporting part. As is nicely pointed out in the disc's commentary, Redford is the glamorous sex object, while the film belongs firmly to Streisand. Career-wise the movie is indeed a Streisand triumph, in that Redford is no Omar Sharif or Ryan O'Neal, but a equally bankable top-rank star. And like those other actors, he's playing George Brent to Streisand's Bette Davis. The Way We Were tells its story from the woman's POV, or better, the Streisand POV. Katie initiates most everything that happens -- meeting, having sex, taking a stand and breaking up. Even as an insecure student humiliated because her writing isn't praised, Katie is clearly a woman of great courage and commitment. Arthur Laurents certainly knew how to write to Streisand's strengths -- as well as her requirements.

The glamour is certainly there; viewers still swoon over the image of Streisand brushing Redford's golden hair off his forehead. He's the beauty object and she's the Woman For All Seasons. In 1973 most viewers hadn't yet encountered a scene in which a woman makes love to a near-unconscious, inebriated man -- it's funny because it's very likely a common experience for many women. Just the same, in its middle section the movie begins to fragment somewhat, with the story getting lost amid montages of sailboats and fireside lovemaking. Sometimes we forget if the war is over or what exact year it is. The 1950s sneak up on us unawares.

The filmmakers get an A+ for conjuring up an old-fashioned romantic tearjerker packed with noble suffering and bittersweet sacrifices. Aided by the engaging title song, they even pull off a romantic coup with what should be a humiliating final scene. Perennial smoothie Hubbell has taken the easy path ever since college, and shows no sign of having worked up a sweat from breaking with Katie. Several years later they meet on the street, and we're supposed to think it a defining moment in the travails of the human heart -- secretly, he still loves her! I'm afraid I still see Hubbell as a writing hack who has taken special care to avoid excess drama in his life. He dishes out an ingratiating smile (which has apparently been his Golden Ticket throughout) and gives Katie a gentle brush-off. That The Way We Were turns this into a meaningful scene for Katie is remarkable.

The finished film jettisoned the later developments of its own political theme, dropping several key story scenes. What the producer and director surely wanted was to turn the Redford-Streisand matchup into a monster box office success, laugh all the way to the bank and emerge as even more bankable talents. The documentary included on the disc, "Looking Back" details the several cut scenes that would have made the blacklist issue a much stronger theme. In the never-finished uncut version the Katie-Hubbell split isn't over romantic issues: she's been betrayed to the HUAC by an earlier associate in activism, played by James Woods. In the cut scenes, Katie loves Hubbell so much that she initiates the breakup to protect his career from her political past: she's a martyr. The final edit doesn't allow her to make that decision. Instead, Hubbell leaves Katie because their relationship is too strained and she isn't really chic enough for his set. This makes him look like a class-A louse.

Make that a blond, blue-eyed and apparently irresistible louse. Character threads that might block the spotlight on the two stars were trimmed way back. In the final cut the impressive supporting cast (Lois Chiles, Patrick O'Neal, Bradford Dillman, Viveca Lindfors, Murray Hamilton, Sally Kirkland, Susan Blakeley) make very limited impressions. What's left are broad strokes. Hubbell's affluent friends pretty much think Katie and her politics are a drag, while several of the women seem shallow and prejudiced. Ms. Streisand is a noted feminist, but the film's unsympathetic take on most of the female characters extends to the on-screen billing of actress Susanne Zenor -- as "Dumb Blonde."

The Way We Were has always been embraced as a superior entertainment. Is Barbra Streisand beyond the reach of mere film criticism? Her prodigious talent, massive industry clout and powerful personality liken her to one of those colossal astral bodies that raises tides and influences the orbits of everything in the galaxy. She has managed to create and maintain her top-roost and mystique through forty years of cultural shifts, an amazing feat. This star vehicle is essentially critic-proof: Barbra is there, she's giving a committed performance, and that's all that really matters to her legion of fans.

The Twilight Time Blu-ray of The Way We Were is a quality pressing of this Sony-Columbia tent-pole library classic. Harry Stradling's Panavision cinematography is actually fairly soft but always attractive -- 1973 was a big year for filters. The mission to fulfill the romantic fantasies of the multitudes is a big success.

The audio has been remixed to 5.1 DTC-HD MA, and English subtitles are a welcome option. An audio commentary by the late Sydney Pollack is present. Sadly, we also lost composer Marvin Hamlisch just last year. His music score is presented on a discrete Isolated Score Track. An original trailer is here, in great shape, along with the insightful, comprehensive long-form documentary Looking Back produced by Michael Arick. It contains key input from, among others, Arthur Laurents.

Twilight Time principals Nick Redman and Julie Kirgo are both qualified film writers. They offer a second full-length commentary, giving equal attention to the film's glamorous stars and its political context. Ms. Kirgo's liner notes lay out the story of Arthur Laurents and the rough road of the making of The Way We Were in just four concise pages. Sydney Pollack is quoted on the decision to drop a number of scenes, especially the key blacklist material. Deleting the thorny payoff to the political story, Pollack decided, would give the movie a clear shot at monster success. Historically speaking, this is something of a switch. It's usually been cowardly or crass producers and studios that stripped political content from directors' movies.

On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, The Way We Were Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Good as a powerhouse '70s romantic star vehicle
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Commentary with director Sydney Pollack, commentary with Twilight Time producers, Isolated Music Score, older documentary Looking Back, trailer.
Deaf and Hearing Impaired Friendly? YES; Subtitles: English
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: November 14, 2013

DVD Savant Text © Copyright 2013 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are often updated and annotated with reader input and graphics.
Also, don't forget the 2011 Savant Wish List.
T'was Ever Thus.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)