DVD Talk
Reviews & Columns
HD DVD/Blu-ray
International DVDs
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
HD Talk
Horror DVDs
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info



Violent Saturday
Twilight Time
Savant Blu-ray Review

Violent Saturday
Twilight Time
1955 / Color / 2:55 widescreen / 90 min. / Street Date July 8, 2014 / available through Screen Archives Entertainment / 29.95
Starring Victor Mature, Richard Egan, Stephen McNally, Virginia Leith, Tommy Noonan, Lee Marvin, Margaret Hayes, J. Carrol Naish, Sylvia Sidney, Ernest Borgnine, Dorothy Patrick, Billy Chapin, Brad Dexter.
Charles G. Clarke
Original Music Hugo Freidhofer
Written by Sydney Boehm from the novel by William L. Heath
Produced by Buddy Adler
Directed by Richard Fleischer

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

Twilight Time has kept a pact with its customer base by doubling back on one of its earliest DVD releases. When it comes to movies, Double-Dipping is something I always associate with films I really don't need to see again. This particular crime thriller is good enough, and the new encoding is so much of an improvement, that seeing it in Blu-ray is like seeing it for the first time.

An influential film book from back in 1971 was art critic Lawrence Alloway's Violent America: The Movies 1946-1964, based on a film screening series that took place at the Museum of Modern Art. Alloway discussed the thrillers of this period as exemplars of a concept called Covert Culture: "There seems to be a greater interest in violence in the mass audience than is tolerable to the elite critics of society." That translates as saying that critics looking for spiritual enlightenment were baffled by the violent fantasies down at the Bijou. The New York Times' Bosley Crowther took this picture as an insult directed at him personally. And all because a sadistic hood grinds a little kid's hand into the sidewalk.

An excellent example of a popular film undermining America's artistic values is Fox's CinemaScope release from 1955, Violent Saturday. Although now promoted as a film noir -- apparently every movie with someone in street clothes carrying a gun now qualifies -- Violent Saturday is a dramatic hybrid. John Sturges' Bad Day at Black Rock from the same year is a socially conscious exposé of a racial hate crime -- but with a little ju-jitsu and gunplay to keep the rubes in their seats. Violent Saturday grafts a brutal caper story onto the basic Grand Hotel converging plotlines template: substitute a volcano or an earthquake for the bank robbery, and we'd have a generic Disaster Movie. Producer Buddy Adler spun a number of golden hits for Fox at this time, spread across several genres. For Violent Saturday he gathered key noir talent in the persons of scriptwriter Sydney Boehm (The Big Heat) and director Richard Fleischer (The Narrow Margin). The movie is certainly violent enough not to betray its own title. But its thematic agenda falls more in the 'threat to the family' subgenre that in the 1950s seemed always to reinforce conformist social ideas.

The desert mining town of Bradenville could easily be renamed "Peyton Place Gulch". Alcoholic mine owner Boyd Fairchild (Richard Egan) is so distraught that his wife Emily (Margaret Hayes) is running around with golf Romeo Gil Clayton (Brad Dexter) that he picks up local nurse Linda Sherman (Virginia Leith). Linda in turn is the voyeuristic object of desire for Harry Reeves (Tommy Noonan), the manager of the local bank. Librarian Elsie Braden (Sylvia Sydney) catches Harry in the act, but they share guilty secrets when he learns that she's turned to thievery to pay her mortgage. And happily married mine foreman Shelley Martin (Victor Mature) discovers why his ten year-old son Steve (Billy Chapin) is so ashamed of him: Shelley stayed on the job during the war while a neighbor kid's father was earning medals on Iwo Jima.

Breezing into town come thieves Harper, Chapman and Dill (Stephen McNally, J. Carrol Naish and Lee Marvin). Their plan to rob Harry's bank at closing time on Saturday makes use of a local farm run by the Amish Stadt (Ernest Borgnine). The crooks are counting on the religious family to offer no resistance -- they're averse to violence in any form.

Violent Saturday is sharp, efficient and thoroughly modern for 1955, thanks to Richard Fleischer's assured direction. Some critics claimed that Fleischer was an example of a good director stifled by the requirements of CinemaScope. We see little compromise at work, as Fleisher composes in depth and uses the wide screen as well as cutting to introduce new visual elements. It is true that the early 'scope lenses just didn't deal well with confined spaces, which means that even cramped settings like the local diner look unusually spacious. But Fleischer breaks entirely with early C'Scope's static wide coverage of scenes.

While the crooks case the town the film presents an interesting vision of a new Wild West. The glory of American industry is an enormous open-pit copper mine. Giant dump trucks seem to be "erasing" the landscape and shipping if off in train cars. Shelley Martin's handsome house has a 180° view of nothing but destroyed scenery. In this landscape it only makes sense that the good citizens of Bradenville should be a collection of selfish, rapacious desires. Emily Fairchild strays out of boredom, but she also seems to be rebelling against something. Linda Sherman looks demure and innocent but would be perfectly happy to see Boyd leave his wife. Linda doesn't even seem to mind Harry's Peeping Tomfoolery all that much. Most telling is young Steve Martin (!) who smashes things around the house and gets into fights with his best friend, all because his dad wasn't a killer in the Big War. A boy needs a role model, right? Stevie is yet another screwed up '50s kid reacting to an anxiety-filled period of peace and prosperity, like little Tommy Forbes in Andre de Toth's Pitfall and David MacLean in William Cameron Menzies' Invaders from Mars.

The fun in Violent Saturday is anticipating the town's eruption into chaos. The filmmakers stage all manner of aggressive behavior, with the pill-popping Dill operating on a hair trigger and the cool cucumber Chapman acting with quiet menace. After playing seemingly dozens of low-life creeps in pre-Code crime pictures, oldster J. Carroll Naish is an excellent choice as a bespectacled crook. New blood Lee Marvin adds a 'method' gimmick with a nasal inhaler to his collection of tics. Both men direct their hostility at children playing on the street and talking back during the robbery. Under the '50s code of Proper Family Conduct, these hoods are begging to receive a vigilante backlash. Top critic Bosley Crowther predictably called the film "dismal" and "sadistic", adding that it "appears to have no other purpose than to titillate and thrill on the level of melodrama and guarded pornography." Crowther's inflexible attitude lasted twelve more years, until his reviewing career ended with a dissenting opinion of 1967's Bonnie & Clyde.

The final showdown at Amish Acres shapes up as the philosophical opposite of Jessamyn West's Friendly Persuasion: Ernest Borgnine's principled paterfamilias offers the desperate Shelley Martin no aid, forcing our hero to resist the murderous bandits on his own. The Amish have silently obeyed the bandits' orders, a choice that leaves a row of little Amish children bound and gagged, as helpless as victims of the Nazis. Will Papa Pacifist find it necessary to abandon his righteous code and take up a weapon? Violent Saturday confects a situation to force the plowshare-sword issue in a hawkish direction.  1

Violent Saturday knows that it's finished when the bloody battle is resolved; we get a moment to mourn a victim of the shooting but don't find out what really becomes of the poor, bitter librarian played by Sylvia Sydney. A still exists of Sydney from what might be a deleted scene. She's talking to a man who could be a problem husband, and the reason why she is short of funds. Just twenty years before the actress had been the personification of social injustice in American films like You Only Live Once, and as late as 1996 the indomitable actress was still appearing in Tim Burton films. Now that's real staying power. Violent Saturday concludes on what ought to be a disturbing note: little Stevie Martin learns that he was right all along: a man who kills is a real man. Peaceful 1955 America is still a warring nation.

Standout Virginia Leith made a number of interesting films but never caught the brass ring. She's unfortunately best known for her knockout performance (really) as a telepathic disembodied head in The Brain That Wouldn't Die. A beautiful '50s starlet-actress sufficiently hip to elevate a Z-grade monster movie? Ms. Leith sounds like a dream come true.

Twilight Time's Blu-ray of Violent Saturday fulfills an unspoken promise by the breakout company that began releasing DVDs, then Blu-rays, back in 2011. Whether by mistake or design, TT was forced to present Violent Saturday in an undesirable flat-letterboxed format that didn't sit well with fans, even ones like DVD Savant eager to see the show in a CinemaScope screen shape. The new Blu-ray is stunning. Not only is it sharp, bright and colorful, it brings back the feeling of original Color by Deluxe films from the 1950s, that had excellent contrast and beautiful hues. Charles G. Clarke's cinematography does its best to be 'dark' in the interiors, giving Violent Saturday an atypical noir look despite the bright color. Most of the medium shots of actors are beautifully lit, modeling their faces with a least a hint of shadow. As with early CinemaScope, when actors lean too close in to the lens, all bets are off. Richard Egan and Virginia Leith's faces bloat out once or twice in a serious case of the CinemaScope mumps. As Virginia leans back, her facial proportions are restored!

The exteriors give us a very pleasing feeling of "terrain" -- we feel a part of the little mining town nestled in a dry gorge. Director Fleischer efficiently sets the scene, at one point using a POV from inside the moving car that reminds us of the famous shot in Gun Crazy. Real desert towns, even busy ones, rarely look as clean and hospitable as this. With the slightest breeze the whole place would be an unpleasant dust trap. And the heat motivates people to get all their errands done early in the morning. Just live in places like Henderson, Kingman and Lake Havasu City for a day, and you'll know what I mean.

Hugo Friedhofer's music appears on an Isolated Score Track. Twilight Time's Nick Redman and Julie Kirgo tag-team the full feature commentary. Kirgo's insert pamphlet essay identifies the filming location as Bisbee, Arizona. Gee, if we take the name of the town as Bisbee and not "Bradenville", then Violent Saturday connects right up to the movie version of L.A. Confidential. Kim Basinger's character Lynn Bracken in Confidential exits with her battered cop boyfriend to go back and live in Bisbee, where "the girls need glamour too." So maybe Lynn Bracken was there at the big bank robbery as well.

On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, Violent Saturday Blu-ray rates:
Movie: Good ++
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: isolated music score
Deaf and Hearing Impaired Friendly? NO; Subtitles: none.
Packaging: Keep case
Reviewed: July 16, 2014


1. The film's view of the Amish farmer's "irrational" pacifism distorts the issue to make a pro-war statement. All good Christians are against violence, yes, and the Quakers and Amish are vocal about their right to not fight -- in WARS. Threaten an Amish farmer's children, or for that matter look sideways at his daughter, and you'll likely discover that he's the Fastest Pitchfork in the West.

Violent Saturday preaches the false 1950s equation: Prosperity = Fighting for Freedom. The underlying message is that the robbers represent the ever-present menace against which we must be forever vigilant: "Hey you slacker ingrate, the only reason you can enjoy that ice cream cone in peace is because thousands of real Americans died to keep you free!"

Text © Copyright 2014 Glenn Erickson

See more exclusive reviews on the Savant Main Page.
Reviews on the Savant main site have additional credits information and are often updated and annotated with reader input and graphics.
T'was Ever Thus.

Return to Top of Page

Advertise With Us

Review Staff | About DVD Talk | Newsletter Subscribe | Join DVD Talk Forum
Copyright © MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. | Privacy Policy

Subscribe to DVDTalk's Newsletters

Email Address

DVD Talk Newsletter (Sample)
DVD Savant Newsletter (Sample)