Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info


Law, The

Oscilloscope Laboratories // Unrated // September 28, 2010
List Price: $34.99 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Jamie S. Rich | posted September 27, 2010 | E-mail the Author


Jules Dassin's 1959 French-Italian co-production The Law (La Loi) is a flirty and fun tornado of small-town scandal. Set in the coastal village of Porto Manacore, looking out over the Adriatic Sea, the ex-pat director's adaptation of a Roger Vailland novel was apparently too hot for the censors upon its release, relegating it to obscurity amongst the filmmaker's resume. After spending two hours spinning in The Law's dizzying narrative, I can't understand how a revival took so long to come around.

The Law is indeed a story of how social structures are governed, showing us how life in the town is dictated by two men--the Godfather-like Don Cesare (Pierre Brasseur), who has all the political and financial power, and the gangster Matteo Brigante (Yves Montand, Z), the muscle on the streets. "The Law" is also a drinking game that was popular in Southern Italy, and its strange rules mimic the way everything else is run. One man is named the boss, and he appoints his deputy, and together they control the wine. They pour the drinks, choosing who gets a glass via posturing and humiliation, until the pitcher is empty. Then a new boss is chosen, and a new deputy. You keep going until the players can't stand it anymore.

Such is life. You keep going until you can't stand it anymore. The heroine of The Law is Marietta (legendary Italian beauty Gina Lollobrigida). Marietta and her mother and two sisters live with Don Cesare, and are essentially his harem. He currently sleeps with her older sister, but Marietta is next to be called into his bed when he grows bored with her sibling--just as it was with their mother and her eldest daughter before them. Marietta's brother-in-law, the Don's right-hand man Tonio (Paolo Stoppa), also lusts after Marietta, and Brigante is determined to make her his own. She has other ideas, however, and when a new fellow comes to town, Marietta sets her sights on him.

Enrico (Marcello Mastroianni, 8 1/2) is an agronomist sent to Porto Manacore to modernize it. He represents progress, and so naturally butts heads with Don Cesare. When you own all the land, you don't want to be told what to do with it, after all. Enrico is overwhelmed by the convoluted social structure, and when he tries to play "The Law," it's not to his liking. On the other hand, Marietta very much is to his liking, even if he can't figure out how to make it work. She's a practical gal and ready to marry the outsider, she just needs to find a dowry. When she sees a Swiss tourist with a fat wallet, she lifts it. Half-a-million lire should be enough for any wedding. By no coincidence, she also gets a neighborhood boy--part of a gang of thieves and pranksters that do her bidding--to steal Brigante's knife. It's his only weapon, and the sharp blade scares everyone else. You don't have to have Freud on retainer to get the symbolism of Marietta taking it from him.

If all of this sounds particularly tangled, well, hold up, I'm just getting started. The Law is packed front to back with subplots and narrative complications. For instance, Brigante's son Francesco (Raf Mattioli) is having an affair with the wife of the town judge (Teddy Bilis). The woman, Lucrezia (Melina Mercouri, Dassin's real-life spouse and star of his films Never on Sunday and Topkapi), enlists another lady, Giuseppina (Lidia Alfonsi), to help her pass notes to Francesco. Giuseppina knows what Lucrezia is going through, as she's the mistress of the chief of police (Vittorio Caprioli). Also, Lucrezia bribes her by buying her a dress that is supposed to lift her breasts so she appears to have a bust like Marilyn Monroe's. When we first meet Giuseppina, it's while the cop is telling his buxom wife that he dreamt that her flat-chested friend had a bosom herself--which should tell you something about how sexed-up The Law is. Gina Lollobrigida's cleavage is an element of real focus amongst her neighbors, and I'm starting to understand why my dad thought it was such a big deal when she guest-starred on Falcon Crest when I was 12 years old. Va-va-voom!

Jules Dassin's script for The Law is an extremely agile piece of writing. He never gets overburdened by all this story, nor does he ever shy away from the heat. Visually, he and cinematographer Otello Martelli (La strada) make use of the tall buildings and winding streets of Porto Manacore to give the audience the feeling of traveling through a maze. Built on a hillside, the village has lots of stairs and many levels, and it's easy to get lost. Try to map out which way Marietta is going as you watch The Law and see if you can keep up. The way the town is built, and how it's put to use on film, is another representation of its class structure. One of the earliest scenes is an impressive tracking shot that takes us up to the top of the police building, peering into the apartments where the judge and the chief live, moving down the side of the building and across, past the jail cells. The camera is being dragged along by Marietta's siren song, and we find her across town, shining boots on a balcony and singing to the morning sky. The men of the movie are bewitched, and so are we.

The Law is a real narrative tour-de-force, full of rich characters and surprising script developments. The actors all attack their roles with relish, and Dassin was at the height of his powers when constructing his mis-en-scene. The Law is as fresh and bold as any modern bendy, curvy crime movie, while also not being a crime movie at all. What a fantastic discovery!


The two-disc Oscillosocope release of The Law is extraordinary. The full-frame black-and-white image is damn near perfect. The resolution is sharp, and there is no extraneous noise, scratches, or dirt. The tonal values of the picture are splendid, with strong shadows and also excellent brightness. This is a top-notch restoration job.

The original French audio track is mixed in mono. Though the movie included a cast that had actors from both countries, the Italian speakers--including Mastroianni--were dubbed into French. It was actually pretty common at the time for international casts to be unified in post. The soundtrack here is as well preserved as the image. The sounds are crisp, there is no hiss or other damage. The subtitles are written well and nicely paced, though maybe a tad bit small.

This double-disc set comes in the usual smart package from Oscilloscope--a two piece paper case, with an outer slipcover and an inner folder with slots for the DVDs. The interior case has a new essay by Haden Guest, director of the Harvard Film Archive, and the text of a 1958 interview with Dassin.

DVD 1 has the movie as well as a full-length audio commentary by critic David Fear. This alternate track is fairly comprehensive, and Fear offers a strong analysis of the movie. His speaking style was sometimes a little off-the-cuff for my tastes, but obviously that's a personal preference and not really a knock at the quality of the information.

DVD 2 has lots of supplemental features about The Law, including the original theatrical trailer and an alternate ending. Titled "Marietta's Revenge" (5 minutes, 23 seconds), it's pretty much self-explanatory from the title. It's actually almost exactly the same except for a very short insertion.

An excerpt from a 1958 episode of Cinepanorama (13:24) features interviews with Dassin, Lollobrigida, Montand, and Mercouri, as well as documentary footage of life in the town where the movie was shot. Montand also acts in a staged scene explaining the game "The Law." The game is discussed further in the 1957 French television interview with author Roger Vailland (12:38), particularly in relation to the meaning of his book.

Finally, L'ultima osteria (40:45) is a recent documentary from Alfredo De Giuseppe that gets to know a group of players who continue the tradition of the game. It takes a while to get some real playing. I'd have liked to see more of the game--I still don't really get it--rather than hear about these random lives. It's kind of boring waiting to get to the footage at the card table.

Highly Recommended. The Law truly deserves the description "lost classic." Jules Dassin's 1958 story of sex, crime, and social mores is a wonderfully salacious and fascinating piece of work. The twisting and turning story of the romantic entanglements of a seaside Italian village is a narrative delight, and Dassin is so light on his feet in terms of storytelling, it's easy to forget just how much is actually going on. The handsome two-disc package is a real winner for Oscilloscope, and I am sure it's going to get a lot of mileage in my DVD player.

Jamie S. Rich is a novelist and comic book writer. He is best known for his collaborations with Joelle Jones, including the hardboiled crime comic book You Have Killed Me, the challenging romance 12 Reasons Why I Love Her, and the 2007 prose novel Have You Seen the Horizon Lately?, for which Jones did the cover. All three were published by Oni Press. His most recent projects include the futuristic romance A Boy and a Girl with Natalie Nourigat; Archer Coe and the Thousand Natural Shocks, a loopy crime tale drawn by Dan Christensen; and the horror miniseries Madame Frankenstein, a collaboration with Megan Levens. Follow Rich's blog at

Buy from






Highly Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links