Reviews & Columns
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio
Video Games

Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info


Secret of the Urn, The

AnimEigo // Unrated // April 12, 2011
List Price: $24.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Thomas Spurlin | posted April 28, 2011 | E-mail the Author
The Film:

Hideo Gosha's early film The Secret of the Urn proves that a storied, eye-grabbing antihero can't always power an entry in samurai cinema on his own, even if he comes rather close to doing do. With a scarred face and a nasty snarl, let alone one of his arms missing, watching Japanese legend Kinnosuke Nakamura cut through enemies in Gosha's distinctive no-frills sword duels can be an exhilarating experience, easily the central draw to this bald-faced escapade. Though instead of the thoughtful ruminations that populate the director's yakuza pictures Onimasa and The Wolves, or his daring flare with Sword of the Beast, Gosha settles into a ho-hum script here with trivial periphery characters and a forced back-story, crafting an amusingly rowdy but ultimately one-dimensional yarn around a well-explored hero.

The Secret of the Urn first introduces Samanosuke (Kinnosuke) as a loyal samurai to the Yagyu clan, who surprisingly finds himself on the wrong end of the blade during an assassination assignment, leaving him disfigured by way of a missing arm and eye. Cut to a year later, where the Yagyu fief have the opportunity to raise their prestige by being selected to provide a hefty sum of money to the Shogunate, something that doesn't sit well with a rival family. A search sparks to locate a legendary urn - the "Earless Monkey Urn" -- that supposedly leads to roughly a million ryo, which both sides obviously want to get their hands on. While in the fray of battle, the urn falls in the hands of the one-eyed, one-armed, scowl-faced Tange Sazen, along with a pair of thieves that catch wind of the urn's worth. The unsavory union between them falls into place, until Sazen's childhood friend Hagino surfaces.

The character of Tange Sazen appeared in several films and books throughout the '20s before Hideo Gosha directed The Secret of the Urn, which serves as a new origin story for the character. With an eccentric tone and one arm tucked in his garments, Kinnosuke Nakamura discovers an exaggerated petulance that fits, even if his brash overstatement bloats bigger than some scenes can handle. His relationship with his female companion, Ofuji (Keiko Awaji), approaches that of the doomed anti-romantic connection between a roguish man and an unsavory woman, and it hits melodramatic weeps and bickering that rings fairly hollow through bluntly-scripted dialogue. Gosha and his recurring writer Kei Tasaka take potentially intriguing characters and, ultimately, create a vigorous but dry fable of double-dealing and antiheroic jadedness, one obviously more concerned with catering to an icon of Japanese culture.

While only scratching the surface with character depth, The Secret of the Urn makes up for it in the sparse to-the-point battles Gosha orchestrates. Obviously, one of the big draws to a story of Tange Sazen comes in the one-armed fighting style that the ronin exploits, and it's handled with an animated flare that fits Kinnosuke almost like a glove. Photographed by Sadatsugu Yoshida, who would later shoot The Yakuza Papers with Kinji Fukasaku, the cinematography carries as much flowing energy as the picture's spirited pacing during heavier blade duels, gaining intensity and a burst of color when approaching the film's robust climax at the Shogunate tea party. With Gosha's direction and seamless eye, the fierce battles rarely cut away from healthy doses of blood-spilling, finding an energetic body-count and a fury of crowd-pleaser turns that throttle the pace all the way to the rewarding finale.

The DVD:

Video and Audio:

Sourced from Toei in a clear and colorful print, AnimEigo's 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen image retains the '60s-era cinematography to largely satisfying results. Spilled blood retains a deep-red coloring and skin tones grasp at properly warm fleshy shades, while contrast typically stays solid and relatively inky when required. Some unavoidable shimmering and flatness of overall dimension hampers the image, offering consistent reminders that it's a digital representation, while a few instances of vertical stretching also pop up occasionally. Mostly, though, the palette retains fine lushness and appropriation, while a few minor details -- the fabric surrounding the urn, the sheen on a blade, and the grain in wood and screen doors -- pop out from the standard-definition image. It's far from perfect, but there's plenty of satisfaction to be garnered from the visual treatment.

The Japanese 2.0 Dolby Stereo track sounds fine enough, keeping vocals balanced and sound effects under control about as well as can be imagined. They still show off the familiar twang that suppresses other sound treatments from the time period, with a few clangs of the blade yells straining on higher-end points. Nearly no hiss can be heard, however, and the two-channel sound design offers a few impressive instances of atmospheric awareness -- sound of a hand slapping against a knee, the tearing of a screen door by way of a blade, and others. Where AnimEigo once again delivers its might is with the subtitle offerings, though they're not as "varied" as other releases: both Yellow and White English subtitle options can be selected, yet they automatically offer the "descriptive" subtext to certain locations and customs (normally optional). Also, instead of "Yellow" and "White", they should probably be labeled "Monochrome" and "Color", since text arrives in greens and reds in the yellow subtitles to annotate individuals speaking. As per their modus operandi, the text remains extremely clear and articulate throughout, proving AnimEigo's still one of the best foreign-distributing companies in that regard.

Special Features:

Like most of AnimEigo's other releases, The Secret of the Urn comes with several excellent text-based supplements -- Program Notes and Bios -- as well as an Image Gallery and a Theatrical Trailer (2:59, 16x9).

Final Thoughts:

The Secret of the Urn certainly doesn't succumb to subtlety, as Hideo Gosha retells the story of renegade ronin Tange Sazen in a vigorous and entertaining entry in the samurai genre. Though there's not much to grasp with the one-note characters and merely supportive story, the swordplay involving the single-armed, facially-scarred antihero remains gripping on more than a handful of occasions. With AnimEigo's consistently satisfying quality backing up the brisk-paced tale, this release comes with a strong Recommendation.

Thomas Spurlin, Staff Reviewer -- DVDTalk Reviews | Personal Blog/Site
Buy from







E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links