DVD Talk
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
HD DVD / Blu-ray
International DVDs
Theatrical
Video Games

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
DVD Talk Radio
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Stalk
DVD Savant
High-Def Revolution
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum
Resources
DVD Price Search
Customer Service #'s
RCE Info
Links

DVDTalk Info
Review Staff
About DVD Talk
Advertise
Newsletter Subscribe
Join DVD Talk Forum
DVD Talk Feeds


Sponsored Links
Search: For:
Reviews » Blu-ray Reviews » The New York Ripper (2019 4K Remaster) (Blu-ray)
The New York Ripper (2019 4K Remaster) (Blu-ray)
Blue Underground // Unrated // June 25, 2019 // Region Free
List Price: $49.95 [Buy now and save at Amazon]
Review by Adam Tyner | posted June 21, 2019 | E-mail the Author
Buy from Amazon.com
C O N T E N T
V I D E O
A U D I O
E X T R A S
R E P L A Y
A D V I C E
Highly Recommended
E - M A I L
this review to a friend
P R I N T
Printer Friendly
In 1972, Lucio Fulci implored you not to torture Donald Duck. Nearly a decade later, Donald Duck is hellbent on torturing you.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Jack the Ripper had infamously preyed on prostitutes in London a century earlier, and New York's Ripper shares that taste for women who trade their bodies. A model. A prostitute (Daniela Doria; City of the Living Dead). A performer in a stage sex show (Zora Kerova; Cannibal Ferox). A bored, privileged housewife drawn towards the sadomasochistic (Zombie Holocaust's Alexandra Delli Colli). The Ripper isn't content to kill. He mutilates these women...carves them apart. Investigators gradually piece clues together, from the bastard's missing fingers to his penchant for sqwawking like Donald Duck in the throes of his bloodlust. The Ripper is insane, yes, but deviously brilliant – always several steps ahead of the police, who are tortured by the knowledge that the only way to inch closer to his identity is to wait for him to kill again.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Even for seasoned gorehounds, The New York Ripper is so vicious and visceral as to be grueling to watch. So many slashers in these early years were content to settle for a single swipe of a machete or an arrow to the chest. By contrast, the murders here are prolonged agony; the Ripper revels in his depravity, ekeing the most of every excruciating moment. Several of his victims are slowly sliced down the middle. Another is dismembered; all we see of her is a severed hand, discovered by a dog playing fetch by the water. A nipple and eyeball are cleaved in two. Another is all but disembowled with a broken wine bottle. This madman doesn't earn the nickname of The Ripper merely because of his body count; it's because he is literally ripping these women apart.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

The argument goes that The New York Ripper is a misogynistic film – deeply judgmental of women and their sexuality. And, yes, nearly all of The Ripper's victims indulge their desires in ways outside of societally accepted norms – say, one making an audio recording of a sex show as she fingers herself in her seat. Sex and violence are so inexorably linked here that it was a struggle to find compelling screenshots for this review, as there are almost always bared breasts or pubic hair on display. Still, I wouldn't say that Fulci's film is misogynistic so much as it's misanthropic, given that The New York Ripper has nearly as little regard for its male characters. They're far more repulsive sexual beasts, whether it's a low-life toe-fucking a woman against her will in a dive bar, a supposedly proper gentleman fumbling for an excuse to cheat on his wife, or a police lieutenant who places the hooker he's shacking up with in danger to avoid revealing his secret shame. (Troy Howarth is more charitable in his commentary, describing the film's characters instead as lonely, frightened people desperately seeking some sort of connection. Your mileage may vary as well.)

I'm intrigued by the structure of the film. Rather than tread down the usual whodunnit? path, we're clearly shown halfway through who's preying on these women. The New York Ripper lacks a protagonist in the traditional sense. Those who return the most are either shuffled to the background too often to serve as a point-of-view character, meet a grisly end at The Ripper's blade, or have an importance that isn't apparent until late in the movie. Virtually everyone has in some way been corrupted, and though those few who are innocent manage to survive, they hardly escape unscathed. Its final moments are haunting, horrifying, and heartbreaking in a way that few other films have managed, and that's accomplished without a gleaming blade or a drop of blood. So, yes, there is indeed far more to The New York Ripper than splatter and sadism. The film cleverly upends everything you think you know. A bondage sequence in a sleazy motel is unnervingly suspenseful – being strapped to a bed while discovering what evil is sleeping next to you. That, honestly, is The New York Ripper's bravura sequence, not its bloodiest make-up effects or jaw-droppingly gruesome denouement.

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Grimy, sleazy, and demented, The New York Ripper is not an easy movie to watch. I can't rightly say that I enjoy it. And though it's far from my favorite of Fulci's work, this is a more substantial and layered film than it's often given credit for being. If nothing else, it's essential viewing for those curious to see Fulci viscerally unite the giallo with the American slasher. For those well-acquainted with the film, even if it was through Blue Underground's first stab at it on Blu-ray a decade ago, this three disc re-release proves to be well worth the upgrade. Highly Recommended.


Video
Newly remastered in 4K from the original camera negative, this reissue of The New York Ripper is worlds removed from the edition that Blue Underground released a decade ago. In lieu of film grain, the 2009 release was saddled with a sheen of analog video noise floating above the image. This noise lent the presentation a false sense of sharpness and suggested detail that wasn't actually present. There's also something frustratingly video-like about that thin, pale image. This new restoration of The New York Ripper, on the other hand, is an improvement in every conceivable respect:

20092019
[click on any of these thumbnails to enlarge]

Though some may argue that the revised grading is too modern, I'm thrilled with the rich, warm, vivacious colors on display here. I'm particularly floored by the way the neon lights pop against Times Square in the dead of night. Contrast is considerably more robust. The harsh video noise of a decade past makes way for a true filmic texture. This presentation is immaculate – not so much as a stray nick nor a fleck of dust stood out to my eyes – and this is accomplished without heavy-handed filtering. More of the image is exposed on all four sides of the frame, even with the marginally heavier matting here. (This latest remaster is presented at the more modern aspect ratio of 2.39:1, rather than the previous edition's 2.35:1.) Stepping up from 2009's BD-25 to a dual-layered disc, the reissue's bitrate is considerably higher as well, helping to ensure that there are no sputters or stutters in its AVC encode.

This remaster strikes an ideal balance, resisting the urge to polish away the grittiness inherent to The New York Ripper's visuals. It shouldn't dazzle in quite the same way as the 4K reissues of Fulci's Zombie and Manhattan Baby as it's a very different film with a very different approach. Still, what Blue Underground has delivered here is nothing short of extraordinary, and it's a compelling upgrade even for those of us who'd already bought their initial Blu-ray release a decade earlier.

The three disc set also includes an anamorphic widescreen DVD based on this same restoration.


Audio
The audio options are considerably more expansive on this reissue. Blue Underground's 2009 Blu-ray release was limited exclusively to English – 16-bit, eight-channel DTS-HD Master Audio and a lossy monaural track. Both English soundtracks now enjoy a higher bit-depth, and they're joined by dubs in Italian, Spanish, and French as well. The same as the two English tracks, the Italian dub is served up in 24-bit DTS-HD Master Audio, while the Spanish and French tracks are in Dolby Digital (224kbps).

[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

Given the film's setting and that its characters are all meant to be New Yorkers, I again opted for the lossless 7.1 English audio, and I went back afterwards and sampled a few sequences in Italian. This is, as before, a respectful remix, without a compulsion to relentlessly fill every speaker with sound. An argument could be made that it's perhaps too subdued. Francesco De Masi's score is unmistakably the focal point, and it sounds sensational: bass that's pronounced but never overcooked, strong separation across channels, a terrific sense of distinctness and clarity, and the primary source of most of the activity in the surrounds. Atmospherics occasionally make their presence known in the rears, whether it's the sound of the Staten Island Ferry crossing the bay, ambient bustle as Jane and her gigolo pull up to a fleabag motel, or police sirens outside the hospital.

Music aside, the surround channels rarely seem to draw attention to themselves, and there were several moments where I was surprised by just how dead silent they were. Take Lt. Williams being surrounded by clacking machines when tracing the Ripper's phone call, for instance, or a subway train bearing down on the camera and Fay's terrifying ride that follows. The rears aren't just low-key in these moments; if there's not music, there's nothing, full stop. I'm not a fan of hyperaggressive remixes from monaural sources anyway, so I'm certainly not complaining, especially when the elements are this clean, clear, and readily discerned.

From what I sampled of the lossless Italian mono track, its inclusion is even more cause for celebration. For anyone who's interested, below is a quick comparison I recorded. I did have to downmix the 7.1 audio, of course.

English 7.1 (Downmixed)English MonoItalian Mono

Consider the deservedly high score in the sidebar for the lossless monaural tracks, and the 7.1 remix is just a pleasant bonus. As with the initial Blu-ray release, subtitles are provided in English, Spanish, and French. This time, however, there are two English streams – SDH subs for the English audio as well as a translation of the Italian dialogue.


Extras
The New York Ripper is – like Maniac, The Stendhal Syndrome, Zombie, and Manhattan Baby before it – another of Blue Underground's three-disc limited editions. This new restoration is on display on both Blu-ray as well as an accompanying DVD, and an audio CD is lurking just behind the liner notes. Nearly all of its many extras have been produced expressly for this new edition.

  • Audio CD: The first disc in the set is a CD collecting Francesco De Masi's music from The New York Ripper. There are 29 tracks in all, and its 71 minute runtime isn't all that far off from the length of the film itself. The fidelity is nothing short of marvelous, and it's especially wonderful to hear so many alternate versions of some of these cues. The title theme, "New York...One More Day", has no fewer than six versions – some playing up the guitars and funk, another going all out with brass.

  • Audio Commentary: Troy Howarth, the author of Splintered Visions: Lucio Fulci and His Films, contributes screen-specific commentary for the director's "darkest, meanest, and most misunderstood" movie. As ever, Howarth offers a compelling blend of critical analysis, historical context, and extensive research – able to delve in-depth into the lives and filmographies of even the most negligible bit players, let alone the key members of The New York Ripper's cast and crew. To rattle off just a few of the highlights, Howarth notes that the opening severed hand gag is a nod to Yojimbo, its more grounded realism ensuring that the hyper-violence stings harder than in Fulci's more fantastic works, dispelling the notion that The New York Ripper presents these women as somehow deserving of their grisly fates, intermissions remaining a mainstay in Italy even for relatively short films such as this one, and a long list of never-produced projects to which Fulci was attached around this time. Well-worth a listen.

  • The Art of Killing (29 min.; HD): "New York Ripper is a study of breaking the territory of the body of the victim, using as a purpose [sic], not sin because it's wrong, but using sex as a target. That's why the Ripper kills women – because he's killing sex, he's killing procreation."

    The first of The New York Ripper's newly-conducted interviews is with screenwriter Dardano Sacchetti (A Bay of Blood). He discusses how, despite having fallen out with Fulci, he was tasked to fix the screenplay by Gianfranco Clerici and Vincenzo Mannino (Devil Fish) – no small feat, given that the crew would leave for New York in a week, the locations were secured, and the actors had been cast. Sacchetti delves into that daunting effort, explains the motivations behind Fulci's compulsion for sex and violence, the primal fears that he exploits in horror, and how elements of this Ripper harken back to the original in London.
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
  • Three Fingers of Violence (15 min.; HD): Actor Howard Ross (Werewolf Woman) discusses working with Fulci to realize his not-altogether-pleasant character, being mistaken for Charles Bronson on the streets of New York, opting against prosthetics for Mickey's two missing fingers, Fulci's pipe indicating how pleased he was with a take, and nearly getting choked to death with a plastic bag. It's a charming, compelling conversation, as are all of the interviews in this set.

  • The Second Victim (12 min.; HD): From being crowned Miss Italy to sneezing during a fully nude autopsy sequence, this interview with actress Cinzia de Ponti (Manhattan Baby) is anything but more of the same. Among the topics here are how de Ponti wound up with her stage name, being taught to scream during her audition, and the revelation that it's Fulci's own hand ripping her apart on-camera.

  • The Broken Bottle Murder (9 min.; SD): The first of two interviews with actress Zora Kerova has been upscaled from standard definition – the only of the newly-produced extras to be presented this way. She speaks about the frenzied sex scene with a gay, biracial co-star (who's had more of a career than she suspects), her heart beating so rapidly that her supposedly dead body looked as if it was breathing, and her subsequent collaborations with Fulci.

  • "I'm an Actress!" (10 min.; SD): This archival interview with Kerova is carried over from Blue Underground's initial Blu-ray release from a decade back. Unless I'm misunderstanding something, it's a bit at odds with her more recent interview. Here, she seems to suggest that the first time she met Fulci was on-set, while Kerova notes in the other that she and Fulci were established friends who'd bonded over their mutual passion for Russian literature. Both interviews address many of the same points, but Kerova does delve into more of her other films here – Cannibal Ferox among them – as well as detailing the backlash of such exploitative scenes from the Communist regime in her homeland of Czechoslovakia.

  • The Beauty Killer (23 min.; HD): Beyond Terror: The Films of Lucio Fulci author Stephen Thrower provides a marvelous retrospective and analysis of The New York Ripper. Thrower begins by charting the history of the project, including its origins as Beauty Killer and Ruggero Deodato (or someone with a suspiciously close name!) being attached to direct. He also explores the balance that The New York Ripper strikes between the giallo and horror, dissects its characters, and delves into its critical reception and troubled distribution. If you pick up this lavish special edition but, for whatever reason, only have time to devote to one of these extras, "The Beauty Killer" is the most essential.
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]
  • Paint Me Blood Red (17 min.; HD): For this re-release, Blue Underground commissioned new artwork from one of the true legends: Enzo Sciotti. The brilliant artist speaks about painting his first movie poster at the tender age of 16, how his process and the demands of producers have changed over the decades, and how he's able to sketch women's bodies purely by instinct. Sciotti showcases quite a bit of his phenomenal artwork, as well as telling stories about working with the likes of De Laurentiis and Fulci. We're also shown several pencil sketches for what would eventually grace the cover of this edition of The New York Ripper.

  • NYC Locations Then and Now (4 min.; HD): The second of two extras carried over from Blue Underground's initial Blu-ray release is this comparison of the New York of 1981 with now. Or, well, what qualified as now back in 2009, anyway. Care is taken to match angles and camera placement whenever possible.

  • Poster & Still Gallery (HD): With somewhere around 67 images in all, this high-res gallery showcases posters from all across the world, international video art, newspaper scans, and lobby cards.

  • Trailer (3 min.; HD): Last to bat is an English language trailer.

Enzo Sciotti's newly-commissioned artwork is also showcased on a lenticular slipcover. It doesn't convey the sort of motion or action that the Zombie covers offer, no, but it still looks fantastic. Purists can breathe easy that the cover inside is reversible.

"Paint Me Blood Red"
[click on the thumbnail to enlarge]

There's a bizarre editing error in the liner notes. Travis Crawford's "Fulci Quacks Up: The Unrelenting Grimness of The New York Ripper" has issues with words containing "fl" or "fi". So instead of, say, "film" or "aficionado", every instance is instead printed as "☒lm" and "a☒cionado". Gotta say: that's a first for me. I have what looks sure like a final retail copy; I'm unsure if this has since been corrected.

Also very much of note is that The New York Ripper is coded for all regions.


The Final Word
I've been subjected to plenty of memes floating around Facebook horror groups, grousing and groaning about Blue Underground's current streak of re-releases. If you're content with their previous edition of The New York Ripper from back in 2009, no one's holding a straight razor to your neck and forcing you to upgrade. Me...? I'm floored that the label is going to such staggering effort to craft lavish special editions of so many of their most coveted titles.

The New York Ripper doesn't just benefit from a new 4K restoration, although that alone to my mind would make it worth another go. This edition marks the first domestic home video release of the film to feature Italian audio. There's somewhere in the neighborhood of three and a half hours of extras. Blue Underground enlisted the artist behind some of the most iconic posters in Eurohorror to craft its cover art. This is an extraordinary release of a film that's irresistible to those with a taste for sticky, depraved slashers.

So, meme away. It's your loss. Highly Recommended.
Find the lowest price for 'The New York Ripper (2019 4K Remaster) (Blu-ray)'
Popular Reviews
1. The Haunting of Hill House
2. Batman Beyond: The Complete Series Deluxe Limited Edition
3. Someone Behind the Door
4. Christmas in July
5. Charley Varrick
6. The Return of Martin Guerre
7. Seven Days to Noon
8. Light of My Life
9. The Gun Runners
10. Ringu


Sponsored Links
DVD Blowouts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Alien [Blu-ray]
Buy: $19.99 $9.99
8.
9.
10.
Sponsored Links
Release List Reviews Shop Newsletter Forum DVD Giveaways Blu-Ray Advertise
Copyright 2019 All Rights Reserved. Legal Info, Privacy Policy, Terms of Use